Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich van ongeveer mijn 12e tot mijn 17e als trans identificeerde, op mijn 16e begon met testosteron voor bijna precies een jaar, en vanaf januari 2024 begon te detransitioneren nadat non-dualisme en radicaalfeministische teksten me aan gender deden twijfelen. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw omdat ik vrouwelijk ben, geloof niet in gender, en ben een lesbienne die inziet dat mijn transitie deels een poging was om van mezelf een heteroseksuele man te maken. Ik heb volledig spijt van mijn medische transitie, al ben ik gelukkig met wie ik buiten de lichamelijke veranderingen ben, en mijn adamsappel en gezakte stem waren mijn zwaarste strijd tot ik na ongeveer negen maanden mijn stem leerde accepteren. Uit de kast komen bij mijn familie was moeilijk en het is moeilijk gebleken een therapeut te vinden die mijn ervaring serieus neemt. Soms wou ik nog steeds dat ik als man was geboren en mis ik de transgemeenschap, maar ik wil niet opnieuw transitioneren en geloof dat tijd de grootste factor in genezing is.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned woman (FTMTF) who identified as trans for about five years, from roughly age 12 to 17. I started questioning my gender at 10-11 when I realized I was romantically interested in girls and wanted a short haircut. I came out as trans at 12 via an Instagram post, around the time I got my first girlfriend, a lesbian, which made me worry that if I were really a boy she wouldn't want to date me. I was very active on social media, which I believe did not help. My identity went back and forth: I came out as FTM, then spent about a year identifying as nonbinary, then FTM again for about four years. I was unsure during the first couple of years but was 100% sure of myself during the last three.
I started testosterone at 16 after about a year and a half of going through the process of getting on it, during which I was repeatedly dismissed and told I would change my mind, which only drove me to want it more. I was on T for almost exactly a year. I began detransitioning in early January 2024 because I wanted to accept my body as it was rather than change it so I would like it more. The realization that I needed to detransition took about two months. The main catalysts were getting into philosophy, specifically nondualism, which made me realize I did not want to spend the rest of my life generating an image of myself for other people's perception, and hate-reading radfem blogs on Tumblr, which I started to feel made a lot of sense. I also believe sunk-cost thinking and the difficulty of admitting I was wrong after years of insisting it was not a phase pushed me toward medical transition in the first place.
I now identify as a woman because I am female, and I do not believe in gender anymore. I still look and dress exactly the same as when I identified as trans; I do not view detransition as transitioning back but as refusing to fit myself into a gender identity. I am a lesbian. During my transition I dated both men and women; the only relationship I labeled at the time was a heterosexual one with a man I called gay, and everyone I dated was either bisexual, trans, or gender nonconforming, which kept the sexuality question from coming up. I now recognize that the term 'queer' helped obfuscate the sexuality question for me.
Physically, the hardest change has been my Adam's apple, which was already prominent before T and is now larger than those of most males my age. I feel it pull at my skin when I turn my head, cannot touch it without freaking out, can no longer lie on my stomach or wear turtlenecks. My voice dropped and I spent months voice training, recording myself daily in bursts of dysphoria, until about eight months into detransition when re-recording a Car Seat Headrest cover I had done pre-T made me realize I do not hate my voice at all and that it is simply my voice. I have not had any surgeries and I am not aware of fertility issues being raised.
Coming out about my detransition was hard. I told my immediate family but struggled with extended family, who have trouble with pronouns and are visibly uncomfortable referring to me. I came out to friends and family gradually by first discussing how my view of gender had changed. After coming out I felt I no longer had to trick people into thinking I was male or constantly monitor how I was perceived. I have struggled to find a therapist who understands that someone can want to deal with dysphoria without transitioning; several therapists short-circuit when I say transition was harmful and repeat pro-trans slogans or insist gender must be part of my identity. I am from a very progressive area of Canada and I would not want a therapist connected to conversion therapy because I am a lesbian and a big reason for my transition was trying to conversion-therapy myself into a straight man.
I deeply regret medically transitioning and hate everything it has done to me, though outside the physical aspect I am happy with who I am today and am ambivalent about whether I would be who I am without it. I feel sad for the 12-year-old girl who was given repression as a solution and grieve the years lost to self-hatred. I still sometimes wish I had been born male but have no desire to retransition, and I miss the community and kinship of the trans/FTM world. I feel I do not belong anywhere, particularly in sex-segregated spaces like bathrooms, where I fear making other women uncomfortable but never passed enough to feel safe in the men's room. Around nine months off T I stopped caring about shaving, voice training, and trying to pass as female, and I believe time is the most important factor in healing. I have shared a detransition playlist ordered by the stages of grief and acceptance I have gone through.