Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik begon op mijn 19e te transitioneren, leefde als vrouw, nam vanaf 2016 oestrogeen en anti-androgenen en kreeg in 2017 een vaginoplastiek in het VUmc Amsterdam. Ik heb me sindsdien weer als man geïdentificeerd en ben gendercritisch geworden, maar ik ben niet van plan te detransitioneren omdat de operatie onomkeerbaar is en ik levenslang oestrogeen gebruik; mentaal detransitioneerde ik terwijl ik lichamelijk in mijn getransitioneerde vorm blijf leven. Ik heb spijt van de verloren jaren en onomkeerbare lichamelijke veranderingen en beschrijf transitie als een verslaving en mijn lichaam als geruïneerd, al heb ik intense zelfhaat overwonnen en is mijn mentale gezondheid relatief goed. Ik pleit nu actief tegen transitie, dring erop aan dat het een laatste redmiddel is en waarschuw jonge mensen mijn pad niet te volgen. Ik ben een postoperatieve man-naar-vrouwtranssekseel persoon die zich weer als man identificeert en niet van plan is te detransitioneren.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and had always been same-sex attracted, always feeling more in touch with women than men. From a young age I put everything feminine on a pedestal, imagining myself looking like the pretty women in magazines, chick flicks and soaps, and I was jealous of the popular, pretty girls in high school. Around 2012 I was struck by Jenna Talackova, a transgender woman allowed to compete in Miss Universe again after a disqualification; I remember being blinded by her beauty and desperately wanting to be her. I was also motivated to become a woman because of the attention I would get from straight men — the men I wanted to attract were attracted to women, so by becoming a woman I thought I could attract them. My dysphoria was also fueled by the social roles put on men and women; I didn't fit the men's role and never would. I hated how men looked and didn't want to look masculine — I wanted soft skin, to be pretty rather than handsome, gracious and sophisticated like a woman.
In 2014 I applied to the gender team in Amsterdam (VUMC). I waited almost a year for my first psychiatric assessment; a year later I began mandatory cross-living (real life experience at the end of 2015) and was cleared for hormone therapy. I started HRT (estrogen and anti-androgens) in 2016, and 18 months later, in 2017, I received vaginoplasty (SRS) performed by Dr. Marlon Buncamper. Regret was not really discussed during my treatment. Vaginoplasty was heavily promoted over orchiectomy, and both the surgeon and the psychologist told me I would receive a vagina nearly indistinguishable from a natal vagina. I was told dilation would not be a lifelong commitment and could be replaced by intercourse after a year of healing. Doctors never mentioned sex-change regret; I was told being trans is a neuroendocrine problem unrelated to paraphilia when I briefly mentioned AGP transsexuals, and that satisfaction rates among SRS patients were higher than among patients treated for bone fractures. Regretters were simply not acknowledged. The gender team worked like a factory, prioritizing throughput; there was no real follow-up — the gender team and the mental health ward kept sending me back and forth.
About two years after surgery I began to discover what I called the current trans rage and how trans activists misrepresented things. I re-identified as male on my own terms after seeing how differently gender dysphoria is presented by researchers and activists, and after having seen literally tons of trans people who were not helped by transitioning — their mental health still earth-shattering afterward. I am almost 3 years post-op and I do realize I'm not a real woman; that feeling didn't go away after surgery. The feeling of being wrong remains after medical treatment. Men might be okay having sex with me so long as no one knows, but they will never want to be seen with me or be in a relationship. The only people left to begin relationships with are other trans women, and you stay stuck in transitional thoughts because acknowledging gender critical views might push away the last people associated with you.
I stopped caring about gender altogether; it's meaningless to me now. I missed out on valuable years I could have spent on something other than what I called an addiction. I have re-identified as a male but have no plans for a future detransition because I believe detransition is impossible in my case — gender reassignment surgery can never be undone, I would be even more atypical as a guy with a surgically created cavity than as a trans woman with one, and I would be stuck on unnatural hormone supplies either way. I'm still taking estrogen. I use women's bathrooms and people use female pronouns because I look enough like a woman for them not to realize I'm a medicalized male, but I no longer believe in pronouns, bathroom bills, or passing. I describe myself as a post-operative male-to-female transsexual person who is gender critical and has no plans to detransition: mentally I detransitioned, physically the harm has been done.
Medically, I still have to dilate contrary to what I was told. Sensation in the cavity is not magical; it's a surgically rearranged penis, not a vulva or vagina. I have sensation and I'm pain free, but my bladder is not the same — I regularly feel like I'm holding urine even after just having peed. Orgasm is possible but is a less intensive version of the orgasm I had with a penis, mostly mental; I reject claims of mythical full-body orgasms on both sides. Nerves are damaged; my body never had the same sensation after what I call that traumatic surgery.
Mentally, my health is relatively good despite going through something I consider so unnatural. I overcame intense self-hate — hating myself when I realized how terrible what I had done to my body was — by focusing on the good I can still do, realizing how much love I still have to give, and connecting with that love. I was 19 when I started and 25 at that point, and I felt I had already ruined my body in a way worse than smoking for 50 years. I don't dwell on the past because it's not productive. I don't describe ongoing suicidal ideation for myself.
I now advocate strongly against transition whenever another option exists, telling people transition should be a last resort, not a first one. I warn young people — including an 18-year-old female considering T and a young butch lesbian — not to fall into the same trap, telling them their sex cannot be undone and that unhappiness with gender must be overcome mentally rather than medically. I see transsexuality and transgenderism as a mental illness rather than an inborn biological defect, and I say changing sexes is impossible for a human being. I advise staying far away from trans adults who give medical advice. I also try to give balanced accounts of SRS results, criticizing both gender-critical exaggeration and trans-activist claims. I encourage a person one year into HRT with no surgeries that they can still go back, and I describe the 2010s–2020s medical system as encouraging what I call sex amputation as treatment for self-hate.