Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik desisteerde van het leven als transpersoon en leef nu als een man die zich niet met mannelijkheid identificeert, nadat ik besefte dat gendercategorieën willekeurig zijn en dat versiering zoals make-up en lang haar normaal is, ongeacht sekse. Al mijn haar afknippen als androgyn ogende man hielp me me gezien te voelen voor mezelf in plaats van voor genderverwachtingen, en de klachten van iemand anders over vrouw zijn waren wat me uiteindelijk deed desisteren. Ik steun detransitie en pleit voor beter ouderschap, voorzichtiger artsen en goede therapie vóór ingrijpende beslissingen, terwijl ik geloof dat medische transitie niet moreel verkeerd is maar veel meer voorzichtigheid vraagt dan nu wordt aanbevolen. Ik richt me op statistieken, geloof dat detransitioners ondervertegenwoordigd zijn en hoop dat detrans een grotere stem wordt in de LGBTQ-gemeenschap. Ik ben een gedesisteerde man die nu als man leeft.
Volledig verhaal
I desisted, and I describe myself as pro-detransition because I have desisted. I was born male and I now live as a man, though I've never felt like a "manly male" — I like some boyish things like video games and superhero stuff, but I've never related to the title of manhood.
What helped me desist was realizing that both male and female are, in my words, "nothing more than monkeys" — we're "monkeys on a rock with no rhyme or reason for being here." That framing took the weight off gender for me. I also found it freeing to recognize that adornment — makeup, long hair, clothing — is normal and has been throughout human history across cultures, including cultures with "two-spirited" people who managed without medically transitioning. I noted that we only see the positive outcomes of those traditions in front of us now.
A concrete step I took was cutting all my hair off. As a man who looks somewhat androgynous — so much so that I get called "mam" more when I'm bald — going bald threw me into "a realm removed from the genders." It felt like I was being seen for me instead of the expectations of me. I also wore some women's clothing, the kind that could pass for anyone's clothes but is technically women's. I described this as accepting being a "failed male" AND a "failed woman" so that I could just be me. I acknowledged this approach may not work for everyone, especially since baldness is more normalized for men.
I also said that another person's gripes with being a woman are what made me desist — I realized each side has its problems, and that's what people mean when they say life sucks: too many rules and people treating you based on those rules. "It's hell."
On transition generally, I take a nuanced position. I don't think medical transition is intrinsically or morally bad, but I think it demands "A LOT of caution (a lot more than they recommend)" because if it doesn't go how you like, your life may feel more miserable — which is why it's more suitable to try to like your body first. I advise people considering transition to really unpack why they want it, whether they can achieve what they want without it, and whether they're willing to deal with how hard detransitioning might be if that time comes. I don't encourage anything beyond that deep self-examination. I've said some people transition in their 20s, have a fun youthful decade, then eventually detransition without regretting it because they're grateful for that time and now focus on cleaning up what they did.
I focus on statistics when discussing detransition, and I believe detransitioners are highly underrepresented even though many trans people genuinely prefer to be trans — so much so that many detransitioners return to transition. I compare medical transition to other body-modification choices people make, like BBLs and facelifts, which aren't the healthiest decisions but are personal choices. I think people end up feeling tricked when they go through with something without proper discernment. I believe the only things detransitioners should fight for are better parenting, more cautious doctors, and ensuring grown adults get proper therapy before making life-altering decisions. I also think the wording around who "needs" to transition needs to be fixed.
I'm critical of what I see as bitterness in some detransitioners who treat trans representation as a boogeyman — I've called that "unserious and reminiscent of racist behavior." I believe representation works by being seen, and that different lifestyles get promoted and it's up to individuals to recognize whether a lifestyle is for them. I'm supportive of detransitioners' stories being heard to aid decision-making, and I hope detrans becomes a bigger voice in the LGBTQ community.
I have sympathy for people with dysphoria and body-image issues — I've said dysmorphic issues "are no joke. It's why we're all here," and that it never hurts to give affirmation people are seeking. I've also been blunt with others in the community, pushing back when I feel people are being rude or closed to conversation, and I've told someone that if their friends drop them for changing identity back to something comfortable, "that was never friendship."
I've dealt with identity issues myself and believe many people in similar situations have identity issues that are being misdiagnosed, pointing to horrible healthcare systems. I've asked a still-transitioning person why they were in the detrans subreddit rather than the trans one, since it seemed they wanted to continue being trans. I also asked about electrolysis for permanent hair removal and noted that males on estrogen develop more breast tissue than typical males, increasing breast cancer risk to roughly that of a female with breast tissue.
On masculinity, I'd advise someone to stop trying to achieve "manhood" or "manliness" — I called it "such a empty title that, if you dont relate to, hurts the more you try to fit into it."