Alle verhalen

Een non-binaire identiteit die de stereotypen versterkte waaraan ze wilde ontsnappen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,2K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die me als tiener een paar jaar identificeerde als non-binair/agender en hen/hun-voornaamwoorden gebruikte, maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Mijn identificatie groeide uit een streng, emotioneel kwetsend en anti-lhbtq gezin, uitsluiting op school omdat ik genderniet-conform was, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, angst voor seksualisering en onbehagen over de puberteit, alles gekanaliseerd door online lhbtq-gemeenschappen die me kritiekloos bevestigden. Ik detransitioneerde door zelfreflectie, gendercritische en detransitioner-media, en door te beseffen dat een non-binaire identiteit juist de stereotypen versterkte waaraan ik wilde ontsnappen; accepteren dat vrouw zijn me niet beperkt, loste mijn onbehagen op. Sindsdien heb ik vrouwelijkheid omarmd, maar ik ben biseksueel en ben diep eenzaam geworden nadat ik afstand nam van progressieve queer vrienden die geschokt reageerden toen ik twijfels over transitie uitte. Ik heb in het verleden suïcidale gevoelens gehad en heb nu een kritische maar genuanceerde kijk op transitie: ik steun haar alleen als laatste redmiddel bij ernstige dysforie en ben tegen het aanmoedigen ervan bij minderjarigen.

Volledig verhaal

I identified as non-binary (and later agender) for a few years during my teens, using they/them pronouns, and never medically transitioned. I grew up in a conservative household in a rather conservative country where my parents were emotionally absent and emotionally abusive, putting me down from as early as I could understand words, which destroyed my self-esteem. They hated anything LGBTQ, saw it as disgusting and unnatural, and were very strict about gender roles, frequently telling me 'you're a girl so you can't do this' and 'you're a girl so you have to do this'. I didn't fit in with the other girly girls and got excluded by my peers at school for being boyish and eccentric, and I fit in better with the rowdy boys. I hated being perceived as a girl because of the inherent expectations and power dynamics attached to it — I wanted to be rough and dirty, not have to sit with my legs closed, and I resented teachers cutting girls slack in physical activities as if we were weaker. I wanted to be a strong, respected boy rather than a meek, fragile girl; it felt far more acceptable to be an ugly boy than an ugly girl. I also hated the sexualisation that came with being a girl. I never questioned my gender until someone told me I could be something other than a girl; if I'd been told at ten that I could escape being pretty and proper by becoming a boy, I would have accepted it in a heartbeat. When I heard of non-binary, it felt like the answer — a way to escape gender stereotypes without doing anything about them. I started out as an ally and gradually warmed to the label. My they/them pronouns gave me 'euphoria' and validation from friends, which I took as proof I wasn't a girl. In reality, adopting the identity only reinforced the stereotypes I was trying to escape: I actively went against stereotypes, which was still living by them. I got out of one prison only to land in another I had constructed myself. I also felt deep discomfort with my body at the onset of puberty — developing breasts and getting my first period — which I took as undeniable proof I wasn't a normal girl. I was deep into LGBTQ activism and supporting 'trans kids' at the time. What changed things was hearing stories of older women and detransitioners, and studies and videos showing that body discomfort during puberty is common among girls and usually fades with maturity. I did a lot of soul searching and watched gender-critical and detransitioner videos, which made sense to me: if I took masculine behaviour as proof I wasn't female, didn't that mean females can't act feminine? I also came to see that the community's emphasis on 'validity' was a form of control — I used to run to my friends after every little problem just to hear them affirm me, which made me fragile, unhappy and codependent. I also recognised the manipulative claim that 'we accept you, your family doesn't, so we're your real family'. I realised the harm of unconditional affirmation: being happy with they/them pronouns was proof I was unhappy with myself, and if my friends had kept affirming me I would have lived a very miserable life in denial. I came to the conclusion that there is no such thing as non-binary — it is an unhealthy escape for gender nonconforming people or those with unresolved mental troubles, built on stereotypes. Understanding that my discomfort stemmed from deep-rooted misogyny and stereotypes ingrained by my upbringing was the key to dropping every false label; the second I understood being a woman shouldn't define my identity, the discomfort gradually went away. I never had any irreversible changes, and I am thankful I realised before going too deep. Since detransitioning I have embraced femininity — I now wear dresses, own things in light pink, which I can finally admit is my favourite colour, and love feminine jewellery and nail designs, having previously refused skirts and anything that wasn't near-black. I am bisexual. I have not tried spirituality and have no intention to. I have struggled with the social fallout: my friends are very progressive and queer, and when I hinted I was not fully supportive of gender transition I saw shock and disgust on their faces, so I distanced myself rather than risk losing the friendships. I now avoid the topic of LGBTQ with peers and stay silent when it comes up, and I have drifted from many friends. This has left me feeling intensely lonely and alienated, surrounded by peers who will affirm almost anything except doubt. I also feel guilty for not speaking up, fearing friends might one day undergo irreversible surgeries they regret. I have had suicidal feelings in the past — I have nearly killed myself many times before, though under different circumstances than the person I was speaking to. I now hold nuanced views: I believe gender dysphoria is real and that transition can be a legitimate last-resort treatment for severe cases, but I abhor how widely 'transgender' has been expanded, how it is marketed as a miracle cure for insecurities, and any involvement of minors. I consider myself a (non-denominational) Christian. I have advocated for detransition awareness online, encouraged others not to make permanent changes while in doubt, and supported legislation restricting gender transition for minors.