Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I want to tell my story as best I can, though my transition was fairly private — school staff and family knew about it, and a few friends did too, but I was never publicly out. All of it happened in a very brief stretch of my life; the transition was brief, though the dysphoria itself was not. I can't explain why my dysphoria eventually went away, but I do want to explain where my headspace was at the time.
I grew up being told I could have any hobby, like anything, do anything, wear anything. By my own account, I only got dysphoria when 'tumbloids came out of the woodwork' telling me I couldn't do 'girl stuff' unless I changed my body. I drew a heart in a binder once when I was 8 — and I've mocked the idea that a childhood gesture like that means someone needs to castrate themselves. When I decided to transition, it felt like a choice about what to do with my body, not something I felt compelled into. I never felt like I was making a spiritual leap into some mantle of manhood; I've since come to reject the whole notion that there is such a thing as manhood or womanhood as spiritual categories.
What first made me disillusioned with the LGBT community was the insistence that being LGBT is not a choice — or rather, that there must be only one cause for it. I began reading studies rejected by the community and noticed patterns. One study, the Universe 25 mouse experiment, struck me: when population gets out of control, odd self-destructive behaviors emerge, including homosexuality. I developed my own theory — that deviant sexual behaviors are a biological barrier against negative behavioral evolution in a group, an instinct to 'self neuter' to prevent the passing on of abusive or destructive behavior. I came to view homosexuality and other LGBT identities as oddly beautiful, a way for people to keep existing despite their trauma. I've been careful to say this is one of a dozen ideas I have, not a single explanation.
At the same time I was losing my dysphoria, I began to view transition as a healthier alternative for some people, but not the only alternative. I don't know if losing my dysphoria was connected to these musings. I later theorized that what happened to me was something I call 'toxic sympathy' or 'toxic empathy' — our brains are hardwired to mirror other people's emotions, and I suspect I picked up dysphoric or LGBT feelings from the distress of people around me; once society became more accepting, the reason for those sympathetic feelings vanished. I've said explicitly that I don't think this was necessarily the source of my dysphoria, but it's my best guess.
I never had surgery and I never publicly transitioned, so there are no surgical complications or fertility losses on my own body to report — but the question of sterilization has become the single issue I care most about. I have come to believe that essentially every form of bottom surgery sterilizes people, that it serves no functional purpose, and that the procedures were designed by eugenicists to sterilize people society considers mentally ill while placating them. I've written repeatedly that 'sterility is the goal... not a side effect,' and that bottom surgery is 'a scam that exists to castrate people considered mentally ill, and to make a buck while doing it.' I tell anyone who asks me for transition advice, in the strongest terms I can muster, not to get bottom surgery under any circumstances. I do still believe genuine trans people exist and have a right to transition — I've said 'I am actually pro trans' — and I've argued against banning transition outright, while supporting bans on bottom surgery specifically.
On mental health, I've framed gender dysphoria as often a symptom of something else — anxiety, depression, OCD, trauma, PTSD, bipolar, dissociative disorders — where a person under distress hunts for a cause and lands on 'eureka, that's why I'm sad.' I've argued that no mental health professional should suggest transition until every other potential cause has been ruled out, and that regular therapy plus antidepressants or anti-anxiety medication is a valid course of action. I've said that hormones often alleviate dysphoria the way a sugar pill cures a hypochondriac's headache — essentially a placebo. I've also observed, from friends who are trans and pass well, that 'transitioning seems to rarely actually alleviate dysphoria.'
I've also described how puberty education, especially for girls, primes young women to be horrified at their own bodies, and I've argued that this feeds body dysphoria. I've distinguished sharply between body dysphoria and gender dysphoria, telling people that if their 'dysphoria' is about not being feminine enough, or about hobbies and clothes, that puts 'the nail in the you-are-trans coffin.'
Sexuality has been a recurring theme for me. I've argued that the LGBT community's insistence that sexuality is fixed at birth actively prevents people from exploring it, and I've asked 'what if one day I am just gay? and wasnt before? why isnt that allowed?' I've suggested to confused people that they may simply be attracted to the gender they want to be, and that people confuse 'being attracted to something' with 'wanting to be that something' — a confusion I attribute partly to anime and hentai consumption. I've been blunt that a lot of trans women online seem to be 'trying to life out a cosplay of female anime children,' and that many trans-identified people 'dont want to be women, they want to be girls.' I've also argued that switching primary hormones can flip attraction, based on what I've seen in others.
I've been open about my own sexuality in passing — I've given advice about exploring sex beyond conventional roles, saying 'You can top as receiver, and you can definitely do it with your butt... source: done it.' I've argued strenuously against the top/bottom dichotomy as a harmful import. I've also noted that I've been told I'm 'fantastically handsome,' and I've complimented others in return.
In terms of what moved me away from transition, it wasn't a single dramatic event. My dysphoria simply faded as I developed these frameworks — reading rejected studies, developing my 'toxic sympathy' theory, and coming to see gender roles as a scam. I've said I never was publicly out, so detransition for me was quiet: I stopped identifying that way and returned to living as a man. I've described myself plainly: 'Im just a man.' I don't report a dramatic mental health crisis after detransition, but I've said that when you stop feeding a source of mental health problems — validating and exacerbating your own worst feelings — 'its not weird that you would have less mental health problems in general.'
I have no stated regrets about hormones or surgeries on my own body, because as far as my posts go, I don't describe having had them. What I do express, intensely and repeatedly, is anger: at the medical establishment, at what I see as a eugenic project dressed up as care, at the 'egg' culture that tries to convince gender-nonconforming people they're trans, at the conflation of attraction with desire to become, and at a movement I believe fetishizes women and lesbians. I've said I'm 'real, REAL fucking tired of the trans community hijacking intersex people,' and I've written a post begging people to stop using intersex to describe themselves.
I've also written a long post about what I call 'Zoomerllenial Astrology' and a post arguing that there is 'a whole movement, dedicated to telling people they are disgusting' — that dysphoria is 'nurtured by the people in the Transgender movement, like it is a delicate and precious flower.' I've advocated for therapy first, for exploring gender nonconformity without changing sex, and for people to simply do what they want without needing permission. I've told people considering transition to take their time, saying the average time for detransitioners to realize they messed up is 'about 5-7 years,' and that I'll respect them whatever they decide.
I've done some advocacy in the form of forum posts — including a widely upvoted post begging the trans community to stop using intersex people as validation, and my vent post about astrology-style thinking. I've also been combative when I feel someone is posting in bad faith, including accusing someone of posting a fake story to make detransitioners look bad. Overall I'd say I'm critical but not opposed to transition in principle: I think genuine dysphoria that is the root issue, not a symptom, is legitimate grounds to transition — just never with bottom surgery.