Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man, als man geboren, die nooit lichamelijk is getransitioneerd maar in 2020 dichtbij genoeg kwam om het telefoonnummer van een kliniek klaar te hebben om te bellen. Onbehandelde psychische ziekte, baanverlies, een break-up en onderdompeling in trans-zware online ruimtes zorgden voor snel opkomende genderdysforie die verdween toen de stress wegtrok. Mijn toenmalige vriend hield me van hormonen af door wetenschappelijke literatuur met me te delen. Ik identificeerde me een tijdlang als non-binair en identificeer me nu als mijn geboortesekse, man, met een wat androgyne presentatie. Ik ben uitgesproken kritisch over de medicalisering van genderdysforie, vooral bij minderjarigen, terwijl ik probeer te voorkomen dat detransgemeenschappen echokamers worden.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and, as far as my own account goes, I never physically transitioned — no cross-sex hormones, no surgery, no puberty blockers. My whole story is about coming very close to medical transition and then stepping back.
The first sign something was off came in 2020. I entered several online communities with a huge trans presence and started exploring my gender. At the same time I lost a job I'd held for five years and went through my first gay relationship, and all of that stress piled up. I also had some undiagnosed mental illness and serious life stress going on. I described it later as rapid-onset gender dysphoria: no childhood indicators, just a sudden anxiety about whether I was trans. I went looking for answers in trans circles online, and what I found there was, in my words, "deeply confirmatory." I ended up genuinely believing I was trans and I had the name and phone number of the clinic I planned to call to start hormone replacement.
What stopped me was my boyfriend at the time. He opposed my transition and referred me to scientific literature. Reading it opened my eyes: a lot of the commonly cited "numbers" around transition aren't great — for instance the widely repeated claim that half of untreated trans people become suicidal is, I believe, bunk, based on an online study asking teens if they "felt suicidal." I realized trans spaces can be an absolute echo chamber. I've said plainly that if my boyfriend had been as "be your best self" as an earlier partner, I probably would have started hormones. I credit my ex-boyfriend for keeping me off HRT.
What I now understand about my own motivation: I wanted to transition because I felt out of place. I'm quiet and introverted, and I hoped transition would win me acceptance. I also thought it would be easier to change my gender than to fix my social skills and crippling insecurity. Guys are expected to be strong, aggressive, and gregarious; a quiet, attractive guy reads as unapproachable, whereas a quiet, attractive girl is sought out — or so I told myself. I felt I didn't fit the male mold. There was also an element of escapism: you only escape one set of problems and get a new set. I'd rationalized that I'd dress more feminine once I looked more feminine on HRT, but as femme as I felt I could never bring myself to wear women's clothing because it looked stupid on my body. I spent serious time on egg_irl and my mental health went "in the shitter" — by that community's definitions everyone is trans in denial.
Once the acute stress cleared up and my mental health improved, the desire to assume a new identity left completely. I went through a period identifying as non-binary (living as a non-binary person born male), and I spent time in the detrans Discord where, as a non-binary-identifying person, I caught flack and was shamed by a moderator who told me I might go on hormones at any moment — even though I never took cross-sex hormones. Eventually I stopped identifying as non-binary and now identify as my birth sex, male.
Currently I let myself be feminine sometimes in a male body, wearing androgynous clothes. That feels right enough, and no one can say anything to me. I've had therapy-adjacent input mainly in the form of my boyfriend's literature and my own reading rather than formal treatment.
On the broader question I'm quite outspoken. I think medical transition has gone from a medical procedure to an ideology. I distinguish sharply between "affirming" (acknowledging someone's feelings) and "confirming" (telling someone that because they feel X they *are* X), and I argue confirming needs great care when identity and irreversible medical procedures are involved. I'm critical of patient-led care for minors, of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for children, of social contagion and peer influence in gender dysphoria, of egg_irl-style communities, and of the way doctors and psychiatrists who raise concerns get labeled transphobic and lose their jobs. I compare gender dysphoria's social-influence component to eating disorders and note it's more likely if a person has trans peers. I also think modern gender politics has reinvented oddly strict gender roles, and that people pressuring others about their bodies is unacceptable. At the same time I don't want detrans spaces to become an echo chamber of their own and have argued for letting trans people listen and contribute here. I've been critical of some trans activism while also saying trans people aren't wild dogs and deserve not to face bigotry. I don't regret any specific medical procedure since I had none; my main regret is how close I came and how much time and mental energy the whole episode consumed.