Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich van mijn 13e tot mijn 23e als trans identificeerde, op mijn 14e met puberteitsremmers begon en op mijn 15e met testosteron, en op mijn 23e na bijna zeven jaar met T stopte. Ik ervoer intens verdriet en spijt en was soms overtuigd dat ik er een eind aan zou maken, maar ik kwam door die donkere plek heen en blijf werken aan mezelf accepteren. Mijn lichaam heeft veel blijvende veranderingen door T, en ik onderging FFS en elektrolyse om een deel ervan aan te pakken. Ik zie transgenderisme nu kritisch als een ideologie die voortkomt uit onderliggende psychische problemen, terwijl ik individuen wel respecteer. Op dit moment worstel ik soms nog met mijn uiterlijk en ervoor aangezien worden een man te zijn, maar de wanhoop is minder intens dan vroeger en ik probeer vooruit te komen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female, and my gender dysphoria started when I was about six years old - but it wasn't about the body I had then, it was about the female puberty I knew lay ahead. The thought that female puberty would change my body one day made me cry a lot. As a child I also disliked feminine clothes; my mother always 'forced' me to wear female clothes because she thought I'd look cute and feminine in them, but I hated them and just wanted to feel comfortable in gender-neutral or 'boyish' clothes. At some point I just gave in and stopped complaining - a small act of suppressing myself to make other people happy.
I identified as trans from ages 13 to 23. I started puberty blockers at 14, when I was only at Tanner stage 3 and female puberty had barely begun. My endocrinologist's report from about ten years ago noted it was opportune to start blockers because I was only at the start of puberty and my body hadn't developed much. First doubts came up when I started blockers, but I wouldn't listen to them - partly because blockers already changed my appearance to a degree where I felt uncomfortable and thought there was no going back, that I had to move on. I also felt more depressed, more confused and in despair when I started blockers, which led me to seek answers more desperately and find them in moving forward with transition. Then a recurring dream appeared about every six months in which I sat in front of a mirror, looking at myself with long hair, as a girl again, and happy. It took me ten years to start listening to myself and escape that unhealthy mindset.
I never really wanted to be a boy; I just couldn't see myself becoming a woman. I now understand that the 'transgender thing' was never something natural for me, but developed intense body dysphoria in early childhood which, with other things, led me to believe I was transgender. I was insecure, felt unworthy, always felt different, confused and overwhelmed. There were things people said to me and things I experienced as a child that had a big impact on me fearing puberty and hating living socially as a woman. I couldn't stand myself back then and needed an escape - and it worked for quite a while, especially because testosterone helped with body and gender dysphoria.
I was on testosterone for nearly seven years, from age 15 to 23, after starting blockers at 14. I stopped testosterone around age 22. I stopped T in mid-2021; by May 2022 I was exactly one year without T, and by July 2022 I was off for 14 months. Changes came back partly: skin texture softened faster than I expected, fat redistribution happened, and people started questioning my sex rather than assuming. A year before April 2022 nobody would have thought I was born a girl; by then nearly everyone questioned it without reaching a conclusion. But my nose and Adam's apple won't shrink again, and my upper body, shoulders, arms and back remain prominent. My voice was deeper than most biological males my age; I voice train when alone and am constantly aware of how it sounds, and on the phone I'm now often called a woman, though it's still not where I want it to be.
The last few years were intense: during lockdown a lot of emotions I'd buried came up. I was pretty isolated, pretty depressed, started meditation and had a few 'crazy experiences', changed my diet after developing a chronic illness (which also changed me mentally), and kept asking myself what I really want in life. Realizing I'd lived a 'lie' for about ten years and had altered many parts of my body forever was extremely tough. There were days I just wanted to end everything, and regret was unbearable some days.
I had an appointment with a facial feminization surgery surgeon and scheduled FFS for September 2022 to reduce some of the effects T had on my face - particularly reducing the Adam's apple and having my nose 'fixed'. I also had a few electrolysis sessions on my face for beard shadow but need to continue; there's still a lot of hair. I recommended electrolysis to others as permanent, unlike laser.
I work at a restaurant, which I really like, but after quitting T it became exhausting because nearly everyone comments on or questions my gender over the course of an evening. People call me a boy most of the time; sometimes one table uses different pronouns for me in the same evening. I told my coworkers I made a mistake with transitioning and they respect me, though they still don't see me as female, which hurts. I haven't yet told people I want to be called by a different name and pronouns again because I fear it will be weird for everyone. I spend my days in the forest with my dog, who doesn't care about my Adam's apple, and I like being alone.
Around October 2022 I reached a point where I felt completely lost and desperate and was convinced I would end everything; I somehow managed to get out of that dark place. I decided to upload a YouTube video about my changing perspectives, which helped me and others. By mid-2023 I said it got much better over the previous months and the intensity of despair was not as bad as it used to be, though grief and remorse remained. By January 2024, approaching three years off T, I was still struggling with my masculine appearance and asked other detrans women how they cope, accept their past, handle names/pronouns, and manage romantic partners and intimacy.
I now think transgenderism is an ideology rather than something you're born with, that it develops from underlying psychological issues, and that transition can be a solution but it's better to work through those underlying issues. I'm angry and sad about 'transgender ideology' and it hurts to see depressed young girls binding their chests. I still accept trans-identifying people but believe you have to be honest with yourself, and I'm especially concerned about children. I want detrans people to be visible and want people to know what this ideology can do. I also acknowledge I don't have all the answers and remain confused about what's right.