Alle verhalen

Een Tumblr-fase, daarna jaren van twijfel — en geen medische stappen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd279
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw — vrouw geboren, nooit medisch getransitioneerd, die al vóór 2021 twijfelde aan gender en een ‘maandenlange tumblr-radfem-fase vlak voor de transitie’ had. Ik geloof niet meer in trans- of non-binaire identiteitskaders en beschrijf mezelf gewoon als ‘een vrouwelijk wezen / vrouw in biologische zin’ die zowel de vrouwelijkheid als de mannelijkheid afwijst waar ik me niet prettig bij voel. Ik sta kritisch tegenover transitie en wijs mensen die erover nadenken vaak op ouder worden, passing en de gevolgen op lange termijn. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen ondergaan, geen spijt over operaties of hormonen en geen geestelijke gezondheidscrises te melden. Ik blijf ondersteunend en vriendelijk tegenover detransitioners en desisters.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and I've never really had a dramatic story to tell about it — no surgeries, no hormones, no formal transition. What I did have was a period where I seriously questioned all of that, and I've spent the years since thinking hard about it. Back in 2019 I was reading up on differences of sex development — androgen insensitivity syndrome, congenital adrenal hyperplasia — trying to understand how sex actually works biologically. That kind of reading shaped how I think about the topic to this day. By December 2021 I was already skeptical of certain claims I'd seen online, replying flatly that something was 'impossible, unless you include MTF lesbians and lesbians who date MTF.' A few days later I admitted to having had 'a months-long tumblr radfem phase right before transitioning' — that's the closest I've come to naming a timeline for my own questioning. Someone asked me to expand on it and I never did in this record. In early 2022 I was spending a lot of time in threads with people who were considering transition, and I found myself pushing back on them rather than encouraging them. I asked one person their age, and then asked a question I clearly thought was important: what do you plan to do when you're in your 50s or 60s, when the probability is you'll be less attractive than you are now? I told another person directly that they seemed very concerned about how other people perceive them, that unless they had money or already had a very stereotypically feminine face and body they probably wouldn't pass 100%, and I pressed them with a series of questions: can you imagine going on dates as a trans woman? Getting married? Having children? Do you imagine yourself in your 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s as a trans woman? Are you ready for that age not to pass as a woman? I wasn't cruel about it, but I was blunt. I also asked pointed questions about identity itself — 'how does a lesbian feel like?', 'how does a transgender person feel?' — because I genuinely don't think feelings are a reliable guide to these categories. On clothes I was consistent: there are no women's clothes or men's clothes, just clothes stereotypically worn by one or the other, and everyone should dress however they want. But I kept pushing people to examine why they feel comfortable a certain way. By August 2022 I said it plainly: 'no, i dont belive in trans stuff or nonbinary anymore.' I added that I'd still be friends with AFAB people who are 'in this thing,' but that I wouldn't date them, comparing it to not dating a hardcore religious person who doesn't share my important values. I told one commenter their comment was misogynistic, that transitioning to a girl won't get them what they think it will, and that they seemed to notice the abuse women suffer and were trying to avoid it — 'but you dont need to avoid anything since you are amab.' In October 2022 I described where I've landed: 'I don't have one, I'm just a female / woman in the bio sense, I don't engage on the parts of feminity that make me uncomfortable, the same with masculinity.' That's really my position — I don't perform femininity I dislike, and I don't perform masculinity either. I'm just female. In January 2023 I explicitly identified myself: 'i m a desister so my opinion may not be what you are looking for.' I talked about how some detransitioners seem to want to compensate for masculine characteristics they got from testosterone or surgery with a more stereotypically feminine way of dressing, acting, and living — especially new detrans or desister people — and that they don't want to be confused with men or trans people. I said it's hard to find a balance between dressing the way you want and being perceived as a woman, that it's a balancing act, and that people who detransition now aren't the same as people who detransitioned 10 years ago. In February 2024 I said nonbinary is 'someone who does not identify as exclusively a man or a woman' but added that personally I don't believe in 'identifying' with anything, so the concept is useless to me. I told someone else that while I saw where they were coming from, my conclusion was different: I don't want to be put in 'the other category' when my feelings are common and usual for a female living in a sexist world, and I think the group will be better off in the long term getting rid of the boxes altogether — though as an individual you should always do what's best for you. I've also been supportive when it seemed warranted — telling someone their face just looked more adult-like after losing baby fat, and in September 2025 telling a detransitioned woman that if I saw her I'd do a double take 'not because you look like a guy, but because you are a one gorgeus woman,' and suggesting voice training if her voice was the issue. I don't have a story of medical intervention or regret because I never medically transitioned. What I have is a questioning period before 2021, a 'radfem phase' on Tumblr, and a slow arrival at a position I hold now: I'm a female woman who doesn't believe in gender identity as a framework, who is critical of transition as it's currently offered, and who still treats detransitioners and desisters with warmth.