Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben therapeut en klinisch directeur van het Gender Harmony Institute in Utah, waar ik werk met mensen die twijfelen aan hun gender of gedesisteerd/gedetransitioneerd zijn, en ik nodig gedetransitioneerde mensen uit om hun verhaal te delen op therapeutenconferenties. Persoonlijk heb ik af en toe nog steeds het verlangen een vrouw te zijn, wat ik koppel aan depressie, schaamte en AGP, en ik heb gewerkt aan het accepteren van mezelf als simpelweg ‘een kerel’ in plaats van een ‘feminiene kerel’. Ik ben kritisch over bevestigende druk, zie termen als deadnaming en misgenderen als controle, en geloof dat transitie de onderliggende problemen die dysforie voeden niet aanpakt. Ik heb zelf geen medische transitie beschreven, en mijn huidige identiteit is die van een gedetransitioneerde/desisterende man die professioneel in dit veld werkt.
Volledig verhaal
I am a therapist and the Clinical Director of the Gender Harmony Institute, a practice my colleagues and I started to help people who are questioning their gender or who have desisted or detransitioned. I can only do therapy in Utah right now, but I offer consultation by phone and try to connect people with supportive therapists in their state. My approach is gentle and neutral — I do not push anyone toward one direction or the other — and thorough, helping people identify and confront the social and emotional factors that might be influencing their dysphoria. I recently submitted a proposal on gender and family therapy to the Utah Association of Marriage and Family Therapy, and our group will likely present at various conferences in the US over the next few years; I've been reaching out to see if anyone in the detrans community would be willing to share their story in person or by video to a group of therapists.
On a personal level, I have my own history with these feelings. I still get thoughts of wanting to be a woman from time to time. For me, those desires arise when I'm feeling depressed, when I feel an intense amount of shame, or because of AGP — an intense attraction to women that I feel I must become one. Doing more "masculine" things helps me find the right masculine/feminine balance. I used to label myself a "feminine guy" and I hated being a feminine guy — I either wanted to be more masculine or opt out of masculinity altogether. I've stopped telling myself I'm a feminine guy; I'm just a guy. I've noticed I'm not a very hairy guy, but I believe that has more to do with my mom's genes than something being wrong with my masculine development.
I've experienced the stigma firsthand: I went to the store the other day looking for hair products in the ladies' section, but I was nervous people would think I was some sort of pervert just for being there. If you're used to seeing yourself as a man or sometimes get mistaken for one, you might feel some internalized misandry.
I have strong views about how the trans issue is handled socially. I think there are a lot of people who don't believe their family members are really trans but feel compelled to agree, because there's an intense amount of pressure and shame on everyone if they don't affirm. It's sad because people go along with it to make us feel happy, and it really doesn't help to pretend — but honesty doesn't mean we need to be mean either. I see phrases like "dead-naming," "misgendering," "transphobes," and "TERFs" as forms of control or manipulation, and I think desisting or detransitioning can be a very lonely road. I wouldn't put all TERFs in the same camp — some are feminists trying to protect women's rights, others are hateful bigots. I believe the problem with transitioning is that it never actually solves the underlying problems fueling the dysphoria in the first place, and that labelling ourselves "trans" covers up unaddressed mental health or social issues. I encourage people to find a neutral person to help sort through their feelings — someone who isn't an "advocate" but also isn't a "transphobe." I also tell people that people do change their minds a lot — that's what adolescence is about — and that it doesn't have to be a big deal to say "I've changed my mind. I want to be referred to as a girl now." I also push back on appearance-focused culture: our culture is hyper-focused on outside appearance, and "our culture needs to change — not you!"