Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die het concept gender nu helemaal verwerpt en alleen gelooft in twee onveranderlijke biologische seksen. Ik herinner me dat ik mijn lichaam vier jaar geleden haatte, maar zeg dat ik nu zelfverzekerd ben en mijn lichaam leuk vind, en ik raad anderen hormonen en 'geslachtsaanpassende' operaties af als altijd een slecht idee. Ik heb een ouder wier dochter plotseling beweerde een man te zijn geadviseerd verstandig te blijven en professionele hulp te zoeken, en een butch detransitioner verteld dat ze biologisch vrouw is en haar verleden niet hoeft uit te leggen. Ik pleit voor vrouwelijk leven zonder medische ingrepen, steun homoseksuele mannen die man blijven en verzet me tegen wat ik zie als linkse identiteitslogica en censuur op Reddit. Ik beschrijf in dit transcript geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen.
Volledig verhaal
I came to these discussions as a detransitioned woman, and over the course of 2019 I found myself arguing repeatedly against both the gender-ideology side and, at times, against what I saw as the failures of the left. Early on I said I had tried to explain my view to a more left-leaning audience and that they don't do logic, they do feelings. I also noted that I had started out being very accepting of every sexuality, identity and imaginary fixation there was, and that it took me a long time to shake that reflex — implying a long personal history of having been permissive of, or perhaps involved in, identity claims I now reject. I used a thought experiment about suddenly deciding that instead of a 20-something white woman I was a 30-year-old black man to mock the logic of identity claims.
I have given direct advice to a parent whose daughter had suddenly decided she was male, telling them to offer support and love but to be sensible about the sudden decision, that she is fine the way she is, and that she may need professional help depending on how seriously she means it. I have also told a questioning person that it is okay to dislike how your body and genitals look — noting that even women with no trans wishes sometimes dislike their bodies — but that four years ago I hated my body for various reasons, whereas now I am confident and like my body. I strongly warned against phalloplasty, calling it an invasive surgery with a high failure rate, and told the person they would be grateful one day that they didn't mess their body up.
On the question of being read as male after detransition, I advised a butch-identified detransitioner that people may assume they are male depending on the day, that this is a sad truth, and that depending on how estrogen works for them they may or may not start looking more feminine again. I said it is entirely reasonable to ask people to use correct female pronouns, that they don't owe anyone an explanation of being detrans, and that trans people often don't explain themselves when they demand pronouns. I told them they are biologically female and should feel no shame claiming that label, and that it's none of other people's business that they were trans in the past.
I have also addressed people who are pre-transition or questioning, telling a feminine-identified male that he doesn't have to be a 'normal' man, that he can wear pink or lilac shirts, get earrings, grow his hair, take care of his skin, maybe wear a little makeup, do feminine things — but not mutilate his body. I told him he doesn't even have to be straight, that being gay is fine, and that he should accept he will never be a woman no matter how hard he tries. I stated bluntly that 'sex reassignment' surgeries are always a bad idea and will not give the relief sought. In a parallel comment I told an effeminate gay man there is nothing wrong with liking feminine things, as long as he understands he will never be female and shouldn't claim to be a woman, and that he should be proud of the type of man he is rather than harming his body. I bet him 'dollars to donuts' that living in a permanently altered body after a possibly unsuccessful surgery and taking hormones that can do serious harm is even harder than accepting yourself.
My philosophical position is that I don't believe in any 'gender' at all, binary or otherwise — I believe in biological sex. I described gender as just a set of rules in society, like a giant roleplaying game that people use to tell you how you should behave, while sex is how you are born and how you will always be, with no change possible: if you're born female, no shouting or surgery can change that. I noted that in previous years gender and sex meant the same thing, that gender then became used to create stereotypes of how men and women should act, and that a billion other genders were added after which the world went berserk. I concluded: gender means nothing to me, I believe in sexes, two of them, and those cannot be changed.
I have commented approvingly on a father who let his son wear a dress only if the boy himself chose it, saying a mom shouldn't use her child as a wildcard and that wearing a dress does not make someone female. I have also expressed hostility toward censorship on Reddit, noting that the subreddit neovaginaresults was banned and thanking AgainstHateSubreddits for it with sarcasm, calling it censorship. I have described a group of LGB people who don't want their streams to cross with trans people as 'pretty okay people' from what I've seen, and suggested a former trans or detransitioning person could definitely have conversation with them.