Alle verhalen

De helft van de transvriendengroep desisteerde

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd58
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerd persoon die op de middelbare school trans was in een overwegend trans vriendengroep waarvan ongeveer de helft uiteindelijk desisteerde of detransitioneerde. Ik betoog nu dat gender niet aangeboren is en dat niemand je kan vertellen of je trans bent, en ik adviseer mensen met twijfels om goed na te denken voordat ze medisch transitioneren, omdat het hen „een patiënt voor het leven” kan maken. Ik heb gedetailleerde waarschuwingen gedeeld over testosteron, hysterectomie, kankerrisico en kaalheid, en pleit voor een eileiderligatie als veiliger alternatief voor wie een zwangerschap wil vermijden. Ik beschrijf geen eigen medische ingrepen, operaties of een specifieke detransitiedatum. Ik beschrijf geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen.

Volledig verhaal

I desisted, and I've been open about that with people asking me for advice. I was trans in high school — not out to my parents, but all my friends were trans, and about half of us ended up desisting or detransitioning once we realized that body image issues or frustration with our bodies and selves was what actually made us think we were trans. At the time we all had experiences that correlated with the common narrative of transness: dysphoria, tomboyness, severe anxiety at being perceived female. I don't think that made us "not trans" at the moment we identified with it — we deeply identified and resonated with it. What I tell people now is that I don't think it's a dichotomy of whether you're trans or not. Nobody is fundamentally, "deep down," actually a gender. We are socialized into specific behaviors associated with some gender, but those behaviors aren't inscribed in your brain — saying so is ignorant from a neuroscience context, and those same arguments were used to deny women the right to vote. Gender matters as a social reality, but it isn't innate, and nobody can tell you if you're trans. There's no formula, no trans brain switch. You can be gender non-conforming without being trans, and you can enjoy presenting as a man without being trans. The problem for me was that I had so many preconceived notions about what women were that I simply thought I wasn't one. My advice to anyone in that position is to first try unlearning the things you know about what it means to be a girl: you can be a tomboy, you can be masculine, you can be straight or gay, and most importantly you can live outside of boxes. I'm cautious about medical transition. I tell people that if they're already having doubts at a certain point of transition, it might get worse as time goes on, and that the internal struggle may not be worth it. Medically it's just going to get worse from there, and socially it gets harder to keep up if you're not 100% convinced. People change, and eventually the people in your life will come around to you not being trans anymore. I'd avoid medically transitioning unless you're absolutely sure — it's a huge decision. It kind of makes you a patient for life, and depending on the surgeries, complications could arise. As people born female it also means increased risk for certain cancers and hormonal changes that might be genuinely uncomfortable. I've tried to lay out specific medical facts for people weighing testosterone: after a certain period on T you're encouraged to get a hysterectomy, in large part to prevent cancers, cysts, and polyps in the uterus — "It's like you're chemically inducing reproductive health conditions." I also point out that these organs aren't just there to make babies; they help calcify your bones and keep organs in place. Another issue with T I raise is premature aging, specifically people balding well before 40 — you might bald faster than cis men. I'm careful to say I'm not trying to scare anyone, but I insist that people know and accept all the changes T would make before starting, because there is barely any medical research on cross-sex HRT. On reproductive questions I've argued that if avoiding pregnancy is a motivation, there are permanent options like tubal ligation that are safer than testosterone, that you can still get pregnant while on T, and that some forms of tube ligation are reversible. I framed this as a matter of reproductive choice: people should be allowed to decide they don't want kids without that decision culminating in more dangerous contraceptive methods or an abortion. In one exchange I told a commenter, bluntly, "Also youre AMAB, this isn't your conversation to have, with all due respect." Overall I try to be kind with people and encourage them to understand their own psychological needs. I don't describe any medical interventions of my own, surgeries, medications, or a specific detransition date in what I've written — just that I was trans in high school and am desisted now.