Alle verhalen

Geen hormonen, geen operaties — maar toch het gevoel een sekte te zijn ontvlucht

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd304
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde lesbische vrouw in Australië en ik ben autistisch. Ik heb nooit testosteron genomen, maar zie er androgyn uit, en het lezen van 'TERF'-materiaal hielp me te stoppen met het obsessief bezig zijn met operaties en hormonen — al voel ik me nog steeds alsof ik een sekte heb verlaten en verwacht ik gestraft te worden als ik dat zeg. Ik ben zeer kritisch over transitiegeneeskunde, 'egg culture' en de self-ID-wetten van Australië, die volgens mij lesbische evenementen alleen voor vrouwen illegaal maken. Ik zet me er openlijk voor in, ondanks mijn angst om vrienden, werk en familie te verliezen. Ik heb nooit hormonen gebruikt en heb geen eigen operaties beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I am a detransitioned (or desisted) lesbian woman living in Australia, and I am autistic. I never took testosterone, but I present androgynously enough that I sometimes do a smile-and-wave thing when entering single-sex spaces so other women don't think I'm in the wrong place — partly, I think, because I'm autistic and overthink social cues. I came out of what I now describe as a kind of cult-like mindset around gender. Reading and watching material from feminists labelled 'TERFs' is what helped me stop obsessing about surgery and hormones, and I feel I have them to thank for showing me there were other ways to think about the topic. Even years later I noticed I still choose my words very carefully when I talk about this, and I still feel like I'm going to be 'punished somehow' for saying the wrong thing — I described feeling like I left a cult and still expecting punishment for disbelieving. I also identify as an 'egg culture' hater, referring to the online practice of telling people they are probably trans. I hold strong views about the medical side. When someone asked about breast implants after a double mastectomy, I pointed out that implants need replacing within 10–15 years and can develop mould, and I argued that all surgery is inherently traumatic and that implants would prevent a person from coming to terms with their body as it is, because they require further surgery later purely for aesthetics. I said I wouldn't have thought about that when I was younger. I've also said I'd be far more comfortable with body modification if the motivation seemed grounded in reality rather than 'delusion and self rejection,' and that I wish people could reach genuine self-awareness and self-acceptance instead. I am very politically engaged about sex and gender law in Australia. I've explained that since 2013 self-declared gender identity has been conflated with and legally overrides sex, so there is no legal definition of 'woman' other than self-ID. I've said it is literally illegal in Australia for lesbians — or any women — to hold a female-only event unless it's an underground, membership-only thing: it used to be explicit only in Tasmania, but a lesbian group in Victoria petitioned the Australian Human Rights Commission for permission to hold a women-only lesbian event in Melbourne and was refused, expecting to lose but wanting to raise awareness. I've said this affects all women because no female-only groups can exist for any reason, and that bad actors are legally empowered to dismantle safeguarding for women and girls and then mock us in court. I wish we could have a Supreme Court ruling like the UK's, but our laws are too different. I also feel I'm not allowed to talk about any of this without being called hateful, bigoted or transphobic, and that saying anything risks losing friends, job or family members. I feel that the ideology is deeply homophobic and that this affects my day-to-day life, while those I disagree with can't see it. I try to hold anger and compassion at once: I think desisters and detransitioners can be angry about how we've been treated while still feeling compassion for the people who hurt us, and I spend a lot of time considering the feelings of those who wrote me off once it became clear I wasn't a 'true believer' anymore. I'm frustrated at having to choose my words so carefully and still being read as coming from hatred.