Alle verhalen

Tumblr-zuiverheidscultuur zei dat ze moest transitioneren — tot ze andere detrans-verhalen las

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd181
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die tussen ongeveer 2007 en halverwege de jaren 2010 serieus overwoog en probeerde sociaal van vrouw naar man te transitioneren, maar nooit hormonen nam of een operatie had. Mijn verlangen om te transitioneren werd vooral gedreven door geïnternaliseerde bifobie en schuldgevoel over mijn biseksualiteit, versterkt door een giftige zuiverheids- en call-outcultuur in Tumblr-fandomruimtes, plus een hormonale/medische aandoening waarvan ik ten onrechte dacht dat ik testosteron nodig had. Het lezen van verhalen van detransitioners, voortdurende zelfreflectie en angst voor hoe hormonen zouden interageren met mijn auto-immuunziekte brachten me ertoe af te haken. Ik omarm mezelf nu als biseksuele vrouw en moedig detransitioners aan hun ervaringen te blijven delen, al heb ik niet aan formeel activisme gedaan. Sinds mijn detransitie meld ik geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.

Volledig verhaal

I am a woman, born female, who is bisexual, and I came seriously close to transitioning from female to male before deciding against it. I never went on hormones or had any surgeries; the furthest I went was acquiring a binder, which I only ever used for cosplay, and attempting to learn how to socially transition through my college and online communities. My interest in transitioning began around 2007, when I was in my mid-teens, and intensified around 2013, when I was about 23-24 and had just gotten into Tumblr. I was immersed in fiction, fandom spaces, and social justice circles. The prevailing attitude there was "all queer all the time," but it felt paradoxical to me as a bisexual person. If I expressed that I liked women, I was told I was a "dudebro" fetishizing women. If I expressed attraction to men, I was called "a traitor to the cause" and accused of fetishizing men. Liking straight romance made me a traitor and somehow meant I was fetishizing myself. Believing in biological sex was treated as a scam I was bad for even questioning. I already carried myself in a way that led people to assume I was a man. On top of that, I had an autoimmune condition that only flared when certain "female issues" arose, which led me to believe I had the wrong hormonal profile and that testosterone would help. I also felt a nagging sense that something wasn't right. I thought that if I transitioned to being a man, it would absolve me of the guilt I felt about my bisexuality and get my peers off my back. I now understand this as internalized biphobia, amplified by the "trans+purity/puriteen/call-out post" culture of the time, which leaked into adult fandom communities. Something told me to move slowly, both because of cost and because I wanted to be sure I was transitioning for the right reasons. I was afraid of starting hormones because I didn't know how they would affect my health, especially given my autoimmune condition, which I now know is affected by hormones. The seed of doubt was planted when same-sex marriage was legalized in the US, and I saw many non-binary, queer, and MOGAI people trying to discard biology altogether. I saw disrespect toward sexuality as a whole within the LGBT community, including ideas like "if you don't date me, you're a bigot" and "I only date for personality, not genitals." I was internalizing these ideas. Trans people were treated as beyond criticism unless you were transsexual and pushed back against the notion that biology doesn't exist. Over the years, I did more self-reflection, especially as more detransitioners began sharing their stories. Their accounts helped me back off the ledge. I eventually embraced the fact that I am a woman who likes both men and women, rather than someone who needed to become as close to a man as possible. I have also come to realize that some of what I struggled with was rooted in biological issues I am dealing with now as an adult. I was in the "Tumblr trenches" back in 2013, and I say it genuinely messed me up. One of the worst things I saw in fandom was around a decade ago, when an actual MtF Japanese person explained why a certain Dangan Ronpa character wasn't trans, and people left the fandom over it. That was when I discovered "activists and allies," and I haven't been the same since. I also saw people threaten to doxx others over disagreements about trans headcanons. I do not blame the creators whose work was used this way, only the ideology pushed through fandom spaces. I have not done any formal advocacy or activism, but I have openly encouraged detransitioners to keep speaking, telling them that they save people like me. I currently identify as a detransitioned woman, though I never fully medically transitioned. I consider myself a furry, and I have an interest in how transgender identity, therianthropy, otherkin, and furry identity may overlap, including with neurodivergence. I am critical of how transition is pushed, particularly through fandom and online spaces, and I believe people need to be able to distinguish fiction from real life. I have found a kind of self-confidence in accepting myself as I am, but I also acknowledge that self-acceptance alone won't be enough for everyone who transitions or detransitions.