Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I never medically transitioned, but I came very close to wanting to, and for years I carried a deep-seated self-contempt and a wish to stop being me. I have thought a lot about why I wanted to escape my own identity, and I keep coming back to the same conclusion: I just didn't want to be me anymore, and if I could get out of being myself, that would solve all my problems.
I was born female and grew up Chinese, in a culture with strong gender norms and intense pressure to achieve, but I was raised in a different culture, so I grew up as a foreigner. I am autistic (diagnosed with Asperger's in my 20s) and have ADHD, and I have been gender nonconforming for as long as I can remember. I never felt normal. Things other people take for granted — turning in homework, getting a date — felt like a Herculean task. People always seemed to think I was weird and were oddly uncomfortable around me. I couldn't shake the feeling that there was something deeply wrong with me and that I needed to be someone else. In the end, trans was just one hat I tried on. It didn't fit very well, but then again, nothing really did.
My mother did a great job of letting me know how much I had shattered her expectations as a daughter, and not in a good way. She would say, "why can't you be bubbly and affectionate like every other girl? Why do you wear boys clothes? I wanted a *girl*, god damn it." Being forced into the mold of the girly girl by my mother is precisely what led me to suspect I'm not a girl in the first place: if that's a girl, and I'm not that, then I must be a boy. I also grew up around women with masculine haircuts and thought nothing of it — my mom had such a hairstyle and I never thought of her as a man.
When I was in school, as an autistic tomboy, I was desperately looking for any reason I was such a weird person who wasn't accepted anywhere. I tried to stuff myself into a man suit because I was not a very "good" woman. I thought I was the problem, and if I just got out of my own body, it would solve everything. But there was the nagging feeling that I wasn't a man and I had no idea what being a man would even mean. I now think that if everyone around me had validated those feelings and transitioned themselves, I can't say I wouldn't have done it too — it's not that there were no underlying mental health issues causing my thoughts, but confused and scared kids often turn to the low-hanging fruit as to why they're the way they are, and if an explanation is "in the air" and socially prestigious, why wouldn't they gravitate to it? Back when I was considering transitioning, it was a very fringe idea and people looked at me like I grew two heads.
I also had a lot of social dysphoria-adjacent pain: the pain of not fitting in. I have wondered whether that contributed to my dysphoria, and I doubt medical transition would have been the solution to not fitting in. I looked into polyamory in my late teens for similar reasons — society's rules are bullshit, so why assume there's any basis in monogamy? I moved many countries without really knowing why, suspecting it had to do with wanting to find a place I felt a sense of belonging. I even moved back to China, where people can usually pick me out as foreign-raised within 2-3 sentences despite my fluent, native-sounding accent.
I also changed my first name in my 20s — I never liked my birth name and thought it was the ugliest name imaginable, so I chose a new one carefully. Within months it started to take on the same ugliness as the old name, and I realized it was never the name: as soon as I identified with the name, I started to dislike it. I accepted it after recognizing that it's me and not the name. My husband was supportive of the first change but wasn't happy at the prospect of getting used to another one. I also took his last name, so now I'm a Chinese person with an Irish last name and a totally different first name — my name is just a group of sounds and letters that points to me. I am me. My name is my name.
Over time I decided to just be myself. Once I made that decision it wasn't so bad. I no longer felt like I had to deny the feminine parts of my personality or looks just to fit into the guy box, and I became more comfortable in the traits that make me a woman. Even my husband says he basically married a dude, but he finds me very feminine in some ways. I am definitely gender nonconforming and it's a bit of a lonely existence. I am now a stay-at-home mom and outwardly I fit the feminine stereotype, but this is just where life brought me, and I act feminine because it is advantageous to do so. I put on a mask most of the time; if I am too "out" with people they treat me like a strange mutant. After trying on a few identities, I have concluded that I am an individual and will always come across as strange if I act like myself, and no labels can change that. When I got my Asperger's diagnosis in my 20s there was relief at finally having an explanation for my strange social history, but a few months later the novelty wore off and I realized it changed absolutely nothing about my life.
I now say that what I want, fundamentally, is simply to be female. Over the years I've come to accept that there is no one right way to be a woman. I'm a little weird because I have Asperger's, but I am a woman in every way. Nobody would deny that, and nobody would call me a man in a woman's body. Even as masculine in temperament as I am, I still come off as very feminine compared to the guys — in a group of all men I am by far the least aggressive there, by a mile. I often still struggle with gender roles, especially after becoming a mother, and I sometimes fantasize about how much easier it would be if I were male. I have a group of mom friends because I want my baby to socialize, but it's awkward — I relate better to one of the husbands than any of the wives (I'm not attracted to him in the least; we just share interests), and it seems to break a social taboo to talk to him more than his wife. Good thing my husband is autistic himself, so I'm not starving for good conversation.
I had a rough relationship with my parents in my 20s, and many of our fights were worth having, though I regret the excessive time I spent baiting them on irrelevant political topics. My mom and I went through a very rough patch in my 20s; we are pretty good now, and I can tell she wishes we could be like nothing ever happened, but it can't be — I learned things about her that changed the way I relate to her. I also had an ADHD doctor, famous in the field, who asked me which medication I'd like to try next — Adderall? Concerta? — which I found absurd; it's his job to decide based on my reactions and medical history. One therapist told me, "My job is not to believe whatever you tell me and affirm you," which I think is the right professional attitude.
I have a wonderful family now: I met my husband at a decent school, and together we have a daughter (she was 13 months old in late 2022, and as of then showed no symptoms of autism, being more social than either of us). I had an unmedicated vaginal birth and can compare my periods to childbirth in pain. I'm almost 30 (as of 2022) and I still have recurring nightmares about school, so I'm homeschooling my kid — I hate gender ideology, though I have nothing against individual people who want to transition, and I believe it transmits largely through schools, teachers, and peer groups. I want to raise my daughter to make up her own mind, though even that value — the value of non-control — is one of my own values I'm imposing.
I don't regret not having been a beautiful teen girl, but I had other regrets, like not applying myself in high school and not getting into my dream school. Still, I went to a decent school, met my husband, and have the most wonderful little girl, and I'm not interested in any other timeline because it would mean losing what I have now. I also deal with feeling disembodied — I don't feel like my body is really me, I'm a ghost in a machine, not aware of where my limbs are half the time — and I've found that being out in nature and finding out what my body can do helps that feeling.
I have never done activism, but I have strong opinions: I hate gender ideology, I'm critical of therapists who affirm without question, and I generally think transition is not the answer to not fitting in. At the same time I have sympathy for individuals who transition and for young people who gravitate to whatever explanation is socially available. I advise people considering detransition to do it for themselves, not for their families, because history doesn't get erased and things won't go back to the way they were — you can only move forward.