Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (als vrouw geboren) die autistisch is en nu stevig kritisch op transitie voor anderen, terwijl ik mensen die detransitioneren of desisteren sterk steun. Ik verwerp de term ‘cis’ en omschrijf mezelf gewoon als vrouw, en ik zie trans identiteit als een leugen die ik als autistisch mens niet kan verdragen. Ik waarschuw anderen gedetailleerd voor de medische risico's van hormonen en operaties — seksuele disfunctie, verlies van libido, problemen met botdichtheid en hart, levenslang patiënt zijn — en voor de sociale kosten, waaronder dat de meesten in het echt niet doorgaan. Ik heb mijn eigen transitietijdlijn, medische geschiedenis of spijt in deze berichten niet beschreven. Ik ben bemoedigend en bevestigend naar anderen die hun weg terug naar het leven als vrouw hebben gevonden.
Volledig verhaal
I am a female woman who is autistic, and I have come to a very firm position on the question of transition. I was born female and I identify as a woman without any qualifier — I reject the word "cis" as what I call a trans ideological term, and I say plainly that I don't need a prefix because I'm "not captured by an insidious ideology." I describe myself as "females like myself" and say that claiming womanhood without having experienced it is "morally wrong and offensive to females like myself."
I have never described undergoing any transition myself in these posts; my account here is largely of how I engage with others in the detransition community and with people considering transition. I have been open about being autistic, and I say that I hate to lie as an autistic person and can't stand falsehoods — which is how I characterize trans identity. I have also mentioned that my best female friend has scoliosis, offered as an example that women come in varied shapes and appearances.
On the medical side, I hold strong views about the harms of hormones and surgery. I tell someone considering removing their gonads that if they want to retain any sexual function or orgasm they need them, that otherwise their libido will be nonexistent, and that it's "unnecessary body mutilation." I have said that hormones are not a wonder drug that will "melt away all male influence," and I list what I see as the risks: reduced lifespan, increased suicidal thoughts after transition, heart issues, decreased bone density, sexual dysfunction, loss of libido or ability to orgasm, and — if bottom surgery is involved — the decimation of any real chance of a healthy sex life and perhaps the ability to have children. I describe the transitioned person as becoming a "premature lifelong patient" with constant issues, risks, bills, pain, and daily effort to maintain themselves.
I have also written at length to someone in their late 20s considering male-to-male transition (whom I read as male), telling them that if they think they will pass that is a lie, that even the so-called stealth ones don't pass to me with their filters and less so in person, and that most don't pass in person because you can't hide shoulder size, hand size, or jaw shape. I said filters and photoshop are very prevalent with what I call trans identified males. I asked them whether they'd be comfortable that people would have to either lie and affirm them or refuse bluntly, and whether there's anything wrong with being a feminine male. I recommended they read stories from the community that centre around MTFTM, advised them to pause and think hard if they had any doubts, and warned that public support for trans people is declining and they should be prepared for hostility or verbal abuse — while saying I don't condone harassment. I acknowledged my bluntness by saying "I'm sorry if this was harsh or blunt, I'm autistic," and that I've seen too many people hurt and made disabled by these choices, left with bodies they don't feel comfortable in, mourning who they used to be.
I am supportive and encouraging toward people who have detransitioned or desisted. I told one person "She will always be a part of you. You are her," that I'm proud of them for finding their way back to their "beautiful female self," and that there is no right way to be a woman. I have complimented others' appearance, saying things like "You look like you're thriving" and "You look lovely," and I remarked that the eyes give away sex first and that even eyes radiate our "innate femaleness/femininity/sex." I also expressed sympathy to someone questioning their decision, hoping they find peace with whatever they choose.
On homosexuality, I have stated that it occurs in nature, not just in humans. On certain rhetoric, I called something "emotional blackmail and abusive" and said the way it's used sickens me.
I have not described my own mental health history, family situation, relationships, sexuality, adversity, or any regret in these posts. My current identity is a detransitioned or never-transitioned female woman who is critical of transition for others and supportive of those who detransition.