Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar sinds mijn kindertijd had gewild dat ik als man was geboren. Ik heb nooit hormonen genomen, een operatie gehad of puberteitsremmers gebruikt, en ik identificeer me als heteroseksuele vrouw die een biologisch gezin wil. Ik ben kritisch over hoe luchtig transitie wordt voorgesteld, vooral medisch, en ik schrijf veel van mijn eigen dysforie toe aan uitsluiting in mijn kindertijd, genderverwachtingen en moeite om contact te maken met andere meisjes. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven. Ik heb momenteel een ondersteunende maar voorzichtige kijk op transitie voor anderen, terwijl ik er persoonlijk voor mezelf tegen ben.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have never medically transitioned, but I have thought about it for most of my life and I have spent a lot of time in detrans spaces working through why. I remember wishing I had been born a boy from a young age — I don't have a specific age pinned down for when that started, but it was childhood, and it has never fully gone away. I write sometimes that I "wished and sometimes still wish I had been born a boy."
Growing up, I had almost all male friends. I wasn't invited to birthday parties or events once people started caring that I was a girl, and I felt shut out of the "inner circle" of my childhood male friends as we got older. I hated the expectations on me to be a "cute little girly girl." I was told I was bossy and outgoing, and I've wondered whether those traits would have mattered at all if I'd been male. I've also noted that I've had trouble connecting with other girls and that I've tried to find better ways to connect with women.
I have never taken HRT, never had top or bottom surgery, and never been on puberty blockers. I've been open about that: in a discussion comparing tattoos, breast augmentation and HRT, I said "while I've never taken it, it isn't as reversible as it is made out to be," and listed voice changes, hair growth, face shape changes, aggression and infertility as things HRT can cause. I've given advice to others considering top surgery or detransition, including suggesting they talk to a doctor about what stopping HRT involves and whether their sperm would be viable — which tells me I was writing from the position of someone who has not been on hormones themselves.
What has kept me from transitioning is a set of convictions I've stated repeatedly. I believe transition won't actually change the fundamental facts of my situation: "no matter what I do, it won't change. I can destroy my body, change my name, my life. But it won't change." I've written that I don't think "destroying my body, brain, and relationships" would fix things and that it would "just further unnecessarily complicate things." I think a lot of people confuse gender identity with happiness and self-worth, and I've told others that their gender is not all they are — they have hobbies, interests, life experiences. I've also argued that there is no right or wrong way to be a man or a woman, and that the idea that wearing a makeup means you must be a woman is, ironically, sexist.
I have been skeptical of the medical pathway in general. I've described transition as "not as light a choice as so many make it out to be, especially medically," and I've pointed out that the positive reinforcement people get — "It gets better!" "You'll pass!" "Give it time!" — doesn't account for the possibility that it won't work. I've also written about how hard it is to be a non-biological male versus a biological one, that HRT is not something you can stop and keep all the effects, and that you can't have biological children afterwards.
I have been politically left-leaning but critical of aspects of trans activism. I've said that people on both sides agree with some of these criticisms but that saying them gets you labeled a bigot or transphobe. I've defended Florida's "Don't Say Gay" bill on the grounds that young kids don't need to be questioning gender identity, and I've been explicit about my own dating preferences as a straight woman: I would treat trans people with respect, but I wouldn't date a trans man because I want to have a biological family. I've also said I think some people attribute their gender dysphoria to trauma, bullying or family issues, and I've described a friend-of-a-friend's rapid transition as concerning.
I've also worked on accepting regret and uncertainty as part of life. I've written that part of life is having regrets and wondering "what if," but also trying not to harp on it and to see the beauty in the life you did choose. I've acknowledged that the support question is genuinely hard — whether people support your transition or not, you can end up wishing they had done the opposite.
As of my most recent writing, I am a detransitioned/desisted woman in the sense that I never went through with medical or social transition, I identify as a straight woman, and I am comfortable with that. I have not described any surgeries, hormone use, or ongoing medical needs. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm.