Alle verhalen

Meelezend in detrans-ruimtes zonder zelf te transitioneren

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd116
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een heteroseksuele, extreem gender-non-conforme vrouw die nooit medisch transitioneerde — het meeste wat ik deed was flirten met labels als ‘genderqueer’ en ‘transmasculien’ op Reddit, dus ik noem mezelf niet gedesisteerd, maar gewoon een bondgenoot in deze ruimtes. Ik heb jarenlang meegelezen in detrans- en genderkritische gemeenschappen, detransitie-YouTubevideo's verzameld en gedeeld, nieuws over pediatrische transitiezaken gevolgd en mijn zorgen geuit over tieners die genormaliseerd worden in kinkcultuur en over ouders die kinderen tot transitie drijven. Ik voel me eenzaam als masculiene heteroseksuele vrouw die niet past in lesbische ruimtes of pro-trans GNC-ruimtes, en ik noem mezelf gender-non-conform en niet butch om geen lesbische identiteit toe te eigenen. Ik ben sceptisch over hoe makkelijk transitie aan jongeren wordt aangeboden, maar steun volwassenen die hun eigen keuzes maken.

Volledig verhaal

I never medically transitioned, but I spent time in online spaces thinking about gender and came close enough that I want to be careful about how I describe myself. The most I ever did was flirt with labels like 'genderqueer' and 'transmasculine' on Reddit — I never took the step of actually identifying as trans or transitioning, so calling myself 'desisted' felt fraudulent. I settled on calling myself an 'ally' in detrans spaces instead, even though that isn't fully accurate either, because it felt closest. I'm a straight, gender-nonconforming woman. I've been extremely masculine my whole life and I'm not sexually oriented toward women. I'd sooner transition than pretend to be feminine — presenting masculine is non-negotiable for me, it's either live my life that way or not at all. That combination has been lonely: I don't fit in on r/butchlesbians, and subs like r/butchwomen and r/masculineofcenter are heavily pro-trans-identification, which I don't think is healthy for me personally. I feel affinity with butch women and I like the word 'butch,' but I've been told it's a lesbian sexual identity and it would feel appropriative to claim it as a straight woman, so I just call myself gender nonconforming. I mostly lurk in detrans and gender-critical spaces. I spent a lot of time collecting and sharing YouTube videos of detransitioners' stories for people who asked — I had a bunch bookmarked and kept finding more, and I'd post them in threads. I watched entire channels of detrans YouTubers and thanked them for sharing, and I asked one creator to make a video about what led her to become kink-critical, because the normalization of 'online dom' culture among teenagers scared me. I also recommended r/GCdebatesQT as a debate community, and I follow news stories about gender medicine closely — I've commented on Jazz Jennings's medical timeline (noting she started estrogen on March 6, 2012, at age 11, citing her biography), on the Coy Mathis case (which I'm 'pretty much 100% sure' is a Munchausen-by-proxy situation), and on a Finnish couple who lost custody of their 15-year-old for refusing to allow hormones. I worry about children whose parents I believe are using the movement for nefarious purposes, and I don't know what can be done to help them. I don't have surgery, hormones, or medical complications to report because I never medically transitioned. My distress around gender has been more about not fitting into femininity and feeling out of place in the small world of masculine women. I don't describe myself as having a current identity crisis — I've landed on 'gender nonconforming woman' and I'm at peace with that, even if it's lonely. I'm supportive of people's right to make their own choices but I'm clearly skeptical of how easily transition is normalized, especially for teenagers and especially around kink and online subcultures.