Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd/gedesisteerd persoon die mijn eerdere trans-identificatie ben gaan zien door de lens van waarschijnlijk autisme en jaren in extreem online liberale ruimtes, waardoor het makkelijk was sociale wrijving aan gender toe te schrijven. De implicaties van chirurgische transitie, plus wantrouwen jegens artsen door negatieve ervaringen in het verleden, behoorden tot mijn grootste redenen om te desisteren. Ik heb veel eigenschappen die me vandaag waarschijnlijk op het autismespectrum zouden plaatsen en ik zie het omarmen van mannelijkheid als versterking van mijn lichamelijke autonomie. Ik bespreek mijn persoonlijke geschiedenis niet als erom gevraagd wordt en negeer zulke vragen meestal. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over transitie, over het verbergen van informatie voor zorgteams om toegang tot genderzorg te krijgen, en over hoe detransitiegerelateerde media wordt gepresenteerd.
Volledig verhaal
I first recognized my own trajectory when I heard someone else describe a trans identification path that looked almost exactly like mine; I was glad she got the support she needed to become comfortable with herself again, and it was affirming to hear someone else experience it the way I did.
On the medical side, the implications of surgical transition were one of my biggest contributing factors to my decision to desist. I've had too many negative experiences with doctors about other things, surgery included, to trust that it would be any better in this context — medically necessary surgeries go wrong all the time. A scene from CSI (I think Las Vegas), where someone is described as having been "fixed to death" through a series of cosmetic surgeries, lodged in my mind and reinforced my thinking. I've chosen to frame my decision to embrace masculinity as a continual reinforcement of my bodily autonomy and emotional sovereignty.
I also have many traits that would likely place me on the autism spectrum today. I was chronically online in extremely liberal social spaces for years on end, and I believe that self-limited perspective made it much easier for me to retroactively attribute many of the social frictions I experienced up to that point to gender, rather than autism or something else more complex.
I may not have many positive things to say about my experiences with western medicine generally. I do think hiding relevant information from a care team is a bad faith move — I even know someone who has avoided diagnosis explicitly in order to ease access to gender affirming care in the future, which I view critically.
On handling questions about my past, what I would like to say is: "I don't do that anymore, if you'd like to know about my personal history there you are welcome to ask." What I actually do is ignore the question.
I've paid attention to media coverage of detransition and gender topics. I watched part of an interview I felt had a lot of potential to "peak" people that was squandered by the interviewer being rude and aiming for quick gotchas — while I thought much of what was said was technically correct, the divisive delivery detracted from the piece's journalistic integrity, and I went from being excited to share it with my family to unlikely to. I wanted to show it to family members who need to see it but would dismiss it outright after the introduction. The end of Plato's Cave came to mind — the freed one who returns to speak the truth to those still fettered and is killed for the heresy.
I've also commented on the Rachel Dolezal case, arguing she was celebrated while she was "stealth" and that much of the hatred toward her comes down to either her working for the NAACP while pretending to be Black, or her being a white woman who became a socially acceptable target for hatred and mockery — a place to gain social capital for rebranded misogyny.
I don't describe any current identity label beyond having desisted and embracing masculinity as a value I hold. I don't discuss surgeries I've had, hormones, fertility, or specific diagnoses in this material.