Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren, transitioneerde om als vrouw te leven en heb inmiddels gedetransitioneerd; nu omschrijf ik mezelf als aan de andere kant van transitie en zeg ik ‘BEEN THERE, DONE THAT.’ Een forensisch-antropologische analyse van mijn schedel van $1500 overtuigde me dat doorgaan voor vrouw lichamelijk onmogelijk is voor mij, en ik heb die bevinding publiekelijk uitgedragen, waarvan ik denk dat ze FFS-chirurgen onder druk zette om schedelgrootte als belemmering voor doorgaan te erkennen. Ik verborg mijn transitie voor veel vrienden omdat het nep voelde, en ik adviseer anderen dat detransitie de meeste mensen niet verrast. Ik ben sterk tegen onomkeerbare genitale operaties wanneer er twijfels zijn en heb anderen een orchidectomie uit het hoofd gepraat. Ik ben kritisch over fetisj-gedreven transitiegemeenschappen en richt mijn leven nu op andere dingen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and transitioned to live as a woman; I have since detransitioned and now describe myself as being on the other side of that experience. My transition involved hormones and I had considered, and apparently was scheduled for, an orchiectomy, which I ultimately decided against. I also pursued extensive research into whether passing as female was physically possible for me.
To settle the question of passing for myself, I paid $1500 for a standard forensic anthropological analysis and an additional $300 for a CT scan of my entire skull. A trained forensic anthropologist compared a long list of reference points on my skull against a large sample of male and female human remains — distances between orbital rims and similar anatomical measurements. Essentially every category for me fell within one standard deviation of the male average, or two or three standard deviations away from male (meaning more masculine), with only two or three characteristics within one standard deviation of the female average. I concluded from this that it is physically impossible to pass as the other sex consistently, and that 95% of males have skull features too large to pass. I told people this and believe my efforts partly forced FFS surgeons to admit on their websites that their procedures will not change skull size and that this may be a barrier to passing.
I now regard transition as something I have been through and moved past: "BEEN THERE, DONE THAT. Thats how I feel about transition. On to other more exciting things." I believe that once someone gets "pricked by the trans fairy" and starts obsessing about it, it is very difficult to give up the fantasy until you actually live it — and that even if you detransition, you may come out the other end with a clarity of mind that prevents you from obsessing about it later in life. That is how I frame my own experience.
During my transition I never felt comfortable telling people because deep down it felt fake and not real, so I hid it from a lot of friends and kept the list of people I was officially out to low. I am happy I did that because it allowed me to maintain control of my identity with those people. I now advise others that even supportive people find transition quite extreme, that they will not be surprised by a detransition, and that you can always chalk it up to an identity crisis.
I am critical of sexual-fetish-driven transition and of pursuing every sexual thought. I point to subreddits where people cage their genitals, use poppers, and consume "sissy hypno" pornography as examples of how the idea that every sexual thought should be pursued and validated "leads people to turn into shells filled with hedonism." I argue that just because you have the capacity to fantasize about something does not mean you need to be anything other than you are, and that fantasies change over time. I distinguish these fetish communities from feminine, flamboyant, well-adjusted gay male friends of mine, and I say I still prefer "essentialist trans girls" to fetish exhibitionists. I noted that the sissy phenomenon seems to have exploded in the last 5-8 years.
I am strongly opposed to irreversible surgery when there is any doubt. I have advised someone not to get an orchiectomy if they have doubts, asking how life would actually differ pre- versus post-orchi and whether the minor change is worth losing all flexibility and the ability to go back to being a completely functional male. I also tell people not to get sucked into a "system" and that they do not "owe" it to doctors and nurses to follow through on a scheduled surgery — that they cancel medical procedures all the time. I have also suggested finasteride to prevent DHT-related hair loss.
On relationships, I have commented that an ex-partner was "at least on a gay-bisexual spectrum" and that if he blamed me for something he was being delusional about himself, suggesting he likely had gay experiences he did not disclose.
I have not described specific mental health diagnoses, therapy experiences, family dynamics, or my current relationship status in these comments.