Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, een masculiene lesbienne die bijna drie jaar als trans identificeerde en hij/hem-voornaamwoorden gebruikte voordat ik net voor hormonen en operaties stopte. Een plastisch chirurg, niet mijn instemmende therapeut, vroeg waarom ik een jongen wilde zijn en hielp me inzien dat ik nooit dysforie had gehad voordat de maatschappij me uit mijn ‘tomboy’-identiteit drong. Ik heb mijn identiteit als masculiene lesbienne teruggenomen en ben dankbaar dat ik blijvende medische veranderingen heb vermeden. Nu pleit ik voor meer begrip van de risico’s van transitie, terwijl ik toegang voor echt transgender mensen blijf steunen, en ik beschouw het richting transitie duwen van masculiene vrouwen als homofoob. Ik ben politiek gematigd/onafhankelijk en actief in het delen van mijn verhaal om anderen te helpen.
Volledig verhaal
I am a woman who was born female and who identified as a masculine lesbian for a long time before I was pushed toward identifying as trans. I never had dysphoria as a child — I was a tomboy, and I was comfortable being a masculine woman who is attracted to women. What changed was the social pressure around me: people in society took away my 'tomboy' status and gave me the status of 'trans.' Because I am masculine and I like girls, people around me insisted I must actually be a boy — a straight man born in a woman's body. I felt pressured by people for being a masc lesbian to be a boy, and it was unnerving how much force was put into making me feel like I, as a masc lesbian, was not right in my body.
For almost three years I called myself by he/him pronouns and identified as trans. During that time I got very close to actually taking medication and having life-altering surgery. A therapist had already approved the path, saying 'Yeah go for it.' I attended a meet-up with a plastic surgeon about having my breasts removed. It was the surgeon, not the therapist, who stopped and asked, 'Wait a minute, why do you want to be a boy?' I told him my friends said I'm a boy and I like girls and I'm masculine. He asked me if I ever had dysphoria before people started to question my identity, and I said no. He told me that society made me lose my identity.
I reacted badly at first — I got so angry, I yelled at him, I was mean to the doctor and said 'how dare you question my gender,' and I stormed out. But it got me thinking, and I thank god it did. I never took hormones and never had the surgery. I sent the doctor a thank-you card afterward; I wasn't able to go back in person because the drive was long, but he knows he changed my life.
Slowly I have been gaining my identity back as a tomboy. I'm a lesbian, I'm into women, I love other masc lesbian women, and I feel better now saying that. I still feel for everyone who was pushed farther than I was. I know detransitioners face a stigma — being called fake, or hurt, or attacked by people you used to love and look up to — and I have felt ostracized, like I don't belong.
What I regret is not a medical change, since I stopped short of hormones and surgery, but the three years of lost identity and the near-miss of permanent alterations. I am thankful every day that I stopped before medication or a mastectomy. My anger at the doctor turned into gratitude.
I think about transition for other people in a conditional way: I want people who are genuinely positive about it to still have access, but I want to help those who are lost, confused, or unstable avoid making decisions they will someday regret. I see a real problem with masc women and 'girly-boys' being forced into a gender stereotype, which I consider very homophobic — the erasure of lesbian women because they are 'too masc' gets to me. I have done informal advocacy by sharing my story, offering my DMs to others who are struggling, and telling people not to let society tell them what they want to be. I describe myself as Moderate / Independent politically; cancel culture and hate attacks don't work on me — I'm 'too old to care.' I believe trans people deserve rights but shouldn't erase the rights of others to exist, and I think internet forums and groups have led some people down a dark road they never would otherwise have gone down. I also worry about friends who say anyone with dysphoria should just 'go on T for a year,' because hormone therapy can't simply be undone — it's permanent. I have encouraged others to come off hormones and resume their lives, and I congratulate people on figuring themselves out rather than falling prey to social constructs pushed by social media.
I hold some strong views about gender and society: I feel women are told by society we're wrong and should just become men to fix our problems, and I argue that men control and own everything and make women's lives difficult. I don't fully understand why men would want to become women, since they wouldn't be gaining power by doing so. I don't think detransitioners are 'winning' for conservatives — rather, detransitioning has let me see the bigger picture and recognize that some conservative critiques have merit without agreeing with all of them. I believe most people in the trans movement have good intentions, but the movement has gotten mean and hateful toward the people who helped it. I also feel that being a detransitioner doesn't mean you're anti-trans, and the stigma needs to go away.