Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een vader van drie van 31 die bij de detrans-gemeenschap kwam omdat een vriend die een geslachtsoperatie had ‘door een levende nachtmerrie ging’, en ik ben zelf nooit getransitioneerd. Ik pleit ervoor dat mensen hun eigen keuzes maken, ontmoedig zelfbeschadiging en moedig detransitioners aan hun verhalen te vertellen zodat anderen vermijden wat mijn vrienden hebben meegemaakt. Ik ben zeer kritisch op wat ik zie als ideologisch gedreven, overhaaste transitiegeneeskunde, terwijl ik erken dat een geslachtsoperatie per geval enkelen kan helpen. Ik heb geen persoonlijke transitie, dysforie of spijt van mezelf beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have never described a personal transition or detransition in these posts; I came to the community as an outsider and supporter. I am 31 years old as of July 2019, I had my first child at 18, and I now have three children. I describe myself as 'just one guy with limited resources and three children of my own.'
I first arrived in the community because a friend of mine had bottom surgery and, in my words, 'is going through a living nightmare.' I have also spoken about another friend with high-functioning Asperger's who underwent SRS and now regrets it, telling him I thought his autism was likely the driver and that he 'became indoctrinated and did it anyways.' I say I have stories of a few friends at varying stages along the ideological path, and that each one I have known who went through with SRS regretted it — describing them as 'depressed, confused, feeling like they've been destroyed, both physically and resultant spiritually.'
My involvement is advocacy and encouragement rather than personal medical history. I am 'here just to give people encouragement to do what is right for them in their own view and discourage self-harm or worse,' and to 'show desperate people who feel lost a rationale for holding on despite how they were treated/manipulated into bad choices.' I am 'not here to judge, only to encourage positive actions, and redemption.'
I hold a strongly critical view of current transition medicine. I believe the medical establishment's approach 'seems like a direct contradiction to the Hippocratic oath,' and I argue that trans ideology is an ideology that values 'power itself over truth,' comparing community moderation to being 'unpersoned' as in Orwell's 1984. I do allow nuance: I think 'there are probably a handful of people who might in some manner benefit from SRS or whatever other treatments exist, on a case by case basis,' but I believe 'the current standard of wholesale treatment has gotten far too out of hand, it has also been politicized, and driven by ideology.' I also stress that 'so many just get rushed along.'
I have been an encouraging presence toward detransitioners who post their stories, praising one person for expressing resentment toward those responsible for their care 'without resorting to any sort of manifestation of vengeance,' and telling them they are 'choosing to be the hero others need.' I have urged people who have detransitioned to demand explanations from those who led them astray and then to 'talk to other trans people about the pitfalls of SRS,' saying 'I see every detrans as a potential super hero in the battle for truth and justice in our culture.' I have also congratulated people on 'finding yourself' and told a suicidal-seeming poster to 'please hold on' and that they are 'a valued person still,' framing redemption — not necessarily religious — as 'the foundational principle of western civilization.'
I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, hormones, surgery, mental health diagnoses, trauma, sexuality, or regret for myself in these posts. My identity and status outside of being a supportive community member with three children are not stated.