Alle verhalen

Niet detrans — gewoon een commentator met sterke opvattingen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd134
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben zelf nooit getransitioneerd of heb nooit dysforie gehad; ik ben een commentator aan de rand van de detransitie, een gekleurde vrouw en afstammeling van slaven in de VS, die ook klein is. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en betoog dat zelfmoordcijfers hetzelfde zijn met of zonder ingreep en dat de focus moet liggen op het behandelen van depressie in plaats van het vertrouwen op zelfdiagnose door patiënten. Ik verdedig sekse-gebonden taal (TIM/TIF), betoog dat operatieve modificaties de biologische sekse niet veranderen en steun datingvoorkeuren die transmensen uitsluiten. Ik steun detransitioners die gemeenschap en feedbackplekken zoeken. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of eigen transitie beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I have never transitioned myself, and I want to be clear that my involvement in these discussions comes from the perspective of a woman who has watched the transition debate from the outside and formed strong opinions about it. I am a woman of color and a descendant of slaves in the US, and I describe that as the only identity I have ever worn — it is not something I grew into or could turn on and off. I am also short, and I have lived with the practical consequences of that: it has cost me job opportunities and earnings, resulted in less respect, and on several occasions put me in physical danger, some of which ended in violence. My engagement with these questions has been mostly argumentative and analytical rather than autobiographical. I have pushed back against what I see as language that erases the category of biological femaleness, saying that certain framings take distinctions away from biological females and ironically reinforce what many of us find offensive about the trans movement, beyond the damage it is doing to so many young people. When someone born male has asked whether they should disclose their history to new love interests, I told them bluntly that a neovagina is not a vagina and that their past is really their now — that even the most fervent trans allies will see them as their biological sex for dating purposes. I compared such surgical modifications to choosing to get breast implants, and to artificial appendages like a faux fur tail, arguing that these are parts not found on biological males. I told one person they needed to be more honest with themselves before finding resolution, and that if lesbians and straight men are not interested in dating trans women, that is their prerogative. I defend the use of acronyms like TIM and TIF as accurate rather than transphobic, and I have argued at length that being born male equates to being male, that fat distribution and manner of dress do not make someone female, and that one can be respectful of another's self-expression while disagreeing with its validity. I compared being perceived as male to being perceived as short: I would not walk up to someone and say 'hey, you're a man,' but I do see such people as men, just as most people do, and I accept that most people perceive me as short. I rejected the charge of dehumanizing anyone, saying the term has been so abused it has become neutered of meaning, and that being not a woman does not make someone less human or less valid. I do not object to the term 'terf' provided it fits and is not used pejoratively. On medical transition, particularly for minors, I have argued that the suicide rate remains exactly the same with or without medical intervention before adulthood, and that the focus should be on addressing depression and suicidal ideation rather than trusting the self-diagnosis of the patient. I have also flagged what I found curious about a post identifying increased probability of being raped and lesser penalties for child molestation as positive reasons for transitioning. I am supportive of detransitioners finding venues to ask for feedback, saying I do not see the issue as long as there is a purpose to it, and I have noted that people who are de-transitioning do not have a lot of venues where they can ask for feedback on this sort of thing. I have also observed that I have seen people go out of their way to be as kind as possible to trans women who are being actively narcissistic, homophobic, and misogynist. I have some familiarity with the Orthodox Jewish community's treatment of members who leave — whether gay, trans, or choosing to marry a non-Jew or live a secularly — and I suggested to a person grieving a friend that there are support services available in Tel Aviv and probably Jerusalem, and that arguing about pronouns for a dead person is not a helpful outlet compared with working to provide better support services for those leaving those communities in Israel and in NYC. I have never described any dysphoria, transition, or detransition of my own; my account here is that of an observer and commentator.