Alle verhalen

Vijf jaar zonder testosteron, nog steeds als transvrouwelijk gezien

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd81
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die vanaf 2021 ongeveer vijf jaar geen testosteron meer gebruikt en wier lichaam volgens mij niet volledig is hersteld. Mijn seksualiteit verschoof tijdens de medische transitie en is na de detransitie niet teruggekeerd, en ik heb blijvende lichamelijke veranderingen waar ik mee worstel — een dieper wordende stem en een prominente adamsappel waardoor ik als transvrouwelijk word gezien, wat me van streek maakt. Ik ben kritisch over r/detrans vanwege vrouwenhaat en vijandigheid in de echokamer tegenover de transgemeenschap, terwijl ik non-binaire identificatie steun, evenals mensen die onomkeerbare veranderingen vermijden. Ik heb anderen afgeraden overhaaste medische beslissingen te nemen, en therapeuten die vrouwelijkheid opdringen als conversietherapie. Ik blijf transitie steunen voor wie die weloverwogen kiest, en ik heb spijt van de onomkeerbare veranderingen en de verloren tijd.

Volledig verhaal

I have been off testosterone for about five years as of mid-2021, and I wrote that I don't really feel my body has bounced back. I was curious about other people's results on estrogen and asked what effects they had noticed since starting it, wondering aloud whether I might need to go on estrogen myself. On sexuality, I said that I know lots of situations where someone's sexuality shifted through medical transition, and that mine did and has never really changed back despite detransition. I also warned someone considering transition that attraction is based on pheromones more than we realise, so changing your hormonal makeup will change your pheromones, and that even if a wife loves and supports you, there is no guarantee she will still have romantic or physical attraction to 'the new you'. I added that it won't really be her changing, it will be you changing, and she will grieve for the person she loved as she watches you change into someone else. I have experienced being read as male/masculine in a way that distresses me. In December 2021 I wrote that this happens to me a lot and that I think it is almost exclusively because of my voice/larynx, that I don't know what to do about it and that it is distressing. I noticed it happens more in queer-positive spaces and particularly how I am read by trans women, which I said is awkward because I feel like a phoney. I observed that it seems to be becoming more common as I present more femme — the more makeup I am wearing, the more likely I am to be read as a trans woman — and suggested that perhaps showing we can embrace our masculine energy/gender non-conforming traits and be comfortable as women with deep voices would help. In February 2022 I said my voice 'never got higher again, and somehow seems to be getting lower over the years. I hate it.' In April 2022 I said I was struggling with the same thing, '7 years later and I am being read as MTF more often, I feel like the Adams apple just keeps on growing!' I have had experience with sex work-adjacent finances and friendships: in February 2023 I mentioned that a lot of my friends are strippers or cam girls, and I discussed the practical realities of that work — that strippers make pretty good money but you have to be confident and good at flirting, which I would struggle with, that camming seems oversaturated, and that OnlyFans seems hard to make good money from and requires hard work at self-promotion. I defended sex work against shaming in that thread, saying 'sex work is real work' and calling the use of quotation marks around 'work' misogynistic. I have also discussed having a large clitoris, saying in December 2021 that I have never felt the need to explain it beforehand and that 'plenty of chicks have big clits!' I have been critical of the r/detrans community itself. In August 2021 I complained that the sub downvotes you if you disagree with anything no matter how reasonable, that 'It's as though we are expected to outright hate the trans community and anything less is unacceptable,' and that 'This sub was not always an echo-chamber like this.' In September 2022 I said that in this sub 'it's just about the raging misogyny.' In July 2021 I pushed back on the idea that trans communities are cults, arguing that the gay community, feminist community, punk community and goth community all tell you to cut off unsupportive people but then abandon you when you cease to identify with the subculture, and that I had personally been cut out of the gay community when I started a heterosexual relationship and lost most of my stoner friends when I stopped smoking weed. I have been supportive of non-binary identification among detransitioners, saying in October 2021 that lots of detrans people are nonbinary. In September 2026 I strongly supported someone who let people choose their name and pronouns and identify however they like without needing irreversible body changes, calling it 'the ideal' from a detrans perspective and 'a massive improvement', and saying this person has my support much more than the person judging them. I have given advice to others: I suggested someone stop spiro straight away and maybe taper down the estro rather than quitting cold turkey, which would probably just give mood swings/PMS-like symptoms but to ask a doctor if worried. I advised someone with a therapist pushing femininity that they don't have to be feminine or like men, that they can accept their body while rejecting gender roles, that there are lots of masculine women throughout history, and that their therapist sounded like they were doing gay conversion therapy — I suggested finding another therapist and exploring identity as a butch/masculine woman. I also said all people have masculine and feminine energy, that you can be female with masculine energy without needing a male body, and that you don't need to change anything. I asked a voice trainer thread for pointers for those who can't afford a voice trainer, saying I was 'a bit desperate'. I also commented that someone's voice recording sounded '100% female' and that their issue was clearly mental health rather than voice, so money for vocal coaches would be better spent on a therapist. In February 2025 I explained that estrogen should cause existing fat to redistribute without needing to lose and regain weight.