Alle verhalen

Een alien in een vleespak, geen man in het verkeerde lichaam

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar zich afvroeg of ik trans was vanwege BPS, autisme en ernstige dissociatie. Ik ben comfortabel als vrouw opgevoed, maar verloor mijn gevoel van identiteit naarmate ik ouder werd, voelde me 'een alien in een vleespak' en twijfelde aan mijn gender. Ik geloof nu dat de dissociatie en psychische aandoeningen, en niet echte genderdysforie, mijn trans-twijfels dreven. Ik ben kritisch over beweringen dat hormonen of operaties het biologische geslacht veranderen, en ik pleit ervoor de grondoorzaken zoals trauma en geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat aan te pakken in plaats van te transitioneren. Op dit moment werk ik eraan me op mijn gemak te voelen om te bestaan als mezelf zonder labels, al worstel ik nog met isolatie, het hebben van geen vrienden en een aanhoudend gevoel er niet bij te horen.

Volledig verhaal

I am a 26-year-old woman. I was born and raised female and never had a problem with it growing up — I was, in my words, the "stereotypical" girl, liking pink and purple and playing with dolls. I have breast implants because my natural breasts were small once I was fully grown. As I got older I was diagnosed with BPD and autism, and I lost my sense of identity. I described feeling like "an alien wearing a meat suit," unable to see or perceive myself clearly. I became deeply dissociated — I didn't feel like a person, didn't know who I was looking at or controlling in the mirror. During that time I sometimes questioned whether I was transgender or wanted to be a boy, and I didn't feel comfortable in my skin or very human. I later came to believe that this dissociation led me "to believe things about me that weren't true," including the idea that I might be trans. I also linked my confusion partly to attraction — I noticed I wanted to be the same gender as the people I was attracted to, and I developed fixations and an unhealthy view of myself because of my BPD and autism. I never took hormones or had any transition surgeries as far as my posts describe; the questioning stayed at the level of intrusive thoughts and identity confusion. I did ask others about health issues after testosterone and whether testosterone had "lobotimized" people's minds, because I'd heard that from detransitioners who started young on puberty blockers — but that was research, not my own experience. What pulled me out was realizing the dissociation and my mental health conditions were the root, not gender. I came to believe that for many people, dysphoria stems from trauma, internalized misogyny, or gender norms and expectations, and that once you address the root cause it fades over time as you focus on hobbies, travel, and making memories. I also reflected on how online spaces pushed me toward labels — I noted that before 2019 I thought gender and sex were the same thing, and only learned otherwise by spending time online, which I now see as an unhealthy obsession for many people. I have autism, which has made friendships with other girls hard — I said other women often see me as competition or a threat, and that women's friendships can be as two-faced as men's. I have zero friends and no real happiness despite being, by my own assessment, attractive. I've never been able to find love. I described my ex-boyfriend in detail (blond, blueish-grey eyes, delicate features) and reflected that attraction and appearance don't map neatly onto gender categories. I now hold critical views of aspects of modern trans activism, particularly claims that hormones or surgeries change biological sex. I believe sex is encoded deeply, including in bones and DNA, and can't be changed — only gender identity and physical appearance can. I think people should be able to live as whichever gender they like, but that it's not realistic to claim it's biological. I've pushed back on being called transphobic or a TERF for stating what I see as basic biology, and I've argued that transgender identity means identifying as a different gender from the one you were born, not changing your sex. I'm critical of how freely mastectomy is allowed and of doctors profiting from medical transition. I also believe the recent rise in young females transitioning may be linked to internalized misogyny or the belief that men have it easier. Currently I'm trying to feel more comfortable just existing. I wrote that maybe my issue isn't gender at all, but something relating to existing itself — that I'm afraid of existing and don't feel comfortable, and that not even transitioning fixes this, that I don't feel like I belong in this world as either a boy or a girl. I'm working on my appearance and body to feel better and trying to accept myself as simply a person without labels.