Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich non-binair identificeerde, ongeveer 15 maanden tot 2 jaar testosteron nam en topchirurgie had nadat ik tijdens een psychotische episode was getransitioneerd. Ik geloof nu dat mijn transitie werd gedreven door een extreem geval van het Peter Pan-syndroom, een verlangen naar een prepuberaal, „puur” lichaam en om aan seksualisering te ontsnappen, plus de echokamerinvloed van online groepen en YouTuber Ash Hardell. Ik detransitioneerde, aanvankelijk uitsluitend vanwege mijn christelijke geloof, en stopte met sessies bij een gendertherapeut van wie ik vond dat die bevooroordeeld was dat ik trans bleef, al ervaar ik nog steeds ernstige dysforie en ellende over onomkeerbare veranderingen, waaronder mijn stem en genitale groei. Ik heb gezegd: „Ik zie geen toekomst met mij erin”, al omschrijf ik mezelf ook als hoopvol dat ik een vol leven kan hebben. Ik ben kritisch over hoe achteloos transitie aan kwetsbare mensen wordt gepromoot en pleit ertegen voor kinderen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up feeling wrong in my body before I ever heard the word transgender. I was severely overweight, apple-shaped, tall, with a slightly deep voice, a C-cup by age 11, and I developed really fast. I was never dainty, had poor hygiene, was a slight tomboy, and desperately wanted to feel pretty but felt it wasn't in the cards for me. I didn't really have much of a childhood. I never felt like a girl or woman and was never feminine, but I also never got mistaken for a man.
My first real exposure to the idea of being trans came from YouTuber Ash Hardell, who became my first look into being non-binary. I identified as non-binary for years. In my old non-binary Facebook group, you basically couldn't play devil's advocate — you had to be 100% supportive or get labeled a troll, have your comment deleted, or your post not posted. I saw people wanting to transition after traumatic events like miscarriages or abusive spouses, and you couldn't say anything. Most seemed lonely or black sheep in their family and wanted community. I watched things get rapidly extreme with names and pronouns. At least three times a week I'd see someone saying they wanted top surgery or hormones while worried about effects, and everyone would downplay permanent changes — 'bottom growth takes a while,' 'if your voice gets deep there's vocal surgery,' 'if you get top surgery and don't like it you can get implants.'
I transitioned during a psychotic episode. I took testosterone for about 15 months (elsewhere described as 2 years) and had top surgery — my top surgery was over a year ago as of June 2022. I was happy with all the changes at first. I needed everyone to call me they/them, and my dysphoria suddenly changed and got stronger — I wanted to be viewed as a man, a bear specifically. The further I transitioned, the worse I felt being called a woman. I now think I was lying to myself long enough to convince myself I had dysphoria until I did. I wanted to feel valid — if I couldn't be a woman properly, I'd be the next best thing, a non-binary person. As a woman I was just straight, but as trans/non-binary I got to be trans and gay, which felt like earning more 'points' unintentionally.
I also believe my transition was about retaining youth — I now think I had an extreme case of Peter Pan syndrome. I cut off my breasts because I couldn't see myself as being pure with them; breasts felt so mature, like I would always be sexualized when I actually just wanted to be adorable and to appear soft. I thought I was striving for androgyny but really I wanted a prepubescent body. It felt like dysphoria to me. I don't think I regret it because I got what I wanted out of it.
After being medicated for the psychosis, I didn't feel the same way about my body anymore. I feel like I suddenly woke up with the wrong body. I'm so confused about what I am. I don't feel at peace with myself — mostly restless and frustrated with my body, and I've started covering up the mirrors in my home because I can't stand to look at myself. I feel disconnected. I worry I'll never appear delicate unless I'm underweight, and I ruminate on breastfeeding my non-existent children. When I look at women I feel like crying. I'm tall for a woman, so I don't even look like a feminine child. I hate the look of men's clothes but hate the comfort of what women are expected to wear. I still have no idea how to be female. I'm a nurturing person but that's about as far as my femininity goes. I feel like I'm going to miss out on being a woman even though I am one. I'm honestly scared for my life as someone who might appear as a Black trans woman.
On testosterone my voice was damaged — after a year I could still sound female but it sounded very unnatural, and I worried about vocal box damage and wondered about surgery to fix it. I have bottom growth from testosterone. In June 2022 I had a hookup and didn't tell him I was detransitioned; he pointed out my genitalia ('baby penis') and said he didn't feel ok touching it, which upset me after I'd been doing better. Intimacy post-testosterone is embarrassing for me.
I detransitioned. I was always happy to continue my transition but I never felt peace. While trans I'd get misgendered a lot; now I guess I'm correctly gendered, but I feel like I let people down, worried they'll use this to invalidate other trans people. My gender therapist seemed biased toward me staying trans despite me initially coming to them for detransitioning, so I ended our sessions. When I say I'm not trans, people tell me I'm confused or just struggling. Everyone around me doesn't buy that I'm detransitioning.
As of January 1, 2023, I'm detransitioning solely due to religious beliefs — I'm Christian and was seeking conversion therapy if I could find no other support. I still have bad dysphoria and hope it lessens over time. I had top surgery and 2 years of testosterone but still believe I can have a full life; I'm hopeful. I was starting to get excited about growing facial hair and getting bottom surgery, but the feeling of being inherently wrong became stronger, and nobody recognized me as male anyway. A strange thing: every time I tried to stop my testosterone I'd find myself mindlessly taking it, like I lost control over my hands; I'm trying my hardest not to pick up my prescription. I'm already worried about getting mistaken for MTF.
I've been active in the detrans community, commenting on others' posts about reverse dysphoria ('Reverse dysphoria is probably a much stronger feeling than gender dysphoria ever was') and criticizing people who say others 'got themselves into this mess.' I've ranted about echo chambers and how transition is treated as if it's not permanent. I've also observed that many women want to be boys but not men — hoping for a prepubescent look — and that there's no androgyny for men, no safe space for men to open up. I've said I don't see a future with me in it. I don't think transition should be offered so casually to vulnerable people, and I believe children can't make permanent decisions about names and pronouns.