Alle verhalen

Op haar 60e uit de kast bij de familie — en een dochter noemt haar een bigot

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd827
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw — 60 jaar, pro-choice, niet-religieus, lesbisch en gender-kritisch radicaal feministe, die ongeveer 30 jaar geleden zonder operatie detransitioneerde. Ik groeide eind jaren 1980 op in San Francisco in radicale kringen waar biseksualiteit werd gestigmatiseerd, en mijn eerste vriendin transitioneerde in 1987. In 2025 kwam ik openlijk uit voor mijn gender-kritische standpunt bij familie en vrienden, nam verlof van mijn werk om een boek te schrijven over hoe ik gender-kritisch radicaal feministe werd, en begon detransitioners te interviewen. Ik heb EDS met meerdere operaties, twee dochters (van wie er een me een bigot noemt vanwege mijn opvattingen), en ik pleit tegen medische transitie voor minderjarigen en voor op therapie gebaseerde detransitie-ondersteuning en juridische verantwoording. Ik blijf een overtuigd liberaal, hoewel ik MAGA word genoemd, en ik voer campagne om het gender-kritische standpunt naar de politieke Linkerzijde te brengen.

Volledig verhaal

I am a 60-year-old lesbian and gender critical radical feminist who detransitioned roughly two to three decades ago, and I have never had any surgery. I was born female and have always been female-bodied — I describe myself as naturally very flat-chested, 'flat as a pancake,' thin with no curves, and I joke I 'would have probably made a good boy.' I also have PCOS, which means people sometimes ask me if I'm a trans man, though never if I'm a man. My detransition happened around 30 years before February 2026, so approximately the mid-1990s; elsewhere I said I detransitioned '2 decades ago,' so the timing is roughly consistent with the mid-1990s to early 2000s. I did not have surgery during my transition, and I'm grateful for that. I've never described the details of my original transition in these posts — only that it happened and that I reversed it without surgical intervention. I grew up in San Francisco and spent my adolescence there in the late 1980s. That environment shaped me profoundly: I said it 'was simply not acceptable to be BI or to have male friends' in the groups I was part of, and that 'in order to be part of the gang we had to be man hating lesbians or we'd not be accepted.' I also said I 'always felt more bi than gay' and was 'literally ridiculed and ostracized for any BI behavior.' I was in a pretty radical group growing up and was consumed in college with the issue of FGM, when people tried to tell me it was cultural and not my fight. My first girlfriend transitioned in 1987 — that was a big deal to me and we broke up over it; she never spoke to me again, so I never saw the end result. My best friend married Buck Angel 33 years ago, later married a trans woman (Lana Wachowski/Karin Winslow). I came out as gender critical to my Facebook friends and family around early March 2025, describing it as 'really heavy' and saying I'd only 'peaked' and gone public with my views two weeks prior. I've been called MAGA despite campaigning heavily against Trump for eight years and campaigning for far-left politics my whole life; I grew up in San Francisco, was in a pretty radical group, live in a blue state, and voted for Jill Stein. I describe myself as a 'leftie liberal gender critical gal,' a 'pro choice, non-religious, lesbian,' and a single-issue voter around abortion. I resent that trans issues got tied to abortion issues via Planned Parenthood doing both, which I believe contributed to losing abortion rights. I have two daughters: one 16 and one 15. My 15-year-old daughter is very pro-trans and thinks I'm a bigot, which is hard for me; my 16-year-old agrees it seems to have been a phase with many of her friends. I took a month's leave from my job in March 2025 to write a book about my journey to becoming a gender critical radical feminist, and I've been interviewing detransitioners for it (anonymous unless they want to be public). I work from my couch. I have EDS (Ehlers-Danlos syndrome), which I've known about for 35 years, with multiple fusions (neck and toe), a badly torn knee requiring ACL/MCL and meniscus repair, and lots of dislocations; strength training is central to my life and I say I'm doing very well post-surgery. I have struggled with motivation at times — some days I can barely get off the couch — but I've been setting small goals, like organizing my sewing space to be creative and sell things I make. I was a stripper for over a decade when young; I miss the power and excitement and the lifelong friends, but I wouldn't choose that path again and feel I wasted the best years of my life. I've been attracted to effeminate men like David Bowie, and I describe myself as a 'fem-ish lesbian who loves butch women' elsewhere and as a 'masc lesbian' — the two descriptions coexist in my posts. On transition itself: I'm opposed to medical transition for minors, describing it as 'cutting off healthy body parts' and 'becoming medically castrated,' and I believe kids can't consent. I advocate for therapy and group support rather than just shutting down clinics, and I've encouraged detransitioners to contact detransition-oriented law firms (Campbell Miller Payne, Jordan Law) for free confidential consultations and to join lawsuits. I wrote to Democracy Now about the lack of liberal media coverage of detransition stories and never heard back. I'm active in LGB and gender critical groups on Facebook and Instagram (including 'actual gender critical left'), though I find some GC spaces hateful. I believe most male trans people are straight men with a kink (AGP), citing the askAGP subreddit, and I view trans activism as dishonest. I see social contagion as driving young female transition, comparing it to anorexia/bulimia, cutting, and false memory syndrome. I support detransitioners warmly and encourage young masculine lesbians to embrace butch identity rather than transition, citing the scarcity of butch role models.