Alle verhalen

Een dozijn transvrienden, en één jaar identiteit

Vrouw · GedesisteerdSociale transitie 21 → Desistance 22590
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich rond 2017-2018 ongeveer een jaar als non-binair/genderqueer identificeerde en nooit medisch getransitioneerd is. Ik raakte trans-geïdentificeerd te midden van misbruik, verwarring over mijn seksuele oriëntatie en neurodivergentie, binnen een vriendengroep van meer dan een dozijn trans-geïdentificeerde mensen. Meerdere transvrouwen in die kring hebben mij en anderen seksueel aangerand of geprobeerd aan te randen, wat mijn latere opvattingen heeft gevormd. Ik heb nu sterk gendercritische en radicaalfeministische opvattingen en omschrijf transactivisme als in wezen een mannenrechtenbeweging gedreven door porno en autogynefilie. Ik verloor daarbij de meeste van mijn links georiënteerde vriendschappen, maar zie dat als iets positiefs.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and identified as trans — non-binary/genderqueer — for close to a year, roughly around 2018. During that period my entire friend group was trans-identified: I knew over a dozen people who were various flavors of trans, and that circle was my whole social world. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers — and I desisted, coming out of that identity around 2018. Looking back, I attribute my becoming trans-identified to several things I've named directly: abuse, my sexual orientation, and neurodivergence. I've also said that when I was identifying as trans and that was my whole social circle, the majority of trans women I knew were, in my reading, blatant autogynephiles — and I've argued that a big part of the current surge in males identifying as trans is driven by porn, hypersexualized anime, and Discord. Several of the trans women in my group either sexually assaulted me or other females in the group, or attempted to. A couple of them called any woman who wouldn't sleep with them a TERF. I described their behavior as "unbelievably male," said I only ever saw evidence of "dysphoria" when it was being used as a cudgel ("I can't do the dishes/get a job/act appropriately/etc etc etc because muh dysphoria"), and noted rampant porn addiction and obsession with pedophilic anime girls among them. I also noticed clothing signals — the AGP skirt, striped thigh-high socks, identifying as a cat or puppygirl. While identifying as trans, I absorbed the movement's beliefs about radical feminists: I believed TERFs were bloodthirsty, violent, hateful, and above all dangerous. I now say none of the stories I heard ever came with proof — they were "make believe scare tactics, repeated around like an endless game of telephone dressed up as activism." I've said I was "basically you about two years ago" to someone frightened of TERFs, in a May 2020 exchange. After desisting I moved into radical feminist thinking. I've described radical feminists as ordinary women from all walks of life with strong boundaries, and said no TERF I've known has committed an act of violence, though I can't say the same for trans activists — I knew a lesbian woman who was beaten up at a bar by three trans activists unprovoked. I've stated plainly that "Nearly all the transwomen I've known have been straight (female-attracted)." I've also said that many males transition because of a fetish, and that this makes their situation "a whole other beast" from what females like me experience, changing my willingness to help them or feel qualified to. I've been open about the fact that I didn't keep all of my super-lefty friends after detransitioning, and on reflection I see losing them as a good thing because they were "exhausting people to be around." I've told another person going through the same that it's hard but that the wool has been pulled off their eyes. I hold strongly critical views of pornography and what I call a sick society "full of sex addicts, perverts, and the like," and I've argued that trans women are, in essence, a men's rights movement — "It's literally just a men's rights movement. I wish more of my fellow women could see this." In June 2022 I was upset when Google put a Pride flag widget on my phone's homescreen without asking. I said every time I see that flag it reminds me of everything I went through and suffered "at the hands of people in that community," and I wanted it gone. I found it inappropriate for a tech megacorporation to push a political statement on users' phones, comparing it to putting a candidate's theme on devices. I eventually found a way to remove it. I've engaged with other detransitioned and desisted women online, reassuring one that despite a naturally deeper voice she sounds "unquestionably female," and telling another "You look female to me." I've recommended red light therapy and topical caffeine for hair growth, noting I use a panel at home that thickened my eyebrows and filled in my hairline. I've also argued forcefully about male violence against women globally — sex trafficking, FGM, femicide, restrictions on women's rights — and dismissed claims that women hold power over men beyond sexual refusal. I do not appear to have pursued any advocacy or activism formally; my engagement has been through online discussion. I experience regret centered on what I went through at the hands of that community and the friendships I lost, though I frame the lost lefty friendships positively. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or medical complications, since I never medically transitioned.