Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die van mijn 16e tot ongeveer mijn 20e-21e als transvrouw leefde, twee jaar spironolacton nam (een jaar zonder oestrogeen) en ongeveer een jaar oestrogeen, zonder operaties. Ik detransitioneerde over ongeveer anderhalf jaar nadat ik rond mijn 20e ‘uit mijn waanideeën ontwaakte’, en het kostte me bijna drie jaar om het zelfvertrouwen terug te krijgen om zonder shirt in het openbaar te komen met mijn lichte A-cup borstgroei. Ik identificeer me nu als biseksuele man met een onderdanige aard en een voorkeur voor mannen maar een verlangen om bij een vrouw te zijn, en ik ben alleen intiem geweest met mannen. Ik dank veel aan therapie bij een psychiater die van bevestiging naar neutraliteit verschoof, en ik blijf hem zien. Ik blijf in contact met de detransitiegemeenschap en geef advies over geduld met het lichaam, de risico's van doe-het-zelf-hormonen en het belang van jonge mensen hun ware motivaties te laten ontdekken vóór medische stappen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and first became seriously fixated on transitioning around age 16, when I was consumed by confusion and a strong desire not to go through with what I called a 'male puberty' — essentially rejecting what my body had planned for me. Another part of my reasoning was how combative my father was about the whole thing; I became wrapped up in opposing him. I began transition at 16 and it ran until about 20 or 21.
I got my HRT the 'official' way through a psychiatrist, Dr Reiche of Alberta, Canada, and I had slightly more accepting family than some. Initially almost all I was given from him was affirmation, but once I began expressing doubt and discomfort he quickly shifted to a very neutral role, often asking about my current view on my gender and whether there had been changes. I've stayed with him ever since I began medical transition and intend to keep seeing him so that detransitioned individuals are not a complete outlier in his practice.
On the medical side: I was on Spironolactone for two years — one of those years without any estrogen, which I think is why I was so heavily out of whack at that point in my life — and then spiro/estradiol, with estrogen for just under a year total (elsewhere I've said 'only a year on hrt'). I had no surgeries. During my time on T blockers and estrogen my beard grew far slower and patchier, but once I gave up HRT it filled in very quickly. I ended up with minor breast growth, barely A cups, which is still enough to occasionally cause me some discomfort, particularly around swimming where I get unsure if I can dare go shirtless. On sexual function, I had one year of only spiro and then another year of spiro/estradiol, and from what I can tell I've gotten full erectile function back; I believe that if you used it a lot less than before HRT, function will be worse after stopping and remain worse for longer, whereas regular use mostly just results in loss of size.
I also noticed how much of my presentation was learned or performed. I became friends with someone whose parents were Vietnamese/Chinese and her whole family made an 'ayah' sound when something unexpected happened; I picked it up quickly without realizing it, and when we stopped visiting as often — coinciding with COVID — I found I had completely dropped it as a habit. That realization 'really did a number on my transition confidence.' I also felt I was acting during my entire transition, with all my goals based off male perspectives on female qualities; half the time it was because I found the women around me attractive and felt a need to imitate them, while also desperately wanting male attention in the way they could get it. My father used to criticize me for being excessive with skimpy clothes and acting self-centered in a single-minded desire to 'be my own person,' which I hated hearing at the time but which cut close.
There was also a deeply held desire to be 'slutty,' which I had for my entire life associated with women only, so to act that way I'd have to become a woman. Pretty quickly during transition I fell into a lot of kink stuff more or less by proximity, mingling in that subset of the trans community. I wouldn't say the kink contributed much to me beginning transition, but it definitely held me in longer than I'd otherwise have stayed.
Roughly around age 20 was when I 'snapped out of my delusions.' My detransition took around a year and a half, most of which I hadn't even admitted to anyone I was decided on it. Coming out again was a very difficult process, and more so the longer you've transitioned; I'd advise easing into the decision rather than making it a big sudden change. It's taken me almost three years from the end of transition to gain the confidence to go shirtless in public.
On dating and sexuality post-detransition: I haven't really tried to date anyone since detransitioning. The closest I've had is hooking up with a guy I'd previously hooked up with as a trans girl, who was just as pleasant and respectful as before, and who enjoyed my new chest hair, which made me feel a lot of things. I describe myself as a bisexual with a preference for males but an undeniable desire to be with a woman — I don't fit the role of a straight guy who can pick up women, so my best chance at a girlfriend would be a woman who takes the pursuer role; otherwise I'll be with dominant men who enjoy my submissive nature. That doesn't make me a woman, it makes me a bisexual with a preference for males. As a submissive male I'm searching for a minority of a minority in a dominant woman, which is why I've only ever been intimate with men. I've only encountered women of the type I'd prefer while I was fully transitioning; I don't know how to meet them as a man, unlike how I used to meet them as a trans woman who envied whoever they chose to be intimate with but lacked the courage to say I liked them.
I've also reflected on the political and social context. I began transition by being pulled by far-left ideas, and once immersed I got nervous that friends might see what I watched on YouTube — I'd just begun watching Joe Rogan's podcast. As I immersed myself in media I'd previously feared, I learned I could leave YouTube open around left-leaning friends; nobody got on my case, and I grew to love the podcast. My friend group ranges from tankie-esque people to stringent capitalist business owners, and none of them would disown me for not supporting every trans person. I've also expressed sadness at threads where a young person managed to find and buy estrogen without their parents even knowing, with almost nobody questioning DIY. I've advised parents to set a hard line at hormonal and surgical changes so a child has time to process their own choices and discover the true motivations behind them.
More recently, I kept the denim purse I'd had from mid-transition — I've had it roughly eight years and have had to repair it a few times. I've described the emotional process of detransition as being like trying to walk with a big rubber band holding you back: it's extra hard to feel an emotion is safe to show, and once you pull hard enough you get a snap back and everything comes out all at once whether you want it to or not. I've also noted that returning to being a man has taught me patience with my body — things didn't all happen at once, and expecting them to only leaves a sour taste.