Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/adaptieve MtF-persoon, als man geboren, die in 2001 op mijn 40e transitioneerde, een orchidectomie en uitgebreide gezichtsoperaties onderging en later met oestrogeen stopte omdat ik er dik, zwak en mentaal beneveld van werd, en het verving door zeer laag gedoseerd methyltestosteron onder een nieuwe endocrinoloog. Ik liet ook een gynaecomastie-operatie doen om de borstgroei terug te draaien en heb mijn vrouwelijke presentatie teruggeschroefd: ik draag geen make-up meer en het maakt me niet uit welk geslacht mensen aannemen, al houd ik mijn gekoesterde vrouwelijke naam. Ik heb geen spijt van de orchidectomie of de gezichtsoperaties, alleen van het oestrogeen, en ik voel me nu weer slank, sterk en helder. Ik ben psychiatrisch verpleegkundige, ouder dan 50 (misschien 60), ben al ruim 20 jaar openlijk trans, en pleit nu voor zorgvuldige, zelfgefinancierde transitie alleen voor volwassenen, terwijl ik me sterk verzet tegen medische transitie van jongeren.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and started my transition journey in 2001 at the age of 40, coming out as trans and living as a woman. I worked for IBM and was out at work as trans, and between 2001 and 2005 I met and socialized with many trans people in Atlanta, attended trans conventions, helped plan one, and got involved in politics. I started anti-androgens (spironolactone) around 2002 and took spiro for 3-4 years, then had a bilateral orchiectomy in 2005 at age 40-45 (I have said both 40 and 45 in different posts). I never wanted SRS. I also had extensive facial work: rhinoplasty, forehead surgery, full facial electrolysis (which I still get occasionally), a facelift, and an otoplasty. I also had gynecomastia from estrogen, which I hated, and later had surgery to correct it (about $5,000, roughly 8 years before 2023, so around 2015). I never changed my voice; when trans friends pushed me to feminize it, I told them I would rather sound intelligent than feminine.
What moved me toward stepping back was health. After the orchi I stayed on estrogen and rapidly gained about 20 pounds, developed gynecomastia that made me look like 'a 60 year old obese man,' became so weak I could not lift a 45-pound empty barbell or change a flat tire, and had brain fog - I described myself as 'fat, weak and stupid' after 12 months of estradiol. My endocrinologist had no answers. I eventually found a new endocrinologist who took me off estrogen and put me on very low dose methyltestosterone, 2.5 mg a day. Over time my bone density and cardio came back, weight came down, hair stayed, and I got back to being lean, strong and clear-headed - I said I was in as good athletic shape as ever, strongest I have ever been. I had been able to bench press 150 pounds while presenting as a woman before estrogen. I also expanded my workouts to include more cardio and weights.
Beyond the medical reversal, I realized I was tired of the daily constant lust and arousal the anti-androgens and orchi had ended - that was actually the main reason I wanted the orchi in the first place. I got tired of wearing makeup and realized I was perfectly happy with what I saw in the mirror when I woke up. I got over being called ma'am. I found the effort of maintaining full-time feminine presentation tiring and not worth what I was putting into it. Being female 24/7 was just not for me anymore. I don't wear makeup anymore, and I now go through life not caring what gender people think I am. I have said I did not really detransition but rather stopped HRT because of the health effects and scaled back my presentation - an adaptation rather than a full detransition. I still use my feminine name as my email address and consider it a cherished name I picked with deeply personal meaning; when asked my pronouns I say 'I don't do pronouns.' I have a flair on the forum that says 'detrans male' but I say I could care less about reddit tags.
I have been openly trans for 20+ years and have known probably over 1000 MTFs and hundreds of stories personally. I have seen marriages end, friends with regrets, friends with peace, friends abused by other trans people, and friends involved with drugs. I did not like where the trans community was going with victimhood and the involvement of children. I am a medical professional - I have said I work as a nurse in mental health, that I work in hospital healthcare, and that I have worked in psychiatry for over a decade with many autistic, aspergers and identified transgender people. I have autism in my family. I am over 50 (and in one 2023 post said I am 60 years old and athletic). I have a deceased father whose approach I said could have used 'a little more Mr. Rogers.'
I do not regret the orchi or the face surgery, but I regretted taking estrogen. I had to search to find an endocrinologist who would take me off estrogen and put me on methyltestosterone, and I had gynecomastia surgery. I looked my best as a woman before I started estradiol because I had a lean muscle body, and I finally got back there, stronger than ever. The least of my worries today is about being trans because I finally found a real comfort spot. I have said I am in love as of May 2023.
I have been active in the detrans forum giving advice, and I have strong opinions about transition for others. I support careful, planned transition by adults but strongly oppose teen and pre-teen medical transition, puberty blockers, and publicly funded transition. I think autism is over-diagnosed and that the autism-trans link is weak. I believe HRT is essentially triggering endocrinological disease and that people should have an off-ramp and pay for their own care. I advise people to be sure they are done with erections and sexual activity before starting anti-androgens, and I warn that orchi is permanent and ends reliable erectile function. I have debated people on the forum who questioned whether I was really trans, eventually posting an intro with photos from 2001 and 2005 to prove it. I have also posted about a podcast of a parent's regretting transitioning their child and shared the essay 'So You Want To Be a T-Girl.' I have no mental health diagnoses mentioned, no mention of suicidal ideation or self-harm, and no mention of trauma or adversity in my own life beyond the general difficulties of aging and health. My sexuality before transition and now is not clearly stated, though I have referenced having given up on women by 45 and being content to sleep with a cat, and more recently being in love.