Alle verhalen

Een homoseksuele veteraan op r/detrans die nooit transitioneerde

Man · Gedesisteerd1,9K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee, ik ben een homoseksuele man die nooit is getransitioneerd; ik heb me altijd als man en homo geïdentificeerd, en ik blijf een oudere homoseksuele bondgenoot en supporter op r/detrans. Ik kwam op mijn 17e uit, diende van 1978 tot 1984 in het leger, voedde twee jongens op en heb de afgelopen jaren detransitioners gesteund, terwijl ik betoog dat de radicale transbeweging een sekte en een rage is. Ik ben tegen medische transitie voor iedereen onder de 18, voor het scheiden van LGB van T+, en steun verder het recht van transmensen om te leven zoals ze willen. Ik heb geen eigen transitie of detransitie om spijt van te hebben, maar ik ben uitgesproken over verloren rechten, verbannen subreddits zoals r/RightwingLGBT en wat ik zie als dwang van jonge mensen. Ik blijf actief, politiek betrokken en steun deze gemeenschap.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and I have always known I was male; I never had any thoughts or questions about my birth sex or about transitioning. I came out as gay when I was 17 and have lived as openly as I could ever since, including six years in a branch of the US military between 1978 and 1984. Coming out to my childhood friend in our late teens went very badly, and back in the 1980s when I said I was a gay man I had to explain that not all gay men were into choker collars, leashes and ass-less chaps. I grew up in a large, close family on the East Coast — I was the oldest grandchild of 18 on one side and in the middle of 27 grandchildren on the other, with four siblings, both sets of grandparents, a great-grandmother, five uncles and six aunts. I did not get 'The Talk' at home, but my school separated the boys and girls for fairly detailed, strictly hetero-based sex education classes that required parental permission. I am in my late 50s, I am a disabled person, and I am about 40 pounds heavier than I would like to be. I describe myself as a mostly conservative-minded but moderate gay man. I have raised boys — my youngest was 9 months old when his biological father and I began living together as gay lovers, and my biological son had known my now-ex lover since he was 1 year old. Neither of my boys ever acted on the homosexuality that older anime was once blamed for. I bartended in a gay club in my younger years and had a close circle of lesbian friends, including one I called my Babushka. I came to r/detrans as a lurker and rare contributor — an older gay man offering support, an ear and a shoulder to people making the difficult decision to detransition. I have never transitioned or considered transitioning, and I have never encouraged anyone to detransition; I believe it is not my place as a gay man to judge or convince anyone. Over time I moved from short supportive replies to deeper discussions, though I admit I like to debate and can get political, and I have had to remind myself where I am. I have been active in the sub for around five months as of April 2020, having been on Reddit slightly more than eight months by then. My central and repeated belief is that the radicalized, vocal minority of the trans movement behaves like a cult — they groom, recruit, indoctrinate, instruct people what to say to doctors and write on medical forms, alienate members from friends and family, and shun and harass those who leave, including detransitioners. I have been calling the T+ group a cult for a few years now. I think the huge spike in FtM transitioners — I have seen figures of a 700–900% jump since 2010 — is more like a group clique or fashion fad, driven by social media, anime, and online self-diagnosis of dysphoria brought to doctors. I am strongly opposed to medical or surgical transitioning before 18, though I am fine with social experimentation for teenagers, and I want laws or insurance decisions to stop minors being prescribed hormones and blockers. I am not against anyone personally: I will fight for a trans person's right to live as they wish as long as they do not interfere with how I and my family live, and I have told trans posters directly that they are valid and that I would stand in the street beside them. I am, however, part of the growing movement to separate the LGB community from the T+ group, because same-sex attraction has little to do with gender identity — a separation of ideology, not of people. I was an active member of r/RightwingLGBT until it was banned in June 2020, and I have warned this sub to have a backup plan. I was perma-banned from r/gaymers for a similar post. I have also been critical of the DSM-5's removal of gender identity disorder, arguing it will cut off mental health care, insurance coverage and disability payments for trans people. I try to offer practical advice: research both sides, get second opinions, talk to more than one doctor, try things out before committing, and remember that detransitioning is a huge step that requires more thought than some people put into transitioning in the first place.