Alle verhalen

Twaalf jaar op hormonen, en opzien tegen het papierwerk

Man · Gedetransitioneerd78
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben als man geboren, leefde ruim tien jaar als vrouw (ongeveer 12 jaar op hormonen en in 2019 zo'n 10 jaar na genitale chirurgie), en had in 2019 geconcludeerd dat ik niet trans ben en dat detransitioneren moreel, cultureel en persoonlijk het juiste is. Ik werd tegengehouden door de sociale schaamte om mijn coming-out terug te draaien, het praktische gedoe van het wijzigen van mijn naam en documenten, de angst mijn relatie te beschadigen (die al onder druk stond door mijn depressie) en het feit dat ik me niet als iets wilde „identificeren” of mensen opnieuw om andere voornaamwoorden wilde vragen. Ik ging goed door als vrouw en was niet bang om verkeerd aangesproken te worden; mijn echte angst was in verband te worden gebracht met wat ik het „sekteachtige groepsdenken” van trans noemde en met de vermeende slechte dienst aan vrouwen. Ik beschreef mezelf als depressief, waarbij de depressie mijn relatie waarschijnlijk schaadde, maar gaf verder geen details over mijn geestelijke gezondheid. In januari 2019 leefde ik nog als vrouw en was ik nog niet met detransitie begonnen; ik zag mezelf als een man vóór de detransitie die zich niet langer als trans identificeerde.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and, in my own words, I am not trans and not female. I began identifying as trans and living as a woman roughly in my early-to-mid twenties: by January 2019 I was in my 30s, had been on feminizing hormones for about 12 years, and had been "post op" (genital surgery) for nearly a decade — which places the surgery and the start of hormones around 2007-2010, though I have not given exact dates. By 2019 I had come to the conclusion that I needed to detransition. I wrote that I don't believe I'm trans or female, that I "can't stand the transgender movement / community / cult," and that I was "extremely embarrassed that I ever put myself and my family through this." I judged detransitioning to be "the right thing to do, morally, culturally, and personally," but said I wasn't sure I had "the heart, guts, and energy for it." What held me back was largely social and practical. Coming out originally had been "awkward as hell," and the prospect of doing it again in reverse felt even worse; I worried it would torpedo my relationship, though I felt my depression was probably doing that anyway. I also said I didn't want to "identify" as anything anymore — the thought of asking people to use male pronouns was horrifying, and going gender-neutral seemed like an attention grab, which was part of my disillusionment with the trans community in the first place ("the whole act of telling people what you are and how they must refer to you is incredibly obnoxious"). I had already resigned myself to never being in another relationship, so being a "man with a "vagina"" wasn't my main worry — rather, I couldn't imagine ever being able to explain that to anyone and felt it would have to be something I took to the grave. My driver's license still showed a very feminine name and a photo of a more feminine me from about 10 years earlier, and changing that would feel like going through a transition/detransition process all over again. For close family, detransition would feel like an "undoing," whereas for friends and coworkers who'd never known me any other way it would feel like a new transition. In terms of passing and daily life, I said I pass just fine and have for many years; I used to put a lot of effort into it but no longer do, and still get "she/her" about 9-95% of the time (I noted I might be in a very liberal part of the country where trans-inclusive language is common). I didn't correct anyone. The fear wasn't about being misgendered — it was about being associated with "the entire trans cult-like hive mind of mental illness" and what I saw as the disservice trans women do to actual women and their struggle for equality and rights. I also said I had literal nightmares about people thinking I was an MTF trans person who would screech at being misgendered or try to infiltrate women-only spaces, and I wondered whether coworkers who supposedly didn't know about my past thought of me that way. Mentioned but not elaborated: I described myself as depressed and said the depression was likely damaging my relationship. I did not describe therapy, specific diagnoses, trauma, or medication. I received encouragement from others considering detransition and responded warmly ("good to know that there's people like me even in a tiny minority of a tiny minority"), and I noted that "not being embarrassed about doing what I think is right shouldn't be as hard as it feels." As of my last comments in January 2019, I was still living as a woman, still on hormones, and contemplating but had not yet begun detransition; my current identity at that point was effectively a detransitioning or pre-detransition male who no longer identified as trans.