Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een als man geboren, twijfelende aspirant-transitioner die nooit met hormonen begon of sociaal transitioneerde. In juni 2021 plaatste ik op r/detrans een bericht waarin ik een MtF-transitie overwoog, grotendeels gemotiveerd door de wens van makkelijkere sociale relaties als leraar, maar na de discussie concludeerde ik dat HRT ‘voorlopig van de baan’ was. Ik heb een geschiedenis van depressie (zelfgediagnosticeerd, zonder medicatie verdwenen), een gewelddadige opvoeding, mogelijk hoogfunctionerend autisme of ADHD (betwist), en ik herleid een groot deel van mijn ‘dysforie’ tot FaceApp. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen gehad en mijn huidige identiteit is die van een twijfelende man die neigt naar man blijven (‘het leven als verwijfde man is prima’), terwijl ik erken dat de wens om te transitioneren kan blijven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and, as of June 2021, I was questioning whether to transition, posting on r/detrans under the title 'MtF questioning with danger signs for future regret.' I never started hormones; I wrote that I had gone for blood tests and could have begun HRT within a couple of weeks, but by the end of that week I concluded, 'HRT is off the table for now' and 'I'm not going down the HRT route anymore.'
Looking back, I told the community that a lot of my 'dysphoria' seemed to have been created by FaceApp: 'From that literal moment, the next thing I googled was how accurate faceapp can be. Here I am a few months later obsessed.' I said the desire to be female had 'mostly went away after discovering erections' when I was young, but it resurfaced later. I also said I actually liked my slim body and face as a man: 'I'm healthy, fit, good genes, with a nice feminine physique I can enjoy... If I think I look good as a guy, why should I risk transitioning?'
My main stated reason for considering transition was social: I expected 'social interaction is the number 1 thing' to improve, and I thought being a woman would make it easier to socialize with the students I hoped to teach. I planned to become a secondary math teacher (18 credits into a bachelor's degree, done online) and wanted to go 'completely 100% stealth once I get my bachelors.' I worried that transitioning could actually worsen my social ability while passing as 'an oddly proportioned woman.'
I described a difficult upbringing: 'I became a pathetic nerd with abusive parents,' made zero friends, was a straight-A student because 'grades was my only real dopamine,' and had occasional thoughts of cutting my penis off 'because I knew how much erections made me socially awkward in high school.' I self-diagnosed depression and later said my father admitted the abuse, saying 'he was the reason for my depression a year ago after diagnosing myself.' I treated the depression without antidepressants — using exercise, diet, sleep, goals, challenges, eye contact, and 4+ cups of coffee — and said it was 'completely gone... for now at least.' My way out included realizing 'I'm never going to have the confidence to kill myself. I am stuck on this planet till a natural cause of death,' so I could choose not to be miserable. I did not describe any suicide attempt.
Several commenters suggested I might be autistic. I reacted aggressively at first, then conceded: 'turns out there's literally a form of autism called high functioning autism.... which I meet a hella lot of symptoms for. Except empathy.' I noted I'd been called Sheldon from Big Bang Theory 'over a dozen times.' Later I reversed again, saying my parents and siblings all said I'm not autistic and that two online tests gave me 'the lowest risk for it,' and I told commenters to 'go fuck yourself' for persisting with the autism idea. I also floated ADHD: 'Could be ADHD. Idk. Basically, I'm just different.'
I held strongly stated views about gender, writing that I 'have and will always continue to believe women are the superior gender in an era of indoor work and mental ability,' that women have stronger academic abilities, and that men are more susceptible to loneliness and depression. I acknowledged being 'sexist in a way.' I was hostile to the subreddit at times, writing 'This entire subreddit is completely oblivious to the positives of transitioning' and defending the legitimacy of medical transition, while also saying 'Trans subreddits cannot be trusted and I can't trust doctors on this topic.'
By late June 2021 I was leaning toward staying male: 'Ya I'm thinking the fem man life is fine. That's probably better than going trans,' and I said I was 'exploring now I can connect more with people emotionally as a dude.' I mentioned that if I stayed a man I'd want 'a toupee, laser hair removal on the body, and maybe some eyebrow work.' I also asked a detrans woman about 'your honest hot flashes experience coming off E,' saying I was 'still considering Estradiol with openness to coming off it,' though elsewhere I said HRT was off the table. I was working 30 hours a week at a convenience store, exercising daily at 5am with my mom and sister over the phone, and in a healthy BMI range (~21), doing 90 pushups in a workout.
I never socially transitioned, never started hormones, and never had surgery. As of my last comments in early July 2021, I was still questioning, still drawn to the idea ('The interest for me to transition will probably always exist for me'), but not acting on it, and I was exploring how to connect emotionally as a man.