Alle verhalen

Online tegen transitie betoogd terwijl ze zelf gedetransitioneerd was

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd76
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die eind 2019 actief was in gendercritische discussies op r/detrans en volhield dat vrouw-zijn een biologisch feit is en dat transitie neerkomt op verminking, gedreven door fantasie en sociale besmetting. Ik heb mijn eigen transitietijdlijn in deze berichten niet uitgewerkt, maar ik drong consequent aan op therapie en zelfacceptatie boven medische ingrepen. Ik geloof dat mensen detransitioneren omdat ze beseffen dat synthetische hormonen en operaties niet het antwoord zijn, en dat de samenleving het probleem is en niet zij. Ik ben kritisch over transitie voor anderen, vooral wat ik zie als man-naar-vrouw-transitioneerders, en zie detransitie als een terugkeer naar de realiteit. Ik heb in dit materiaal geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I have not written much about my own transition history here; most of what I've posted has been advice to others and arguments about the meaning of transition, sex, and detransition. In September 2019 I told one person plainly that the answer to their situation was "One word - Therapy," saying they clearly had a lot of issues and needed to talk to a professional who could help them make sense of them. In the same thread I pushed back on the idea that a woman in a heterosexual relationship needs to perform conventional femininity: "Why do you need 'feminine things'? ... Just be you. He'll either like you the way you are or he won't and if he doesn't that's not your problem." I accused their therapist of pushing a sex-role stereotype, calling it "nonsense." I also questioned someone's use of the word "top" in a heterosexual context, asking whether they were "freaked out because you aren't actually into boys?" I later admitted I hadn't read the rest of that thread, calling it "Embarrassing, lol." By October 2019 my comments had hardened into a much more confrontational, gender-critical position. I stated flatly: "Self aware people do not detrans because of the stigma of being trans. They detrans because they realise mutilating their perfectly healthy bodies and pumping themselves full of synthetic hormones is not the answer. Society is the problem, not them." I described surgery on healthy body parts as mutilation, dismissed people who identify as trans but do not pursue SRS as "transtrenders" who "have jumped on an insidiously harmful bandwagon," and attributed it to "ROGD because of spending too long in some pro trans social platform most likely." I framed the issue as women being erased: "Women are being erased because of 'trans'. How? By being made to skoosh over to allow men to take over whatever belongs to us. Public restrooms, sports, award categories specifically for women, women's products getting rid of any symbols of Female....and getting told we're bigots if we don't agree to it." I also wrote, "White hetero men who get a hard on from wearing a dress are not oppressed IN ANY WAY." I argued with a trans woman directly, writing: "Being a woman is not a social category. It is an observable biological fact... There is no 'innate sense of being a woman'. You either are or are not." I stated that "Intersex has nothing to do with 'trans'. They are not a third sex. They are a genetic anomaly," and told her, "You are a man. Who wears dresses... Even if you have those cut off your chromosomes will still say 'male'." I defended the feminist definition "Woman= adult human female" and said "Being female is a biological reality not some feeling in your head." I also wrote that "Running away from reality and hiding yourself in fantasy can feel great but it solves nothing. Your problems will still be there when you decide that fantasy is wearing thin and isn't giving you what you crave. There will be people who will help you when you decide enough is enough." I contrasted gender-critical explanations of transition (different for "TiM" and "TiF") with what I called "feelings and junk science" on the trans side, and I told one commenter to "Begone" for "Polluting a sub about detransing with your pro 'trans' rubbish." I have not described my own dysphoria, coming out, medical steps, or detransition process in these comments, so I cannot say here when any of that happened for me. What comes through clearly is that by late 2019 I identified with a gender-critical, feminist reading of detransition, believed transition was a form of self-harm driven by fantasy and social contagion, and was willing to argue about it sharply.