Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die 15 jaar als transvrouw leefde op hormonen, waaronder 13 jaar post-SRS, voordat ik in 2019 op mijn 48e detransitioneerde en terugkeerde naar testosteron. Nu identificeer ik me als vrouwelijke man en beschouw ik mezelf nog steeds als transseksueel, maar heb ik gendercritische opvattingen en geloof ik dat transitie dysforie kan verlichten maar de biologische sekse niet kan veranderen. Ik beschouw mijn vaginoplastiek als een ramp die me chronische infecties en een 'misvormd geslachtsorgaan' bezorgde, terwijl FFS en borstvergroting de enige operaties waren die ik nuttig vond. Detransitie, geholpen door cognitieve gedragstherapie, bracht me verlichting, en nu pleit ik kritisch over transitie en waarschuw ik jongeren voor onomkeerbare ingrepen. Ik noemde dat ik zonder detransitie op weg was naar zelfmoord en dat twee transvrouwen in mijn kring door zelfdoding stierven, maar ik beschreef geen eigen poging.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and first had trans thoughts around age 4 or 5. In my teens I got into crossdressing, then got married; my marriage collapsed because I was obsessed with crossdressing and wanting to be a woman all the time. Shortly after we separated I did some soul searching and, with the knowledge I had back then, applied for a gender change trajectory. I had my intake assessment at the gender clinic UZGent at age 31, started hormone therapy at 32, and lived full-time for 15 years. I had SRS and breast augmentation at 33 (2006) and FFS at 35, all with well-regarded surgeons (Stan Monstrey in Ghent for SRS/BA, Noorman Van Der Dussen for FFS). I was on MtF HRT for 15 years total.
The first few years I was 'living the dream' and thought I had become female. After a while I started to realize how fake and artificial it all was, and how lonely it was. I kept experiencing urinary tract infections and yeast infections almost all the time from the vaginoplasty, even though my surgical results were considered excellent. I described the result as 'a piece of penis head hanging between slices of scrotal sac' and 'a surgically created fronthole that can not be called a vagina.' I also felt out of place showering with women after cycling. I didn't pass completely but was conventionally attractive ('an attractive trans'). Friends and family were supportive throughout.
Over time I came to see transition as living an 'artificial man-made existence instead of a natural reality,' and I felt exhausted by having to live a life that wasn't real and by feeling the world was walking on tiptoes around me. I also realized how lonely growing old as a trans woman is — citing a documentary 'I'm a woman now' where none of the trans women interviewed, well into their 70s, had a life partner. I began to think about the memory I want to leave behind in the world. I came to gendercritical views: I still consider myself transsexual and believe I am and always will be genetically male, but I no longer believed transition could change that. Cognitive Behavior Therapy helped me more than transition did; I said '90% of your unhappiness is caused by your own hangups' and that learning to cope with them matters more than hormones or surgeries.
I detransitioned at age 48 in January 2019, starting testosterone shots and cutting my hair short the same day. I began wearing a binder (later planning top surgery to remove my breast implants and breast tissue), bought a male wardrobe, and boxed up my female clothes for donation. I planned a possible phalloplasty/vaginal canal closure as a later step, and discussed facial masculinization surgery. I described myself as going through life as a 'feminine man' reclaiming my male identity. I said I feel healthier back on testosterone and that returning to biological reality was a liberation. I called SRS 'an absolute disaster' and said that if I had to redo it all I would likely only have done HRT, BA and FFS and lived openly as trans without obsessing about passing; FFS and BA were the only surgeries that felt useful. I'll be on testosterone replacement for the rest of my life and described myself as 'a handicapped sane man' who 'got out of this cult alive.'
I do not want transition abolished and said it can relieve dysphoria, but I now hold critical/gendercritical views about transition for others, arguing no one can change what they were born as. I have been vocal on Reddit sharing my experience, arguing detransition is more common than the trans community admits, warning young people about easy access to hormones and surgery, and criticizing what I called 'hugboxing' in trans communities. I mentioned two trans women from my connection circle who committed suicide within a year of each other, and said that without detransition I was on my way to ending up with my wrists cut in a bathtub or hanging from a roof. I did not describe a suicide attempt of my own. I don't hate myself for having transitioned — 'what's done is done' — but I would make different choices today.