Alle verhalen

De broer die transitioneerde, en de zus die niet bestond

Man · Gedesisteerd638
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een heteroseksuele man die nooit genderdysforie had en nooit transitioneerde; ik kwam naar deze gemeenschap omdat mijn broer naar vrouw transitioneerde. Ik werd in mijn kindertijd bijna dagelijks misbruikt door mijn moeder, wat me een blijvende angst voor en wantrouwen jegens vrouwen heeft gegeven waar ik aan werk, en mijn vader was afwezig. Ik geloof dat transitie voor velen een makkelijke ontsnapping aan zichzelf is en dat het medische systeem waarborgen mist, en ik heb detransitioners aangemoedigd juridische stappen te overwegen. Ik ben kritisch over zowel trans-activisme als gendercritische/mannenrechtenkringen die hele sekses de schuld geven. Mijn huidige identiteit is die van een heteroseksuele man die kritisch is over genderideologie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and I have never had gender dysphoria. I came to this community as a straight man and, in my own words, "I'm a straight man and my opinion is that I would rather be alone than be with a trans woman." I have never transitioned myself, so my story here is about the family and personal experiences that shaped how I think about transition and detransition. I grew up in an abusive household. "I and my siblings were abused virtually every day of our childhood by our mother. To this day I have a fear and mistrust of women. But that is my emotion that I need to work on, it is not the problem of an entire gender." That abuse left me with lasting fear and mistrust of women, and I have spent years working on it. My father was "just never around," so I never had a masculine role model, and because I look a great deal like my father, "I hated looking in the mirror. So I wanted to change my appearance for a long time." I also described myself as having been "a very emotional man" who "got so much abuse from people specifically because I was a man and emotional. Being in this body didn't help me. I had to learn to change my inside." I have a brother who transitioned to female. I wrote, "I never had gender dysphoria but my brother does and he transitioned," and "I'm a brother to a MtF." I also referred to "a family member to a transgender girl." I believe my brother found various online forums and that transition "seemed an easy way to escape who he is and the past." I told other family members that "As a family member to a transgender girl, we would be happy to hear about a detransition. They spent the money because they wanted what is best for you. They hasn't changed." I also dated a girl who, around adolescence, "hated her body and her breasts. She bound her breasts and she wanted her friend to hit them to make them go away. She is an adult now and is beautiful and completely fine with her body." Watching that made me conclude that "The system is failing us" for telling teens that changing their body is an acceptable option for what I see as a temporary phase. My own struggles with appearance were not about gender. I have thought about plastic surgery to look better, and I get jokes about my facial features, but I decided instead to work on how I react: "I work on building myself more than focusing on my exterior." I came to accept my looks: "recently I started to accept (maybe disregard?) my looks and accept myself as I am." I have also noted that I am short with facial features different from most people, and used that to argue that society valuing looks does not mean one is in the wrong body. I have been critical of how easily the medical system allows transition. I said "The whole system is messed up if someone with mental illness can hack it so easily. They should have safeguards in place. Before you needed to live as the opposite sex for 2 years before any physical changes were done. But activists changed that." I encouraged detransitioners to consider lawsuits: "Talk to a lawyer. Don't just blame yourself. They are the health pros and should practice restraint and they didn't." I also criticized therapists, saying "Medical professionals think about keeping patients more than actually getting them well" and that "They are scared of malpractice suits." I have been active in critiquing gender-critical spaces as well as trans-activist ones. I told a gender-critical commenter, "Head over to men's rights. They blame women for all the world's problems. GC blames men. You guys are 2 sides of the same coin." I described reading r/gendercritical as giving me "the same depressed sinking feeling that I get in a mens rights sub." I have posted and commented extensively in support of detransitioners, encouraging them with advice like "Trust yourself, don't compare yourself to others. Give yourself time to heal your body and mind." I have drawn on Carl Jung's ideas about sacrifice, quoting him twice about how "a painful sacrifice can be risked with a mighty effort of the will" and that "Sacrifice always means the renunciation of a valuable part of oneself." I recommended reading Jung's works. I have thought about therapy for myself indirectly, noting from a professional standpoint that providers sometimes worry "what if with this treatment the patient doesn't need me anymore?" I believe abuse victims like me are drawn to communities that offer false refuge: "I too was abused and it took years for me to realize that I continued to choose people to surround myself that didn't really care about me. That is what we are used to as abuse victims." I have never detransitioned because I never transitioned. My current identity is that of a straight man who is critical of both gender ideology and of hostility toward men. I see transition, for most people, as "anxiety that has attached itself to another thing to focus on" and compare it to 1990s anorexia: "In the 90s it was anorexia where girls starved themselves, now it is dysphoria."