Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde butch lesbienne van 31 die ongeveer zeven jaar sociaal getransitioneerd leefde tijdens mijn tienerjaren en vroege twintig, gedreven door seksueel misbruik in mijn kindertijd, me nooit 'meisjesachtig' voelen en het geloof in het gendergerichte transverhaal. Ik had nooit genitale dysforie en ben altijd gek geweest op vrouw zijn; ik 'pack' soms nog omdat ik me daardoor zelfverzekerd en sexy voel, al voel ik daar wat schaamte over. Ik ben nu gelukkig, verloofd met een steunende biseksuele verloofde en woon in een blauwe staat. Ik ben sterk kritisch over transitie voor anderen en betoog dat de meeste online dysforie voortkomt uit onopgeloste psychische problemen en ideologie, terwijl ik toch mededogen toon met mensen die met psychische ziekte worstelen. In dit transcript heb ik geen medische transitie-interventies, operaties of hormoongebruik beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and identified as trans for about seven years, living socially transitioned through my teens and early twenties. I came out and began living as trans around my early-to-mid teens, packed every day and night during that period despite not really having bottom dysphoria, and generally presented masculinely. I never had genital dysphoria — I have always loved having a vagina and never fantasized about being a man or about having a penis instead. When I thought I was trans, it wasn't about sex for me. I now identify as a desisted, gender-nonconforming butch lesbian; I am currently 31.
What led me toward transition, in retrospect, was a combination of factors: I was a vulnerable teen survivor of childhood sexual abuse (CSA), I never felt 'girly,' and I bought into the gendered trans narrative. I also identify as having a psych background and am aware of my own cognitive distortions. I have diagnosed, well-managed mental health conditions, including a history of 'crippling anxiety,' and I have experienced sexual assault (SA) as an adult as well. I have also dealt with recent weight gain that upset me considerably.
I did not describe a specific therapy or event that moved me toward detransition in this transcript; my desistance appears to have already happened by the time of these posts, and I speak about it as settled. I do describe ongoing reflection about why I transitioned and why I still occasionally pack.
On packing: many years after desisting, I still occasionally pack. I don't want a real penis — I just like how packing feels and how it makes me feel more confident and sexy. It has also helped draw my attention away from recent weight gain I'm upset with. My fiancée, who is bisexual, finds it 'kinda hot.' I feel a lingering shame about it, partly because I worry people will think I secretly identify as trans again, especially since I still present so masc that I sometimes get called 'sir' and get weird looks in the ladies' room. I considered and rejected autoandrophilia as an explanation and noted packing is more about how others see me than about feeling 'right.'
I have not described any surgeries, hormone use, or puberty blockers in this transcript — only social transition and packing. I have not described fertility concerns or medical complications of my own. I do discuss testosterone's effects on others (vaginal atrophy, damage to connective tissue and joints) in a general, warning context.
Mentally, I describe a history of crippling anxiety and diagnosed, well-managed conditions. I also reference having a psych background (though not being a licensed therapist) and discuss intrusive thoughts, OCD, and ruminating as things others might be experiencing.
Adversity: childhood sexual abuse as a teen/child survivor, and sexual assault as an adult. I attribute part of my discomfort with being perceived as 'womanly' to an inherent worry for my safety that developed both as a woman and after experiencing SA.
Socially, I am engaged to a bisexual fiancée who is supportive of my packing. Most of my friends are men, and my best friend is described as compassionate and protective. I identify strongly with the lesbian community, more so than with any 'gender,' even when I lived socially as trans.
Sexuality: I am a butch lesbian. I describe myself as attracted to women and reference lesbian experiences and community. I don't describe internalised homophobia; rather, I express pride in butch identity and lesbian history.
Regret: I don't express sharp, explicit regret about specific medical interventions (I don't describe any). I do express a critical view of transition generally, describing hormones as 'foreign hormones' your body was 'never meant to process' and surgery as 'mutilating your figure' or 'medically mutilating your body.' I frame my own past trans identification as having been driven by vulnerability, CSA, and ideology rather than genuine gender identity.
Outcomes: I am currently happy as a 31-year-old gnc/butch lesbian living in a blue state, with no issues feeling unsafe or unseen beyond what any other woman faces. I have a fiancée and a friend group.
Attitudes toward transition for others: I am strongly critical and largely opposed. I say things like 'If you don't want anything that has to do with actually transitioning, you're not trans,' advise people to move rather than medically transition, say 'you will never be not female, and you will never be male,' and argue that most public/online gender dysphoria is rooted in unresolved mental health issues and/or ideological indoctrination. I also push back against demonizing people with mental illness who post 'do I pass' photos, showing some nuance. I have not described formal advocacy or activism.