Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die in deze gemeenschap kwam nadat ik concludeerde dat ik een fout had gemaakt met transitioneren, en ik adviseerde anderen in crisis niet toe te geven aan suïcidale driften en zich te richten op praktische stappen zoals werk zoeken. Ik omschreef mezelf als polyamoreus en als iemand die „misleid” was toen ik trans was, en ik spreek nu alleen voor mijn eigen weg als ik in transruimtes kom. Ik geloof dat transitie vertraagd en begeleid moet worden door professionals en ervaringsdeskundigen, terwijl volwassenen verantwoordelijk blijven voor hun eigen keuzes. Ik denk dat gender-diverse mensen door de hele geschiedenis heen bestaan, al speelt sociale druk een rol. Mijn huidige identiteit is die van een gedetransitioneerd persoon die voorzichtig en gematigd kritisch is over hoe transitie wordt gepusht, terwijl ik openlijke vijandigheid tegen trans mensen blijf afwijzen.
Volledig verhaal
I wrote to others in this community while I was working through my own detransition, and my advice to people in crisis was blunt: I compared the urge to suicide to "a caught rat gnawing off it's leg to escape" and urged people to fight it, or at least be lazy about it and put it off. I told one person they had come to the conclusion that they made a mistake and that they shouldn't die over a mistake, and I encouraged them to focus solely on job searching eight hours a day as a way to build a backup plan, saying I had been in similar spots where I felt trapped.
I described myself as polyamorous and said I was happy to have found this place, which is by its nature outside of the trans community, so I could hear these points of view. I advised someone speaking in trans spaces to speak only for their own journey, warning that saying "trans is evil" or that all trans people are crazy would get you thrown out, and that your very presence is proof that at least some of them are deluded "like you were." I expressed hope that people might be reached "before it's too late for them to detransition."
I reflected on why trans identification shows up in nerd and cosplay circles, saying I run in a lot of weird circles and could back that up. I saw cosplay as a release from the normal boundaries of who you are allowed to be, compared it to D&D-style role playing where it is easy to make a character of the opposite gender to explore, and noted similar effects on myself with my personal style and my shifting personality dictated by my role in social situations.
On medical process, I argued that the trans community has become so sensitive from being unfairly treated that even reasonable measures now seem unreasonable, and that transition processes don't all have to happen at once as fast as possible. I said a slower walk through options would give time for people who might be making mistakes, that not every trans person needs everything to feel better, and that while as an adult the responsibility is on you, there needs to be more involvement from people who have been through it and professionals who can coach people through in a reasonable manner without all of that trans hate — "There is a middle path." In a related exchange I said I wouldn't take away the agency from the adult who asked for this and now has to live with the consequences of her actions.
I also pushed back on the idea that gender-diverse people are purely a modern social construct, arguing that these kinds of people have been recorded in medical books, history, and myth forever, that some cultures embrace them and some shun them, and that they persist independently as spontaneous phenomenon — while conceding that a certain amount of social pressure can influence people.