Alle verhalen

Sociaal getransitioneerd op haar 14e, gedetransitioneerd voor haar 16e, en nog steeds in oorlog met haar lichaam

Vrouw · GedesisteerdEerste dysforie 7 → Sociale transitie 14 → Desistance 162,2K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (als vrouw geboren, autistisch) die op mijn 14e sociaal is getransitioneerd als FTM, bijna 16 gedetransitioneerd is en nooit hormonen of operaties heeft gehad. Ik worstel nog steeds met ernstige borstdysforie en heb af en toe gedachten aan opnieuw transitioneren, maar ik identificeer me als vrouw en wil niet trans zijn. Ik heb therapiebrieven gehad, maar vond zelfonderzoek betekenisvoller, en ik schrijf mijn detransitie toe aan de operatiecomplicaties van vrienden en mijn eigen intuïtie. Ik ben kritisch over de statistiek „1% detransitie”, over de verheerlijking van topchirurgie en over transitie voor minderjarigen, terwijl ik zeg dat ik niet tegen transitie voor anderen ben. Op dit moment verken ik mijn seksualiteit na een controlerende relatie met een man, vraag ik me af of ik lesbisch ben en hoop ik onder een pseudoniem een fictieroman over de detransitie-ervaring te schrijven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and grew up in Australia in an educated upper-middle-class family. My parents separated when I was 4 and fought constantly for years afterward. My grandmother, who was effectively my mother because my actual mother was a workaholic and neglectful, had a major stroke when I was 10 and remained ill for about five years. As a young child I was gender-neutral and didn't think about being a girl at all. From about 7 to 10 years old I lay awake dreading growing breasts. When puberty began around 10-12, nobody explained anything about it to me; I was peer-pressured into wearing bras before I wanted or needed one, and I interpreted having to cover my chest as shame. I'm autistic and took things literally, so the rule that women must cover up while men can be shirtless made no sense to me and felt deeply unfair. In sixth grade (age 12) a friend touched my chest area twice and laughed it off when I said it was harassment. I discovered the trans/FTM community at 13 and came out as trans FTM at 14. My parents were separated; they were accepting at first but quickly became defensive, and my dad withdrew from my life for 16 months because I was trans. I socially transitioned at 14 and was in an alternative high school during this period — a school of about 90 people where pride flags were in every room, everyone introduced themselves by pronouns, there was a 'queer room' and 'queer club' where about half the school identified as trans masc or non-binary, and that group received special privileges (trips to coffee shops, zoos, malls, beaches) that the rest of the school did not. Half the teachers were genderqueer. I bound my chest for about 1.5 years, from ages 14 to 16, using GC2B binders, and I don't believe it caused permanent damage. I detransitioned at nearly 16 (I sometimes say I was FTM between ages 13-15). I detransitioned because transition didn't help my overall mental health — I had many other issues as a teen — and because I'd realized I wanted to be a cis man rather than a trans man, and that being trans would cost me life opportunities. I never had hormones or surgery. I had buckets of therapist letters and jumped through hoops toward medical transition, but soul-searching rather than a therapist letter told me it was wrong for me. I've said that if I'd had testosterone or top surgery my life would be ruined. I first heard about the risks of medical transition through friends: a trans male friend nearly died from top surgery complications, paid $10,000 for it at 18 out of his own pocket, and lost both nipples; another friend's nipples fell off in the shower; another had surgery botched by a drunk surgeon. I also saw graphic post-op photos on Transbucket and read about unknown long-term effects of testosterone. I detransitioned initially out of an intuitive feeling that medical transition was damaging to the body. I'm now 19-20 and identify as female/detrans/desisted, though I'm gender-nonconforming and masculine-presenting, and I've described myself as 'non-binary, agender, not in ideology but in spirit.' I still experience dysphoria: I hate my breasts, describe them as feeling like tumours, experience psychosomatic aching, and still sometimes dream about top surgery and want to re-transition. I've said I want a flat chest and a man's voice, don't perform femininity, and am sick of being a woman, but I don't want to be trans, don't want lifelong medication, don't want surgery, and want to live a normal life. I've considered binding again for a flat chest under menswear and asked about the cost of top surgery (in Australia, $6,000-$20,000 for breast reduction; about $10,000 for top surgery). I've struggled to accept being a woman. I've described internalized misogyny, hatred of how sexualized breasts are, anger that women can't be shirtless, and grief that I can't accept my body. I've written about wanting to write a fiction novel about the trans/detrans teenage experience under a pen name because I'm building a career in the music industry and fear that openly sharing my detransition account would destroy my professional reputation. I've said I feel silenced by the trans and LGBT community. I took mushrooms with my mom at one point; the trip became anxiety-provoking, my ego died, and the voice in my head became that of a young guy, and I realized the masculine and feminine sides of my mind had always been at war — something I linked to my parents' conflict. I've found Tori Amos's music, Eckhart Tolle's writing, and Elle Palmer's YouTube channel helpful. I was in a relationship with a straight man for about 1.5 years before moving in with him; after moving in he pressured me into performing feminine gender roles, said things like 'periods are gross' and refused to apologize, and was controlling. My dysphoria got much worse. I left and told him I thought I was a lesbian. I then dated a woman but was unsure whether my attraction to women was genuine or whether my attraction to men was real or driven by internalized misogyny and dysphoria; I noted that the more I worked on internalized misogyny and dysphoria, the more I liked women. I've said I like the idea of having biological kids, that I'm enamoured by men but frightened of them, and that I'm more comfortable around women but less sexually attracted to them. I've also said I hated penetrative sex physically and emotionally and had a lot of chest dysphoria during intimacy. I've been critical of the '1% detransition' statistic, of informed consent practices for minors, of the glorification of top surgery on social media, and of the claim that testosterone changes are reversible. I've cited regret rates of 7-20%. I've said I don't want to discourage anyone else's transition ('do whatever you think will make you happy') but that detransitioners are silenced and that young people and people with comorbid mental health issues can't truly give informed consent. I've advocated for more nuance, art, and honesty about detransition, and I've posted a montage of masculine-presenting women as 'proof you can be handsome, masculine, and wear whatever you like as a woman.' I have no recorded history of self-harm, suicide attempts, or suicidal ideation of my own in this transcript (I mentioned a friend who was suicidal after surgery).