Alle verhalen

De bijwerkingen van één pil, een heel pleidooi tegen hormonen

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd207
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw die kritisch is over hoe snel het medische systeem mensen naar hormonen en operaties duwt, sterk gekant tegen het toepassen van genderstereotypen op kinderen, en die detransitioners en gendercritical standpunten steunt. Ik weiger de anticonceptiepil te nemen nadat die gewichtstoename, acne, verlies van libido, vaginale droogte en depressie veroorzaakte, en ik gebruik die ervaring om te betogen dat knoeien met hormonen ernstig is. Ik heb in deze berichten geen volledige medische transitie-/detransitietijdlijn uiteengezet, maar ik schrijf als iemand die dat proces heeft doorgemaakt en verlaten. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw en moedig andere vrouwen aan schaamte over vrouw-zijn af te wijzen.

Volledig verhaal

I have been active in detransition and gender-critical discussions online since at least 2019, and while I have not laid out a full medical timeline of my own transition and detransition in these posts, my comments reveal a good deal about how I think and what I have been through. Early on, I recommended the book As Nature Made Him to people arguing about gender medicine, and later I pointed others toward Elle Palmer's YouTube channel, saying she does a wonderful job explaining her journey with transitioning and detransitioning. I also said I watch Kalvin Garrah, that he has good points and is hilarious, that he calls out 'trenders and predators using the trans movement to push their own agenda,' and that while he can be a dick and cross the line, it is refreshing to see someone lay it out without apologizing. I reacted strongly to a story about someone getting surgery young, writing, 'That's insane! You can't even drive in some states, get a tattoo, drink, buy cigs, live outside a guardianship...how the hell did they let you get surgery???' I have also argued that 'Point A, figuring out you might be trans, should not lead to Point B, getting hormones. There should be a long chain of events that need to pass by smoothly in between those two points,' and I criticized therapists who I feel either don't listen or are scared of being sued, and who are 'quick to throw drugs at us.' On identity itself, I wrote, 'What even is identity?' and advised someone to get off the internet, unplug, live, listen to whatever music they like, wear whatever is comfortable, take up a hobby that keeps their hands busy, and stop smacking labels on everything: 'The less you stress about who you *should* be, the more the true you comes out.' I am sharply critical of gender stereotypes and of how children are treated in this area. I wrote, 'Stop putting people (especially CHILDREN) in boxes! Boys can be boys and like ballet and girls can be girls and like monster trucks. How frightening is it that we are paving the lives of children based off outdated stereotypes.' I also argued that 'the emergence of non-binary is, in a way, reviving the old Puritan beliefs that women and men need to act a certain way,' and I told another woman, 'Being a woman isn't a prison sentence if you don't let it be so,' adding, 'Society told you to be ashamed. Fuck society. Be a woman and be a damn good one.' I have given advice to a parent of a gender-questioning child, describing myself as having been 'one of those do it because they said I can't type of kids.' I advised supporting her — letting her cut her hair, buying boy clothes with her, not freaking out or lecturing — but also being honest that transitioning is a long process of therapy, and being real about the physical changes of puberty blockers or testosterone: 'low voice that might never go away, facial and chest stubble, temperament issues, enlarged clit, etc.' I added that people who actually have gender dysphoria need those doctors and medications more than she does, but never to flat out say no. On my own body and hormones, I shared that birth control affected me badly: 'I gained so much weight, I broke out, I lost my sexual libido and when I forced myself to have sex I would be drier than the Sahara, and to make matters worse I got terribly depressed. Messing with your hormones is not a joke.' I said no one takes me seriously when I talk about how awful BC affected me to the point where I refuse to take it now, while acknowledging plenty of women have the opposite experience. I have also commented on appearance in what seems to be a detransition or re-identification context — telling someone they started off beautiful and get prettier each picture, and telling another person they are cute but that a mustache 'did not suit you.' Overall I come across as skeptical of rapid medical pathways, critical of stereotype-based gender thinking, supportive of detransitioners, and personally wary of hormonal medication after my own negative experience with birth control.