Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw die zich vanaf 2003 als trans identificeerde en sociaal transitioneerde maar nooit hormonen nam. Ik werd op mijn 16e gegroomd door een oudere transvrouw, beïnvloed door pro-transitiefiguren als Buck Angel en door porno, en mijn van nature hoge testosteron deed de mannelijke rol aanvoelen als ‘bedoeld’. Ik desisteerde toen ik besefte hoeveel schade de sociale transitie aan mijn leven had gedaan, en sindsdien heb ik mezelf herbouwd rond hobby's, natuur, stoppen met porno en hormonale anticonceptie, en een relatie met een hetero man. Ik heb het Ehlers-Danlos-syndroom, waardoor ik niet meer kon binden, en ik heb een ernstige gezondheidscrisis doorgemaakt waardoor gender irrelevant voelde. Ik ben nu kritisch over transitie die wordt opgedrongen aan minderjarigen en masculiene vrouwen, zie het deels als sociale besmetting en pleit ervoor dat detransitioners zich uitspreken.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I started identifying as trans back in 2003, when I was in my early twenties. I never medically transitioned — I never took testosterone — but I did socially transition, and I lived in that role for years. I was a tall, masculine, butch woman with naturally high testosterone: an endocrinologist once told me my T levels were at the very top of the natural female range. That physical reality made transness feel almost inevitable to me. I fit the male role so effortlessly that it felt intoxicating, especially compared to being treated like a weird, awkward, gangly woman who was supposed to hate her own masculine features. I got praise and attention from other trans people for being tall and butch, and it made me feel like I was 'meant to be trans' and that it would be a 'waste' not to transition.
A major driver of my transition was grooming. When I was 16, a 40-year-old trans woman groomed me, telling me I 'made such a cute boy' and pressuring me into that role. Around 2006 I was deeply embedded in the LGBT community, where figures like Buck Angel were everywhere, promoting the idea that being a trans man was cool, sexy, and queer — 'it's ok if you don't want bottom surgery, just go on T, it's totally cool to be a man with a pussy.' That messaging directly contributed to my choice to transition. Porn also played a role; it made my dysphoria dramatically worse by presenting stereotypical, toxic views of gender roles and sexuality.
I also have a chronic pain condition, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. The first time I tried binding, I immediately realized it was a terrible idea for me — my lungs, spine, and shoulders are extremely sensitive and I already deal with a lot of pain there. That experience made me think hard about how many people bind daily at a level of damage just beneath their tolerance threshold, pressing through pain in a dysphoric state for months or years. I also dealt with a serious health crisis at one point — a period of being very sick with a fever, during which I experienced a hallucination of 'little people planning war strategies.' During that time I made a deliberately utilitarian decision about my legal sex: I kept my sex marker as F rather than changing it to M. My reasoning was functional, not identity-based — 'This isn't about my identity. This is about the function of my body' — because I didn't want to add confusion to a situation where I was praying doctors would run the right tests and give me answers about my health.
I detransitioned — I use the word 'desisted' — and the social transition alone 'fucked up my life a lot.' Losing my community was painful. I had friends I thought were ride or die, that I thought I'd grow old with; now the only one left is a trans guy who still thinks I'm at least non-binary. I've also been pressured into sex by trans women, an experience I share with other detransitioners. My ex, a trans woman, went from an outgoing, charismatic young man with a fulltime job and active social life to an agoraphobic young woman who spent all her time playing Dwarf Fortress and watching porn, could never go outside because of stubble and makeup, and started drinking daily — I had to pay her share of the rent.
Since detransitioning I've focused on rebuilding a life outside of gender. I work on my life purpose: podcasts, books, crochet, witchcraft, cleaning, taking care of my cat and plants, exercising, and getting outside in nature. I listen to Not Another DnD Podcast, read bestsellers like Naomi Alderman's *The Power*, lesbian romance, and non-fiction on botany and witchcraft. I quit porn over a year ago (as of April 2022) and also came off hormonal birth control; my period is still heavy and my libido isn't as high as it used to be, but it's slowly coming back and 'it's nice to feel alive again finally.' I'm in a relationship with a straight man who likes my hair long, though I think about cutting it all the time. I've also been on antidepressants in the past, which killed my libido.
I'm now critical of how transition is pushed, particularly on young people and on masculine women like me. I think the trans community has gone 'absolutely insane' since the 2000s, when it was understood that being trans is hard and transitioning shouldn't be done if you can cope otherwise. I'm opposed to binding for under-18s and to surgery for minors, and I view binders as a modern-day corset — body modification based on rejection and punishment of the natural human body, attractive to people already disposed to self-harm. I believe rapid-onset gender dysphoria in teenage girls is a social contagion like self-harm and eating disorders. I've also been critical of the medical establishment: 'A trans patient is a patient for life,' and people in pain are sold the idea that transition will fix them. I think there should be spaces where masculine female people are embraced as women regardless of appearance, and I've pointed people toward lesbian communities that welcome detransitioners and gender-nonconforming women. I've been open about being groomed as a teenager and pushed back against the 'you did this to yourself' narrative that's used to silence detransitioners. I also believe that differences of sex development are variations within the two sexes, not a spectrum or third sex.