Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (voormalig FTM) die medische transitie probeerde maar stopte vóór grote zichtbare veranderingen. Ik stopte vooral omdat ik op hetero cis mannen val en besefte dat daten makkelijker zou zijn als vrouw, en omdat ik accepteerde dat ik nooit het mannelijke lichaam zal hebben dat ik wilde. Ik leef nog met grote genderdysforie en haat het om borsten te hebben, maar ik behoud ze en heb gestopt transgevoelens het middelpunt van mijn leven te maken. Ik geef transidentificerende therapeuten de schuld dat ze me subtiel naar transitie duwden toen ik twijfelde, en ik geloof dat de vrouwelijke puberteit, seksualisering, pesten, gewichtsproblemen, pijnlijke menstruatie en een disfunctioneel gezin allemaal bijdroegen. Ik heb nu kritische opvattingen over transitie die aan jongeren wordt aangeprezen en pleit in plaats daarvan voor meer acceptatie van gendernonconformistische mensen.
Volledig verhaal
I have always been a very masculine female, and I am straight, which makes dating hard for me. I was skinny until about age ten, when puberty started and I began getting chubby; I believe this was mostly due to some kind of hormonal imbalance and food allergies. I was bullied very badly for my weight throughout my childhood by peers and family, and I grew up in a very dysfunctional family which made everything worse. In my teens and twenties I tried all the diets and exercise fads and lost and gained large amounts of weight several times. The stress of extreme and constant scrutiny and rejection led me to seek refuge in food, but my eating was controlled very much by my family so I didn't have as much opportunity as my thin friends to indulge in junk foods. I noticed my thin friends could eat much more than me and worse than me and stay thin while I seemed to put on weight eating a consistently healthy diet.
Around puberty I started choosing my own clothes and would usually gravitate towards my older brother's hand-me-downs — dark, baggy clothes. This was the 90s when 'heroin chic' was in. For me it was less about hiding my weight and more about hiding my breasts, hips, thighs, and bottom. I developed my womanly body parts long before my female peers and was being sexualized by adult men on a daily basis while my brain was far more innocent than most of my friends. As soon as my breasts were visible I was being catcalled by old men daily, which made me feel cursed and like a walking target. When I was a pre-teen the transgender movement did not exist and the only exposure to trans people I had was on Jerry Springer. I had no language for the discomfort I felt regarding my sex/gender and no one to help me.
What I hated most about being female growing up was how my body was viewed and treated by men as I developed into a woman, plus how oppressed and dominated women have been by men throughout history, and the body horror of being female — menstruation, pregnancy, menopause. Specifically menstruation was very painful for me and led me to hate the way I was born. As I got older and trans ideology became mainstream I expressed my interest in it to my mom, who insisted it was only because I was fat that I wanted to be seen as male. I promised her that even if I had grown up thin I would still have had this discomfort with my body.
I think it was a big mistake for me to seek out trans-identifying therapists to support me when I was questioning my gender identity. They pushed me towards identifying as transgender and then transitioning — not always overtly, but subtly and over a long period of time. I tried medically transitioning but stopped before any major visible changes occurred. This was the right choice for me mainly because I am sexually and romantically attracted typically to straight, cis men, and removing my breasts, etc., would severely limit my ability to find a partner.
After my long-term partner died and I grieved him, I tried to date again. I realized it would be easier for me to find someone as a woman than as a transgender man, because I am mainly attracted to straight cis men who are more traditional types. Also my body is very curvy and feminine and no matter how hard I try I will never have the kind of male body I desire to look like — I would have to devote my whole life to achieving that. I realized I'll never have a functioning penis and I don't want to carve up my arm like a turkey to end up looking like Frankenstein down there with all kinds of complications. It's easier to just make the best of how I was born. I'll always have those trans feelings but I stopped making them the center of my life. It's not ideal but life is hard.
I continue to live with major gender dysphoria despite accepting that I was born female and will not change my body any further in terms of transition. I still hate having breasts but I keep them because removing them wouldn't improve my specific situation and would likely make it worse. As a gender non-conforming, fat female it is harder for me than most women to find an eligible partner. I continue to struggle with excess weight as I try to figure out what I can and cannot eat, since I obviously have major food sensitivities and a metabolism/body type/genetics predisposed to gaining and keeping on weight.
I believe the root reason many women want to escape femaleness is that in many countries women are still treated as subhuman and the property of men — they can't go to school, vote, uncover their hair and faces, are forced into marriages and to have children, sometimes have their genitals mutilated as infants, are shamed for their natural cycles. Women are physically weaker and easier targets for assault, abuse, kidnapping, trafficking, torture, murder. Because of a woman's biology she bears the burden of pregnancy, childbirth, and child rearing. In the west we've come a long way but women still fight sexism in the workplace and unequal pay. It makes sense there are more FTMs than MTFs these days because there are generally fewer advantages to being female than male. Female puberty is hell for many young girls, and facing the treatment of men and society as their body develops leads many young girls to want to hide their bodies and masculinize their appearance. I also believe the social contagion thing is real and that girls are more susceptible to it than boys. Being transgender should not be marketed to young people as a cool new style but rather as a major and rare mental disorder, which it is. Another important aspect is the lack of tolerance for androgyny in society — if people were more accepting of adult tomboys and effeminate straight cis men, there would be a lot less detransitioners and a lot less lives ruined. My views on this matter are not influenced by feminism; they are purely my observations of society and based on my own experiences and the stories of girls and women I've known.
I have advised others who are having regrets, doubts, or questions to consider stopping hormones and pausing pursuing surgeries, since they don't want to further change their appearance when they are not sure how they identify. I think it's ok to be androgynous or non-binary or genderfluid, and society needs to be more inclusive of gender non-conforming people without pressuring them to change genders or sexes. I have also encouraged detransitioners sharing their stories, telling them they're not alone and thanking them for spreading awareness.