Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als man leefde en een periode testosteron nam (testosteroncypionaat, 140 mg/week) voordat ik ongeveer een jaar vóór september 2022 stopte. Ik transitioneerde omdat het opgroeien in een seksistisch mormoons gezin, dat zei dat mijn waarde lag in onderworpenheid en zwangerschap, me alles wat vrouwelijk was in mij liet haten, en ik detransitioneerde toen ik besefte dat ik geen man wilde zijn — ik wilde gewoon als bekwaam behandeld worden. Ik ervaar nog steeds fysieke dysforie over de secundaire geslachtskenmerken van beide geslachten en vind ‘non-binair’ de minst verkeerde beschrijving voor mezelf, hoewel ik sceptisch blijf over het concept. Blijvende effecten zijn een lage stem, resterend lichaams- en gezichtshaar en slappe, leeggelopen borsten van maandenlang binden. Ik heb nog wat geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat waar ik aan werk, en ik raad anderen nu aan hormonen langzaam af te bouwen, therapie te zoeken en rigide genderhokjes af te wijzen.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up in a sexist cult — Mormon — and was told that because I was born with a vagina I would always have to submit to men, and that the most important thing I could ever do with my life was get pregnant. Those narratives made me want literally anything else but womanhood. I am a child-free GNC woman, and the tomboyish personality traits that made me an outcast as a kid were praised once I was presenting as a man.
My dysphoria has been along a particular line for as long as I can remember having it: I have felt body dysphoria about all secondary sex characteristics of both men and women. My internal image of myself has been that I am unidentifiable as either male or female — I don't want breasts or facial hair, I want a generic body. I still have some dysphoria about not having a penis, but I don't want to not have a vagina; I feel like I should have both. For me the core issue was always the idea that women are weak and men are strong — I know there's some biological truth to it, but in the end it really is just a stereotype. It hurt me badly. I cannot live with the idea that I am incapable of becoming strong and protecting people; any implication that my femaleness means I could never become strong is not something I can stand.
I transitioned and lived socially as a man. I loved being a man socially — I finally felt respected. I was on testosterone: when I stopped I had been taking 0.7 mL of 200 mg/mL Testosterone Cypionate intramuscularly each week (140 mg). I also bound fairly consistently for several months during my medical transition, which did somewhat permanent damage to my breast tissue over time — my breasts are rather saggy and deflated-looking now. I have undergone a few medical procedures that make it difficult for me to pass as either sex.
I decided to detransition because I realized I didn't want to be a man — I just wanted to be treated like I'm competent. I'm not trans, just traumatized. I stopped testosterone by reducing my dose to about 0.2 mL straight away and then stopping altogether after about a month, which did not feel good; I now advise others to taper more gradually over about two months to avoid low energy, low sex drive, irritability, and depression. I've been off T for almost a year as of September 2022. When I stopped I was, in my own words, an absolute yeti — few cis men were as hairy as I was. Over time the hair has thinned a ton, gotten softer rather than thick, rough and wiry, and doesn't grow nearly as long; I no longer bother shaving my body hair even at the swimming pool. My voice is still pretty low and I often get mistaken for a man when gaming, though not always; body fat distribution reverted to female patterns within a few months.
It's definitely weird to get used to being a girl again. I still have a lot of gender issues personally, but I'm dealing with them in slightly healthier ways these days. I've been uncomfortable with expressing femininity all my life, but recently I've been able to put aside my fear of judgement to try some light makeup and cuter clothing. Acting femininely and submissively during sex with my long-term partner was one of the first times I was able to enjoy femininity and vulnerability without feeling reduced to a stereotype — I have a sissy/femboy-type kink, and it was my first safe and enjoyable outlet for genuine femininity. My partner has supported all parts of me and helped me embrace my femininity.
I grew up realizing that what I thought was dysphoria had been an intense hatred of everything that made me a woman — I feared the way women were treated and thought of in my hometown, so I feared being a woman. There is definitely some internalized misogyny in me that I need to sort through. I'm skeptical about non-binary identities, but I still find myself feeling like it's the best descriptor for me in detransition. One of the things I regret most about my transition was trying to push it further than I intended because of feeling pressured to fit into one of the binary options. I would like to be fully androgynous; trying to fit myself into the binary gives me a sense of cognitive dissonance almost like pretending a mule is either a horse or a donkey. I don't identify as non-binary based on gender roles — I rejected those notions long ago — but rather on my relationship with my body and the assumptions I want others to make about my body. It is a physical dysphoria, but instead of feeling like the opposite binary, I feel like I need to have neither characteristics. Now that I am detransitioning, my deep voice keeps me from really seeming like a woman; people ask me my pronouns all the time, and Tbh I hate being asked my pronouns, but I love that they have to ask.
I've advised others to taper off testosterone slowly, to find a good therapist and not be afraid to try a few until one clicks, and to give themselves all the time they need. I believe detransition isn't about conforming to your birth sex's stereotypes — it's about avoiding the health hazards and long-term damage of medical transition that isn't medically necessary. I don't owe anyone femininity, and being a girl isn't about wearing heels and dresses and makeup. I've told others to stop trying to fit into a neat little box like trans/detrans or man/woman, and that gender and sex are really only useful for romantic and sexual compatibility, not personality types. I also push back on the idea that any political 'side' is wholly right or wrong — I've said left and right both equal bad, and that right-wing circles pushing women to be stay-at-home moms in straight relationships push people to transition just as much as leftist pro-trans stuff does. I don't currently identify as an activist, but I do give detailed, candid advice to others detransitioning.