Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw — als vrouw geboren, ontwikkelde in de puberteit hele erge geslachtsdysforie en anorexia, en herstelde van genderdysforie rond mijn vroege twintiger jaren, waarbij ik rond mijn 22e-23e accepteerde dat ik een vrouw word genoemd. Ik ben autistisch, heb OCD, werd op school gepest, en ik ben de artsen en therapeuten die ik tussen mijn 18e en 21e zag dankbaar dat ze wisten dat genderdysforie bij tieners grotendeels voorbijgaand is. Ik beschrijf nooit hormonen te hebben genomen of een operatie te hebben gehad; mijn verhaal gaat over desisteren, niet over medisch detransitioneren. Ik schrijf en reageer nu uitgebreid tegen het bevestigingsmodel, puberteitsremmers voor kinderen en het statistiekje van 1 procent spijt, en spoor anderen aan om onderliggend trauma, angst en OCD te behandelen in plaats van te transitioneren. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw en voel me daar prettig bij.
Volledig verhaal
I am a woman who was born female and who started menstruating at 12. I used to have very bad sex dysphoria, and I hated my feminine name and being called a woman; I used to think that the word 'woman' reduces a person to a baby-making machine, and I only realised later that I was the one reducing it that way — in the end I got over my internalised misogyny. It took me until I was around 22 or 23 to accept the word 'woman' for myself, and I now say that it took me until 23 because not only did I not feel female at 17, I also did not feel like an adult; now that I am older, 'woman' fits because I actually feel like an adult. I am autistic, and I believe most female detransitioners and desisters are too; autism is what makes me feel like an alien among women, and it is much easier for me to interact with men. I also have OCD, and I have been bullied at school because I was different and weird — bullying is insidious and stays with you forever. I had an eating disorder (anorexia) that began in puberty; I have essentially been anorexic since puberty, and it took me years to reconnect with my body in any meaningful way after physically recovering. I also experience body dissociation: while writing a book with a one-handed main POV character last year, I deliberately tried to get used to the idea of only having one hand, and alarmingly quickly I stopped seeing my own right hand as part of my body, even though I knew exactly what I was doing. I used to despise my breasts; I am neutral about them now. I have never worn makeup, I couldn't care less about makeup or the colour pink, I don't have a particularly feminine temperament, and my sense of humour fits in much better with men than with women — but none of that makes me less of a woman. I wear a lot of my brother's old clothes, including his trousers and shirts, which are some of my favourites. I am a writer: I spent a good chunk of last year writing a book. I quit Tumblr years ago because of the toxicity and the grooming of teenage girls by grown men there, and I am not going back any time soon or ever; even so, I still notice how all of the nerdy, often autistic, girls and young women online are trans-identified and often on testosterone, which I find heartbreaking. I am Catholic, though I never made life decisions on the basis of religion. I have a brother. I know what it is like to have medication fry your brain: I am still recovering from constant migraines and brain fog after a medication I took three years ago. I am in my early thirties: I say I am ten years older than a 21-year-old correspondent, and I refer to being 23 as being in the past. I am female and I identify as a woman.
I did recover from gender dysphoria — I say plainly, 'I did' when asked whether it is possible to recover. How you can recover depends on what caused the dysphoria: if trauma caused it, working through the trauma properly can resolve it; if OCD caused it, getting the OCD under control resolves it; if general body issues caused it, you have to work through the body issues. You have to tackle the underlying cause. I am convinced that gender dysphoria can be a maladaptive coping mechanism where a person focuses all their hope for a solution to their other problems on 'resolving' the issue of gender, but that is a pipe-dream. I am critical of the affirmation model: I think it is an incredible dereliction of duty that doctors nowadays ignore all mental and neurological issues and just prescribe hormones and surgeries, and that affirmation-only doctors are papering over the cracks while the patient's actual issues are left untreated and festering. I argue that both mental ill-health and neurodivergence cause trans identification, especially in young people — autism gives an easy explanation for why someone doesn't fit in, and OCD gives a fixed pathway to follow. I think anorexia and gender dysphoria in teenage girls are practically the same thing: same triggers, same underlying causes, same body hate, and both are ways of preventing the body from feminising and of escaping the daunting prospect of becoming an adult woman. I am strongly opposed to puberty blockers for children, saying they should never, ever be given to stop a healthy puberty, and I have cited Sallie Baxendale's work on puberty blockers possibly lowering IQ. I have repeatedly shared research arguing that the widely quoted 1 percent regret statistic is a lie. I am sceptical of the brain-sex hypothesis and have quoted at length an article arguing that the studies failed to control for cross-sex hormone use and sexual orientation. I have advised people against bottom surgery because of horrendous complication rates, and I have warned about the plastic surgery industry in general preying on people. I have told people to get off social media, to seek therapy for underlying issues rather than transition, to get DEXA scans after anorexia, and to get treatment for anxiety disorders, OCD and PTSD. I have also advised someone to stop looking at the detrans tag on Tumblr because there is no way it is good for them. I have been open about my own history: I had very bad sex dysphoria, I was bullied, I had anorexia, I am autistic, and I had doctors and therapists between 18 and 21 who knew that gender dysphoria in teens is largely transient — I consider myself lucky in that regard. I do not describe any medical transition of my own: I never mention taking hormones or having surgery, and my account is of desisting/recovering from dysphoria rather than of detransitioning after medical intervention. I currently identify as a woman and I am comfortable with that.