Alle verhalen

Dysforie wortelen in trauma, niet in een vrouwelijke identiteit

Man · Gedesisteerd118
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde of nooit helemaal getransitioneerde man die zich als autogynefiel identificeert en gelooft dat mijn genderdysforie voortkomt uit jeugdtrauma en een fetisj en niet uit een vrouwelijke identiteit. Ik heb niet beschreven dat ik hormonen of operaties heb ondergaan, maar ik ben van plan me androgyner te presenteren in plaats van te transitioneren, en zeg dat ik altijd terug zou willen naar man zijn. Ik ben zeer kritisch over gendertherapeuten, trans-ideologie en online trans-gemeenschappen, en verzet me tegelijk tegen homofobe gebruikers op de detrans-subreddit. Ik heb therapie, antidepressiva en CGT aanbevolen voor mezelf en anderen met vergelijkbare gevoelens. Ik heb geen formele diagnose, geen specifieke detransitiedatum en geen suïcidale gedachten bekendgemaakt.

Volledig verhaal

I have been active in the r/detrans community since around April 2019, and much of what I have written there is advice I have given to other people questioning their gender — advice that is clearly rooted in my own experience and beliefs about my own situation. I identify as autogynephilic (AGP). I have written plainly, "I am an AGP myself," and "I have no intention to be a female and I would always want to go back being male." I have also said, "I don't really want to be a woman or anything if I woke up as the most attractive women in history I would go back to a slightly more ugly version of myself, so in no way am I trans." At the same time, I have described real distress with my natal sex: "I can't stand living in a female body, I would miss being male." That sentence, together with my repeated references to being male and to AGP, indicates I was born male. Because of that conflict, I have said, "For me transitioning isn't an option, I have to switch back and forth between male and female, so I'm planning on being more androgynous." I have not given explicit ages, dates of first dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgeries for myself, so I cannot build a precise timeline from this transcript. My thinking about my own feelings has been heavily shaped by Blanchard's typology. I distinguish between what I call "homosexual transsexuals" (HSTS), who I believe have a partially feminized brain because of their female sexuality and attraction to masculine men, and autogynephilic transsexuals, whom I regard as males with a fetish. I have linked to research (an NCBI article) arguing that AGP trans women are not women, and I have argued that AGP is not pseudoscience: "autogynephilia is not pseudo science it's a real thing." I have also said that "gender identity is not a thing" and that gender is not a spectrum, citing an Aeon essay against the gender-spectrum idea. I believe my AGP developed out of trauma. I have written that "many of us have had trauma wich causes us to want to turn into our autogynephilic persona" and that trauma doesn't have to be abuse — "children are delicate so they can easily be traumatized, your memory can also be repressed too." I have suggested that AGP creates a female persona built up through sexual reward and used as an escape from one's real self, and I have speculated that "AGP and AAP are types of dissociative disorder, but very complex ones." I have also linked AGP to other mental health conditions: OCD, trauma, BDD, BPD, sexual frustration, DID, anxiety disorders, psychosis, autism, and ADHD, and I have said that treating these comorbidities can diminish dysphoria. I have not described undergoing hormones or surgery myself, but I am clearly concerned about their risks: I have warned that "hrt can cause liver problems and cancer," that "transitioning at 50 is horrible," and that most trans people "attempt suicide after transitioning." I have described GRS in graphic terms as "chopping of your dick and making a hole inside of you" and argued that the result "wouldn't be a functional organ anymore." I have repeatedly urged people to talk to a therapist before irreversible procedures and to explore past abuse as a possible cause of bottom dysphoria. My own mental health picture is partly implied rather than stated directly. I have mentioned depersonalization/derealization in the context of someone else's post, and I have recommended antidepressants, CBT, and psychotherapy for dysphoria and comorbid conditions. I have not disclosed a formal diagnosis for myself. On sexuality and relationships, I have commented on others' situations — for example, telling someone their boyfriend "needs to accept that he is in a gay relationship" — but I have not described my own relationships or sexual orientation directly, other than through the AGP framework I apply to myself. I have not described a formal detransition event for myself, though I posted asking "Any Autogynephilic detransitioners here?" and I have said "I would always want to go back being male," which suggests I have either transitioned or considered it and want to reverse course. I have also said I plan to be "more androgynous" rather than fully transition or fully detransition. I am critical of gender ideology and of gender therapists, whom I have called "full of BS pseudoscience and a waste of money." I have called r/egg_irl "an actual cult." I have also tried to get another user banned from r/detrans for what I described as homophobic and offensive comments targeting the LGBTQ+ community — showing that while I am critical of trans ideology, I also push back against overtly homophobic speech in the community. I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond these Reddit posts. Overall, I would say my regret is not about specific medical procedures I have undergone (I have not described any), but about the whole framework of my dysphoria — I see it as a trauma-driven fetish rather than a genuine identity, and I want to reconcile myself to being male while acknowledging that I "can't stand living in a female body."