Alle verhalen

Twee jaar non-binair, en dan opnieuw leren man te zijn

Man · Gedesisteerd137
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde homoseksuele man in de twintig die zich ongeveer twee jaar publiekelijk als non-binair identificeerde voordat ik in het voorjaar van 2025 besloot te desisteren en te accepteren dat ik man ben, al ben ik nooit medisch getransitioneerd. Mijn beweging richting transitie werd gedreven door een afwezige vader, narcistisch misbruik door mijn moeder, autisme en maskeren, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en de wens om aan mannelijkheid te ontsnappen in plaats van een echte wens om vrouw te zijn. Sinds ik desisteerde heb ik moeite mezelf in de spiegel als man te zien en te accepteren dat ik een homoseksuele man ben, al hielpen kleine momenten zoals „bro” genoemd worden op werk, en ik ben weer kleding gaan dragen die meer naar masculien neigt. Medio 2025 was ik actief op zoek naar een therapeut en een detrans-gemeenschap specifiek voor mannen. Ik blijf kritisch over transitie voor mezelf, terwijl mijn trans vrienden me nog steeds dierbaar zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I'm in my twenties, born male, and I spent about two years publicly identifying as nonbinary with the hope of eventually transitioning to female. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — but I socially identified as nonbinary from roughly two and a half years before my first post here until I decided to desist in the spring of 2025. What led me toward transition was a tangle of unresolved issues. I had an absentee father and was narcissistically abused by my mother, and I felt that being a woman would make me more worthy of protection. I'm autistic, and I measured my self-worth on how typical I could be and how well I could mask. I also felt that transition could fix my homosexuality — I'm attracted to men, and I realized later that I didn't so much want to be female as escape being male and the feeling of being inadequate as a male. I was also deeply uncomfortable with how the women around me had been treated by men — misogyny, objectification, sexual abuse — and wanted to escape being considered part of that group. I've always abhorred those things and felt that 'not all men' was technically true but a cop-out. In April 2025 I posted that I wanted to desist and learn to accept my sex but also really, really didn't. I described male spaces as feeling like 'a gazelle in the middle of a den of lions,' and said that being called man, mister, sir, or he/him felt like constantly performing full man-ness. I noted I'm not especially feminine but am perceived as at least a little effeminate because of my autism and hobbies; I don't drink, have a naturally high and soft voice, and tend to be quiet and cerebral. I felt I wasn't feminine enough to be seen as a woman even if I transitioned, but not masculine enough to be considered a man as I already was. I also worried that transition would require years of hormones and dangerous, irreversible surgeries to shoehorn female features onto a male body, and that my height (tall even by male standards), angular jaw, and large feet would always read as masculine. Based on my feelings and commenters' input, I decided to desist around early May 2025. I took a 'soft desisting' approach — going back to male pronouns without drawing attention to it, and explaining my situation only if asked. Nobody has asked yet. I was fortunate to have a gender-neutral name from birth, so I never had to change it, though in most online communities I still used she/her and they/them because I wasn't comfortable being a 'he' yet. Part of my desistance, which my parent insisted on, was getting a haircut — it had been medium-length and is now short — and letting a little stubble grow in. It really sucked; I'd been putting it off, and my profile looks distinctly more masculine already. A few people called me handsome, which I rarely heard before, and while I appreciated the intention I don't like the term at all — I want to be beautiful in the way people describe women as beautiful. I still envied women, especially straight ones, and found it disheartening that nobody really saw me as anything but male after years of trying to move as far away from maleness as possible. Sexuality has been a major struggle. I had a crush on a guy in my sophomore year of high school, which is when I realized I was gay. I tried very hard to force myself to be attracted to women but it never worked. My sex drive has never been high; I initially thought I was a late bloomer and gave it a year, then another, then another. I've concluded I'm same-sex attracted. I thought I was asexual for a while too, and even had my testosterone levels checked — they came back pretty much in the middle of the male range, which disappointed me at the time because I was identifying as nonbinary. Despite being accepting of gay friends and family (a sibling is bisexual, several relatives are gay), the possibility of being a gay male viscerally sickens me. I think part of it is that I never identified with tired gay archetypes, and part is my autistic brain wanting to be as 'normal' as possible, hoping that being a straight woman instead of a gay man would fix that. I also think identifying as nonbinary made my biological maleness feel better — it seemed to exempt me from the homophobic and autism-phobic male social hierarchy without invalidating my attraction to men. After desisting I struggled to see a man, boy, or male in the mirror — not in an 'I don't feel male' way, but I couldn't fully perceive myself as male. I acknowledged I'm biologically male, which was more than I could have said two and a half years earlier, but couldn't really internalize it. I was trying to find a good therapist. I also noted that the non-masculinity neurodivergent males like me show is quite different from actual femininity, which helped explain why I felt comfortable in a nonbinary identity rather than going full send toward transition. Things did improve a bit. In early June 2025 at work, a delivery guy and I lifted a heavy pallet of metal sheets together, and he said 'thanks, bro' — and while I normally hate male terms of address, this time it felt oddly okay. It reminded me that not everything about being male has to involve toxicity or anxiety. I'd also started wearing masculine-leaning clothes again rather than only unisex or oversized sweatshirts, finding a few outfits I liked that actually fit my body type. I went to Pride events in my city for the last couple of years, and 2025 was the first Pride Month where I'd be presenting as a 'gay man' rather than nonbinary. Being autistic, a teetotaler, and not into party or hookup culture made it isolating. I felt modern Pride had become too overtly sexualized and perpetuated harmful stereotypes I didn't want to be connected to; what I really wanted was a safe gathering celebrating LGBT history and the fight for rights. I looked for detrans/desist forums or Discord servers specifically for men, since most male-only spaces are homophobic or misogynistic alpha-male echo chambers. I found a Discord link but it had expired; I was still trying to get in as of mid-June 2025. I haven't done any advocacy or activism. I love and care about my trans friends, but I believe transition isn't something I can do with any chance of success. I'm gay, autistic, and currently desisted, still working on accepting myself as male.