Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw: als vrouw geboren identificeerde ik me ongeveer twee jaar als trans maar nam nooit testosteron of onderging operaties, en ik leef nu als onbeschaamde tomboy. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door autisme, een narcistische moeder, pesten omdat ik gendernonconformistisch was, en Latijns-Amerikaans seksisme waardoor ik me een mislukte vrouw voelde; ik desisteerde nadat ik besefte dat de trans-gemeenschap hetzelfde seksisme reproduceerde. Ik heb een autismediagnose en complexe PTSS (eerder verkeerd gediagnosticeerd als schizoïde), en ik beheers premenstruele dysfore stoornis, die ooit constante suïcidale gedachten bracht, met gecombineerde anticonceptie. Ik ervaar nog dysforie maar kom ermee om door werkelijkheidsverankering, feministisch herkaderen en vriendschappen met andere mannelijke vrouwen. Ik ben biseksueel, getrouwd met een man, werk als kunstenaar en geloof nu dat er geen 'echte trans' bestaat, terwijl ik me verzet tegen transitie zoals die wordt aangeprezen, hoewel ik de lichamelijke autonomie van volwassenen accepteer.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in Latin America, in a family that constantly told me I was unladylike and failing at being a woman because I was a tomboy. I hated having a uterus because it bled, hurt, and was a sensory nightmare for me. I thought that if I were a man, the problem of being a 'failed woman' would be fixed. I identified as trans for about two years — I never took testosterone, though I sought it out and researched it intensely, and I never had any surgeries, though I researched those too when I was planning to eventually get them.
Several things disillusioned me. First, I was diagnosed autistic, and reading a book about autism in women made me realize how much of my discomfort was about not understanding gender roles as made-up social rules. Second, my mother was a covert narcissist — a professional psychologist who used therapy-speak and feminist points to justify awful behavior — while my father was functional and loving; this gave me a terrible first reference for what being female means. Third, I was bullied and ostracized by female peers for being gender-nonconforming, and pressured by family, peers, and teachers to conform, which made me resent femininity and by extension femaleness. I was a classic bisexual tomboy-to-trans case.
Inside the trans community I noticed that trans women talked over trans men, dictated what was acceptable, and treated female trans people as props; this emulated the very sexism I was trying to escape. A turning point was reading an essay by a female detransitioner at newthoughtcrime.com that put into words what I'd felt. I also had several friendships with autogynephilic males that ended badly — one admitted his urges started from watching shemale porn as a child, another posted vague tweets calling me a TERF after I sent him a single paper about surgical complications. Being called a TERF for the first time was an epiphany: once it happened, I had nothing left to lose and it freed me to speak plainly.
I also struggled with premenstrual dysphoric disorder — crippling PMS with constant suicidal ideation, severe insomnia, and ravenous hunger for two weeks of every month — which made me hate my uterus. I found out about PMDD in this very subreddit from another detrans woman, and starting drospirenone-ethinylestradiol combined birth control flipped my life around; I can skip the placebo pills and halt my period entirely. That contraception is how I manage PMDD still.
On mental health: I am diagnosed autistic and with complex PTSD; before that I was misdiagnosed with schizoid personality disorder because I masked my repetitive behaviors and special interests, so the psychiatrist only saw my detachment. I was never diagnosed with BPD. I still experience gender dysphoria and dysphoric feelings, but I've developed coping mechanisms: reality-grounding rationalization, distraction, physical grounding activities, feminist affirmations about function over form, and letting the feelings wash over me while reminding myself they're temporary. I describe handling dysphoria pangs as similar to handling addiction cravings.
I became a feminist — not a radical feminist — because it gave me language to redirect my anger at society rather than at my body. Reading that women survive famine better than men helped me reconceptualize femaleness as neutral rather than inferior. I deliberately seek out tomboy role models, art of butch women, and friendships with masculine women; those connections 'saved my life.'
I am bisexual and butchy. I've been in a long-term relationship with a man for years — he's a wonderful man — and I am married to him (same-sex marriage is not legal in my country, so our marriage would not be recognized at home). I have close friendships with men built on shared interests. I work as an artist selling art at geek conventions in Latin America, and I've said that being a desisted artist trying to make money is extremely stressful because I fear saying something that will cost me my livelihood.
I do not call myself a radical feminist. I consider myself a feminist but not radical, and I've said I don't click with everything radical feminists say. I have no interest in female separatism. I now believe there is no 'true trans' — that gender dysphoria is real in the way anorexia or body integrity disorder is real, a delusion to be treated in the mind, not the body. I am opposed to how transition is marketed as life-saving and to medical transition for anyone, though I hold that adults have bodily autonomy and can choose harmful things like alcohol or cigarettes. I advocate informally by posting extensively in detrans spaces, encouraging questioning people to deconstruct their reasons, recommending breast reduction over mastectomy for sensory issues, and being a visible unashamed tomboy as a role model for 'baby tomboys.'
I have a physical health condition — pectus excavatum, spotted in childhood — that I was told was purely cosmetic; I felt my heart and chest hurt during PE as a child and teenager, and doctors sporadically ask if I have a heart murmur. I recently decided to book an orthopaedist appointment because of a post here.