Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde homoseksuele man die op zijn 29e uit de kast kwam, ongeveer twee jaar als vrouw leefde en 15 maanden spironolacton, finasteride en daarna oestrogeeninjecties gebruikte voordat ik in 2020 mijn tweede poging tot detransitie begon. Ik ben getransitioneerd op zoek naar erbij horen en identiteit na een traumatische, gewelddadige opvoeding zonder positief mannelijk rolmodel, verergerd door een borderline persoonlijkheidsstoornis, PTSS, bipolaire stoornis type 1 en hersenletsel dat door oestrogeen en antiandrogenen zo verslechterde dat ik een wandelstok of rollator nodig had. Ik ben gedetransitioneerd omdat de hormonen mijn gezondheid schaadden, ik ongelukkig was met mijn uiterlijk, in angst leefde als transvrouw die niet doorging voor vrouw, en omdat ik besefte dat mijn probleem lag bij hoe ik ben opgevoed en niet bij man zijn. Nu identificeer ik me als man, al voelt „man” nog wat vreemd, en ik was van plan onder medisch toezicht af te bouwen met oestrogeen terwijl ik therapie zocht. Ik steun geïnformeerde toestemming in principe, maar vind dat cross-sekse hormonen veel serieuzer genomen moeten worden.
Volledig verhaal
I came out at 29 and started hormones in December 2018, identifying as a trans woman. I was on spironolactone for 11 months before switching to finasteride — my first attempt at detransition was in November 2019 — and then I switched to estrogen injections in February 2020 at 5 mg. I presented female for about two years. I planned an orchiectomy twice but it never happened, and I planned female voice feminization but that never happened either. I am now detransitioning, on my second attempt, and I feel a lot more mentally stable than last time. I now identify as male, although calling myself a man still feels a bit odd.
I did not transition because of autogynephilia — I'm gay and attracted to men, and I find the concept of autogynephilia deeply insulting. I've lived my entire life around women, have deep respect for them, and relate to women more than men. I had an extremely traumatic life with no positive male role model: my father was physically abusive, and my mother was abusive emotionally as well as sexually. I grew up absolutely hating myself in every possible way. As a young adult I had literally no confidence, and I only discovered I was gay at 26 after years of trying to date women and a lot of confusion and heartbreak. Despite my mom's abuse I've always been very close to women, though I am not and have never really been feminine. I think I transitioned because I wanted a sense of belonging and identity — something I never had. I also didn't hate being male; I hated how I was raised and the roles I was forced into, which were rigid and traditional, and as a gay person it was very confusing, especially being told my whole life I was supposed to be interested in women when I'm not.
At the time, transitioning didn't feel like a choice — it felt like something I had to do to become myself. But there were key factors I ignored: I have borderline personality disorder, PTSD, and bipolar type 1. The combination of the three created a very unstable scenario, and I was personally not mentally stable at the time. I chose to detransition because I became aware that the antiandrogens and estrogen were making my brain injury far worse — I was literally at the point where I could not walk without a cane or walker. I was also not happy with how I looked or how I had transitioned. On top of that, being a trans woman is not easy; it's brutal, especially coming out later in life and not passing. I had grown very scared for my life and become a shut-in. All of this, plus realizing I never had a problem being a man but rather with the person I was raised as, made me decide to detransition.
I haven't gone off estrogen yet as of early March 2020, but I was discussing it with my doctor that week and planned to start. I'd been on estrogen for 15 months and my body was accustomed to it, so coming off was expected to take 4–6 months as I needed to get my testosterone levels up so stopping estrogen wouldn't throw my body out of whack. I also smoked while on hormones despite being told to quit; I kept smoking until I started having major chest pains and was terrified for a week that I had a blood clot in my lungs. I didn't, but it was a serious scare. I think one problem with trans culture is not taking cross-sex hormones seriously — I don't have a problem with informed consent, but people need to treat these hormones with gravity because they affect everything in your body and have serious side effects like deep vein thrombosis.
I was doing okay and looking into getting professional help — something I really should have pursued before fully plunging into medically transitioning, though hindsight is 50-50. I wasn't sure where to look for that help yet. I was about to turn 31. I planned to start working out, including weight lifting, since I'd heard it helps with increasing testosterone. I also helped spread the word about a small Discord server for detransitioning men. I don't see anything wrong with transitioning in principle — some people are legitimately trans — but it's dicey when someone can go in via informed consent and doctors and therapists won't challenge you, or people don't follow doctor's advice.