Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik transitioneerde, onderging een keyhole-borstoperatie en identificeer me nu weer als man; ik geniet van man zijn en zie mijn transitie als een slechte beslissing. De transidentiteit loslaten was eerst pijnlijk, maar werd gevolgd door intense opluchting dat ik geen 'freak' meer hoefde te zijn. Ik blijf actief in de detrans-gemeenschap, waar ik anderen steun die detransitie overwegen, terwijl ik kritische opvattingen uit over vroege transitie, transbians, pornografie en transactivisme. Sinds mijn detransitie heb ik geen genoemde suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.
Volledig verhaal
I transitioned and lived as a trans woman for a period of my life, but I now enjoy being a man and consider the whole thing a bad decision. I had keyhole surgery on my chest at some point while transitioning; my pictures are still in the detrans subreddit somewhere. The surgery went well, though my nipples are still slightly larger than they were before HRT. Removing more skin would cost another $6,000 and require going back under the knife, so I haven't done it. I say I look like any other guy who has larger areolas — all the breast tissue and fat is gone and you cannot see the scars. I also noted that one benefit of going back as MTF is that you typically don't have more than an A cup, so keyhole surgery remains a possibility unless you have implants.
On letting go of the trans identity, I told someone else going through it that at first it felt like tearing something away from me, like I was tearing my "future" up, and that it was painful for a few months. But shortly after that I felt intense relief. I described it as: "I don't have to be a freak anymore! I can be who I was born to be. I can revel in my natural characteristics instead of fighting them." I framed detransition as the pathway to a good, happy and powerful life instead of a life of bullshit, hardship, anxiety and fear, and I told the person I was replying to that I thought they would feel that relief too.
I have strong opinions about the culture around transition. I argued that the feeling of being trans is subjective and that for some people it describes them at a point and then later they no longer have the same feelings — I pushed back when someone claimed otherwise, saying that isn't true for most detransitioners. I defended the detrans subreddit for being transparent, saying that even if there wasn't a single troll on it, the "crazy trans subs" would still screech about everyone being TERFs. I was skeptical of claims about the sub being infiltrated, and I questioned whether someone arguing against detransitioners was actually a detransitioner or an outside actor, saying the services in question help trans people who desperately need them and that not everyone will regret transition.
I'm critical of early and youth transition. I argued that transitioning young before 18 does not at all mean you will pass — it only increases the chances. I cited Kim Petras, who I said started puberty blockers around 10, as someone who does not look like a cis woman, pointing to her head, facial planes, arms and shoulders. I also referenced teen transitioners featured on the Jazz Jennings show who I felt were clearly never going to pass despite starting at 12, 13 or 14. I noted there are sex differences in skull shape starting in toddler years, namely the cranium, and said people don't accept these things because it's easier to think "if I do this at this age I will be rewarded this way," which fuels the panic and rush that consumes early transitioners. I described older transitioners as consumed by their fantasy, projecting, craving attention, and offering terrible advice to younger transitioners.
I hold critical views of transbians and of trans people generally. I called transbians "always cringe" and told someone their friend is not a woman but "a spazzy effeminate straight guy" with a beta orbiter who doesn't feel like one because he's framed as a woman. I said transbians are almost always simps. I also said lots of trans people love to fuck each other and fetishize each other. On pornography I'm clear: "The porn is problematic. You should avoid porn."
I have views on masculinity and told someone I thought they had a flawed perspective on what being a man is — that they seemed to crave a world where people value submission and passivity, which isn't the real world. I said we evolved from apes, not their fantasy of pleasure and worship of passive characteristics that are easy to display to others ("nice," "nonthreatening," "passive"), and that people want to be entertained and impressed. I also said adults have to take responsibility for their actions.
On family conflict I'm skeptical of framing it in political or racial terms. Discussing a post about an estranged family, I said leftists call everything white supremacist these days and to take it with a grain of salt, describing it as a dysfunctional family that can't get along with anyone with a different opinion, where the sibling cut the dad off and then claimed to be cut off. I said to stop cutting everyone off and communicate. I acknowledged I know multiple huge asshole chauvinists who ruin relationships with their LGBT kids, but said it's hard to know what's going on without details and that "white supremacist" muddies the water since we're talking about LGBT issues, not race. I also said the sibling in that post sounded more of a nutcase than the typical alt-righter, contrasting neo pronouns and furry porn against church. I told someone their family situation was sad but that at least they have a negative example to guard their own children against.
I'm also critical of people I see as capitulating to trans activists. I said I don't care that they were cowards who couldn't stand up to trans activists, that it shows the weakness of their own movement — they can fight the patriarchy but not a bunch of trans activists, which I called pathetic — and that they should have told all those AGPs to fuck off.