Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man die zich als gedetransitioneerd beschouwt, nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, maar jarenlang wenste een vrouw te zijn, tot ik halverwege mijn twintig bewust voor mijn mannelijkheid koos. Ik zie mijn gevoelens nu als voortkomend uit zelfhaat, het gevoel als man te hebben gefaald, eenzaamheid en door porno beïnvloede fetisjisme, en niet uit echte dysforie. Het gaat nu redelijk goed met me, ik heb een vriendin, en ik heb alleen spijt van de jaren die ik verloren heb door in mijn hoofd te leven. Ik sta kritisch tegenover de huidige transbeweging, vooral tegenover transitie bij jongeren en het versnellen van trajecten, en ik deel regelmatig mijn kijk online met mensen die twijfelen aan hun gender. Ik doe niet aan formeel activisme en heb geen geschiedenis van zelfbeschadiging of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I'm a man who used to wish I were a woman, and I want to share how I got out of that mindset in case it helps anyone reading.
For years I was stuck in my own head, constantly thinking and agonizing. I hated myself and wished I were a girl, and I felt like I had failed as a man — that I had let down mankind and would be better off as a woman. I now realize that thinking was arrogant and ignorant; it treated womanhood as an escape from responsibility. A lot of what fed those feelings came from porn, podcasts, and mainstream media. When I was going through the worst of it, the modern trans phenomenon hadn't really happened yet, so I had very little reinforcement of the idea other than porn itself — and only a madman would make life decisions based on that.
What changed things for me was a deliberate decision. I decided that I not only wanted to be a man, but that I actually was a man, and that being a man was fine — good, even. Masculinity is good. It's O.K. to have hair on my knuckles and greater upper-body strength. So I leaned into it. I let myself be a man and I made myself be a man: I worked out, I enjoyed time with my male friends, I looked at women as women and myself as a man in relation to them. I'm taller than most women, stronger, broader-shouldered. I have inherent characteristics they will never match. I AM a man, and that's a good thing.
I also came to see that if I had transitioned I would have been, at best, a somewhat cute homosexual or bisexual man — whereas I'm actually heterosexual and now have a girlfriend. Rather than not wanting to be masculine, my problem was feeling I had failed my masculinity. It took until my mid-twenties before I ever really appreciated being a man.
I'm skeptical that people are genuinely in the wrong body. I think a lot of what gets called gender dysphoria is 'grass is greener' syndrome, dissatisfaction with life, lack of accomplishments or prospects, too much time spent comparing oneself to idealized versions of other people's lives, trauma, or a sexual fetish. Every time I think about what I would do as a woman, I realize it largely revolves around sex — it's a sexual fetish for the most part, and it's insidious because it tries to tell you it's more. You feel like you 'belong' to that world, yet you know nothing about it. From my DNA to my skin, I am male. I may as well wish I were a willow tree.
I don't think I was ever legitimately in the wrong body. I think I had real problems — depression, dissatisfaction, feeling like something was 'missing' — but they had nothing to do with my sex. I used to think that if I were a girl I'd be a proper girl, but as a guy I was just worthless; the truth is I'd almost certainly have been worthless as a girl too. It wasn't my sex that held me back, it was just plain old me. Your problems will be your problems whether they fall upon your chest or your breast.
I don't have a formal detransition timeline because I never medically transitioned — I never took hormones or had surgery. My 'detransition' was purely psychological: choosing to stop wishing I were a woman and instead embracing masculinity. I don't describe myself as having been dysphoric in a clinical sense; I'd characterize what I felt as a mix of self-hatred, failure, loneliness, and fetishistic ideation rather than being in the wrong body.
I'm critical of the current trans movement. I worry about over-diagnosis and fast-tracking, and I'm afraid to say anything negative about it even in detrans spaces for fear of being banned for 'hate-speech.' I think there's a push for it happening right now, and a record number of people 'chopping off their genitals' and reporting this kind of dysphoria is not normal or a coincidence. I'm also skeptical about children transitioning — I don't think parents should let an eleven-year-old take the lead on something like that, just as you wouldn't let a child amputate limbs, jump into a lake without knowing how to swim, or play with loaded guns.
On gender differences generally, I believe men and women are genuinely different — physically and behaviorally — and that this isn't merely socially constructed. I think equating men and women and pretending they're exactly the same confuses everyone: men think they're big, stupid, ugly brutes that women hate, and women think they're weak, worthless children who will never match up to men. I also think it's narcissistic and presumptuous to assume the other gender has it easier and that life would be better if you'd been born the other sex.
I don't have any formal advocacy or activism, but I do engage in these discussions online, offering my perspective to people questioning gender, and I made a YouTube video reading the first chapter of the first Warrior Cats book (my introduction to the series, which I'd missed as a kid — I was more of an Animorphs and Babysitters Club reader).
Overall I'd say I'm relatively well-adjusted now. I have a girlfriend, male friendships I enjoy, and a settled sense of who I am. I don't carry intense regret because I never acted on the wish to transition, but I do regret the years spent living in my head, pining for an existence that wasn't mine instead of making the most of the one I had. That regret has faded as I've gotten older and grown into appreciating my masculinity.