Alle verhalen

Geen hormonen, geen operaties: een sociale detransitie terug naar het geloof

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd970
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die nooit hormonen heeft genomen of een operatie heeft gehad. Via een geleidelijk proces van aanvaarden wat ik nu als waarheid zie, ben ik teruggekeerd naar mijn natuurlijke lichaam en naar de islam. In mijn atheïstische jaren had ik suïcidale depressies, die ik toeschrijf aan ‘mezelf blind maken voor de waarheid’, en die verdwenen toen ik weer tot het geloof kwam. Nu ben ik sterk kritisch over transitie, genderbevestigende zorg en de LGBT-beweging, en ik omschrijf spijt over transitie als catastrofaal en onomkeerbaar. Ik definieer vrouw en man strikt als vrouwelijke en mannelijke mensen en zie de transbeweging als een verwarring tussen persoonlijkheid en gender. Sinds mijn detransitie heb ik geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female. My path out of identifying as trans was gradual, and I describe my return to religion as a very gradual process that mirrored my desisting — 'It all came down to an acceptance of truth.' I never took hormones: I have said explicitly, 'If you fortunately never did hrt (like me), then you have it physically easier but left with mentally accepting your natural biology.' So my detransition was primarily social and psychological rather than surgical or endocrine. During my questioning years I was online heavily. Looking back, I wish someone had told me: 'if you think a passing internet opinion that has brought the trans question to your head means you should transition, then you need to quit the internet for a while. Literally. Just stay off this toxic machine. If only I had someone to tell me that when I was questioning.' I now advise minors in the same position to tell a trusting adult and to 'protect yourself from mind pollution.' I also think the trans movement is largely 'a confusion between personality and gender,' and that people who were 'fairly androgynous and carefree' get misled into thinking that makes them trans, because the movement pushes the idea that any questioning at all means you are trans. I experienced suicidal depression during my atheist years. I describe 'a pollution or heaviness in my chest' that I had assumed was just a physiological symptom of that depression, but which I later attributed to 'the slow accumulation of blinding myself to truth' — a blindedness that extended well beyond gender to God and other matters. I say that if I have had any supernatural experience, it was 'the feeling of my chest literally loosening up on the day I admitted this blindedness.' I am Muslim. My reconversion had several milestones: reading a biography of the Prophet Muhammad written by a Romanian priest, where the chapter on the revelation of Surah Ad-Dhuha gave me 'a thick blanket of empathy' for him; reading 'Road to Mecca' by Muhammad Asad; and reading the Qur'an in Arabic alongside translation, with Muhammad Asad's translation my favorite. I have 'a decent elementary knowledge of Arabic' and find its eloquence unmatched. I love Jesus as the son of the Virgin Mary but see him as a beloved prophet. I have not had any 'supernatural' experiences in the conventional sense, but I believe anyone can be in direct contact with God, though not in the way humans interact with each other and not through an intercessor. I hold strongly critical views of transition and of the broader LGBT movement. I have written that 'We detransition to become our original selves since the new body is artificial. We don't become male or female with transitioning. It just screws up our biology and you're basically a perpetual hrt patient.' I believe the best and truest thing to do is to return to the body you were naturally born with and undo changes as best you can. I define woman and man strictly as female and male human beings, comparing them to hen and rooster, bull and cow, and I dismiss the intersex argument as 'a miniscule minority' that is 'basically just a genetic error.' I argue gender is not a social construct but gender roles are, and that what people call gender confusion is really confusion between personality and gender roles. My feelings about the LGBT world are intensely negative. I have written: 'Anything related to lgbt makes me queasy now. Sorry not sorry, that's just how disgusted I am at this point.' I also wrote, 'I feel disgusted, ashamed, and dirty when I see them. It gets better... hopefully.' I believe the whole trans phenomenon is driven by a hyper-sexualized society reacting against millennia of sexual deprivation and by money, and I am skeptical of claims that LGBT people existed openly since antiquity. I have called the phenomenon 'gender cult, gender fascism, gender circlejerk' and described the whole trans thing as 'completely fake and attention-whorey.' I see gender affirmation therapy as harmful — 'Why should a therapist affirm your illness? They want you to be ill so you can be a perpetual patient to doctors and pharmaceutical companies' — and I criticize the claim that failing to give a child HRT will lead to suicide as a pharmaceutical talking point aimed at skeptical parents. On regret, I have described transition regret as 'A catastrophic, irreversible, insurmountable regret, but the regret rate is still too low for these numbskulls to reason with.' Because I never took hormones, my own physical situation is easier, but I frame detransition as accepting a mistake by regressing back to your default self. I believe being a woman is easier for me 'because that's what my biology dictates,' and that detransition means accepting your natural biology even though 'being a woman or a man doesn't matter.' I am wary of medical gatekeeping failures elsewhere too: when another poster described a suspected testosterone issue, I urged them repeatedly to see an endocrinologist and said 'I might even sue somebody,' suspecting 'that fishy T made things worse.' I have not described undergoing therapy myself, nor specific surgeries, nor fertility concerns of my own. I have not described family reactions or relationship status. I have not described any activism beyond participating in this community and expressing a hope to write longer, more objective posts reaching non-detrans people — I said I was 'working on my writing skills and hopefully I will post things in the near future.' I want content 'so well-written that even trans and never-trans people can relate to it and understand where we detrans people are coming from,' and I dislike motivational-poster style content that gives off 'circle-jerky vibes with non-detrans people.'